gravethebeyond
Best pastries in the whole country! Delicious Merry-Go-Round cake I had for my birthday a few years back! I 100% recommend Capri bakery! When they say new York pastries and baked goods are the best! This is 1000% percent the place to go! The prices are worth the quality of taste! Don’t believe me, then go see and taste for yourself! A place you won’t, forget about it! Ooooh!
… moreVanessa H
I love this bakery! The workers and owners are very nice. Jessica recommended me a few items and every single one was a hit! The sourdough is delicious and the cannolis are a must have. I must also say their rainbow cookies are probably the best I’ve tried on the island. You really can’t go wrong with anything Capri makes. Consider me a regular now!
… moreJohnny Marte
I stopped by Capri Bakery in Seaford to pick up a chocolate birthday cake, and it was absolutely amazing — rich, fresh, and so delicious. I also grabbed two cannoli treats for my kids, and they loved them.
The bakery itself is super clean and inviting, and the quality of everything I tried was top-notch. Rachel took care of me during my visit, and she was incredibly friendly, accommodating, and professional. She made the whole experience even better.
Highly recommend Capri Bakery — I’ll definitely be coming back!
… moreKulinary Mafia
One of the best bakeries on Long Island. Everything is made fresh on that day. With so many fresh pastries to choose from, If you’re not careful it can get a little expensive, Worth every penny you spend though. You can call ahead and place an order too. #kulinarymafia approved
… moreJoanne Gonzalez
I had a wonderful experience at this bakery recently! Was in town for my grandmas 95th birthday decided to order some cookies and pies. My grandma loved rainbow cookies those are her favorite. The food was absolutely delicious, and Rachel went above and beyond to make sure I had everything I needed. Her friendly service made my visit even better. I’ll definitely be coming back!
… moreIrene Metaxas
Stopped in for the first time after driving by, and I’m so glad I did. The bakery has that old-school Italian aroma and charm I grew up with in Queens. I went in for canolis, which are filled fresh on the spot! . . . and ended up buying their personal rainbow cookies as well! Absolutely delicious!!! My kids were raving about it. Christy was so sweet and patient while I made my choices. I’ll definitely be back!
… moreChristina Spero
Outstanding Customer Service from Rachel!
I just have to share how amazing Rachel is at Capri Bakery. Every time I walk in, she greets me with genuine warmth and a smile that instantly brightens the whole place. She’s incredibly attentive, patient, and always goes above and beyond to make sure I get exactly what I need—even when it’s busy.
Rachel’s professionalism and kindness truly stand out. It’s rare to find someone who consistently delivers such exceptional service, and she makes every visit feel special. Capri Bakery is lucky to have her, and I’ll definitely be returning because of the wonderful experience she creates.
Highly recommend stopping by—and if Rachel helps you, you’ll see exactly what I mean!
… moreJacob Nauth
Ahhh Capri Bakery, where do I start? It’s a magical and heavenly place to get your delicious sweet treats. From fresh cakes to cookies, the options here are limitless. The ambience is very welcoming and the store is kept very clean and tidy ! The staff and owners are courteous, professional and very welcoming. Tell them what you need and they’ll get it done for you!
My experiences here have always been pleasant and I have no hesitation in recommending Capri Bakery to my fellow customers. Well earned five stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. I wish I could give more :).
Make sure to stop by when you’re on Long Island in the Seaford/Wantagh area! You won’t regret it!
… moreRachie 1228
Rachel had me try a cake that is said to be their most popular and that’s why I go back. At first bite I was amazed by how good it was. Rachel really pointed me in the right direction. She’s kind and one of their best workers!! If you want good cake you definitely need to try this place and ask for Rachel she’ll give you the best recommendations!!
… moreKathleen Frey
This bakery is the best. My husbands favorite canolis. Another fave is the merry go round cake. All my special occasion cakes come from capri and the breads are the best around. Hailey behind the counter was friendly, helpful and knowledgeable about many of their sweet treats and pricing. The only bakery we visit.
… more