Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Busy, comfortable bistro turning out generous pasta portions & plating thin, pan & stuffed pies.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1026 N Sherman Ave, Madison, WI 53704
Phone: (608) 243-1200
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Roo’s Kitchen moves into former Cafe La Bellitalia | MADISON …
The business is taking shape at 1026 N. Sherman Ave., where Italian restaurant Cafe La Bellitalia closed in fall 2024 after a 19-year run.
Cafe La Bellitalia to close after 19 years on Madison’s north side
r/madisonwi. • 14y ago. Best places to eat in Madison, WI? (The less high-profile the better). 20. 101. Are there any Italian restaurants in …
Cafe La Bellitalia to close after 19 years on Madison’s north side
Cafe La Bellitalia, a homey Italian American restaurant on Madison’s north side, is scheduled to close on Monday, March 10.
Reviews
Laurel Ann
Food and wine were great. Waitstaff friendly and made this first-timer feel very welcome. Only downsides were older, more basic decor and smaller interior. This is a busy place, so while a bit more space would be desirable, might also take away from the cozier, family feel. Definitely returning!
… moreAaron Floyd
Plan ahead or make a reservation as it has been busy on both of my visits (Thursday evening and Saturday evening).I absolutely love this place. Food is absolutely top notch, as is the service. You’re greeted at your table with some garlic bread and oil. Order a glass of wine while you peruse the menu. Their red sauce is made in house, and is incredible. Remember this as you look at the options on the menu. I had the sample on the last visit.which had spaghetti, a delicious meatball and probably the best lasagna I’ve had in my life. Had a taste of the alfredo sauce which was delicious as well. We will be back, and hopefully many times, as this is definitely our favorite Italian restaurant in Madison now!
… moreRita Peters
First time after living in Madison for 4 years. We popped in here for for a last minute dinner. The good overall was delicious, healthy portions and reasonably priced food. I like places like this, it’s easy to over spend in a big city!
… moreNorman Davis
One word: Satisfying. The red sauce so perfectly compliments the pasta. We had the sampler (lasagna and eggplant), veal, chicken, and chicken with sausage ravioli. Great portions and wonderful Italian flavors! We’ll be back soon!
… moreJeff Porter
Great flavors on every dish every time !
Italian salad, pescadora pasta, chicken marsala pasta.
Will miss this place when it closes in March.
Hope another restaurateur will take on and continue.
… moreItalian salad, pescadora pasta, chicken marsala pasta.
Will miss this place when it closes in March.
Hope another restaurateur will take on and continue.
Ben Voeck
This legendary gem is a great place to stop for an old school dine in experience. Here you will find great food done the Sicilian way. Pietro & Josephine, the Italian food masters of the Madison area, should be awarded. MMMMMMMM
… moreMichele Westphall
Fantastic local Italian restaurant.. all from scratch. Going to miss it when they close in March.
Ordered pick up.. everything hot and yummy.
… moreOrdered pick up.. everything hot and yummy.
Hannah Foley
Cafe la Bellitalia, you will be SO missed. Growing up in an Italian-American family, this restaurant provides comfort food to an extent I didn’t realize could happen. The food at CLB unlocks nostalgia every time and I am devastatingly elated for the owners to be retiring. PLEASE go support this amazing restaurant before their last day on 3/10/25. You will be missed ❤️❤️❤️
… moreLance Green
2002 -Warm, wonderful, authentic Italian! 2/25 – Still most amazing, tasty dinners. But we had to wait two hours after we arrived to taste it, even with a “reservation.” So sad they’re closing.
… moreSamuel Fassbender
I have tried every stuffed pizza the greater Madison area has to offer, and this is hands down the best. You wouldn’t think to order the stuffed pizza here with all the other options, but it is worth it. What separates this stuffed pizza from all the rest is there is no grease. It is flavorful, light and fluffy, and dense, but you are not swimming in your meal. You can pick up a slice and hold it without it falling apart. It doesn’t make you feel like crap like most greasy pizzas do. I ordered this twice in less than a weeks time. A new go-to and a must try.
… more