Crystal Dunn
Fantastic experience from start to finish! Quaint spot that was busy, yet we were seated right away. The wait staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming, and even during the lunchtime rush, the owner stopped by our table to check in. The island ambiance added to the charm, creating a relaxed, laid-back vibe that makes you want to stay and enjoy the moment. And the calzone? Absolutely delicious! This place truly delivers! Highly recommend!
… moreIrene Woodson
I decided to take my husband here for lunch as we are celebrating his birthday “week” and doing some Christmas/Birthday shopping in town. It is located in a beautiful historic alleyway, with vines running along stone and brick walls. Really charming. We had the lobster, arugula, truffle, mozzarella pizza and it was absolutely delicious. Jennifer was fantastic; great staff and excellent customer service! We highly recommend Café Amici!
… moreIan Bugbee
Great Italian spot in the heart of Charlotte Amalie.
The location is tucked away off the main drag and the food was quite good. The Lobster and Truffle pizza I would highly recommend, a long with the Lombardy pasta (pictured).
… moreScott Doyle
One of the best Italian restaurants with homemade Marinara sauce. The food was delicious, service was excellent and the atmosphere perfect. Stopped here while on a cruise with port call to St Thomas. Highly recommended. Sat at the bar, had a couple of drinks and ordered food. The bartender was excellent.
… moreCaitlin Creed
This place was down an alley in the Charlotte Amalie area. Attached to the side of a Turkish shop with laps and rugs. We we very hungry and it smelled great. I got a cheese pizza to go.. it was not what I was expecting. Kinda like a Red Baron frozen pizza taste. But fillled us up..
… moreDarcey Sweet
This restaurant is located down the alley in a historic mall. The place is quaint and is lit up for Christmas. The food is fantastic. The stromboli bites is like nothing I ever had before. We loved the calzone, so cheesy!, Steph provided great customer service and was very knowledgeable about the menu. Jen was the bartender and is very personable. She makes a great peachy amici. We will definitely be back.
… moreIsaiah Jackson
Very good italian spot in St. Thomas. In a great alley off of the waterfront with plenty of seating.
Food is really good, especially the pizza. The lobster truffle pizza was so flavorful and delicious as well as the meat lovers!
As with everything on St Thomas, a little pricey but here the price of of one pie was about $20-$30 dollars. Not bad.
… moreAmanda
We’ve been here a few times, and it’s always consistent and not in a good way. Probably the worst Italian food we’ve ever had, every time. Caesar salad was soggy from the dressing even though our server said it was light. The croutons were sooooo hard. I thought my crown was gonna pop off. The sausage and peppers were overly vinegary and salty. The Bologna pasta was oversauced and overcooked. Another soggy mess. We were the only ones dining and I’m guessing the food was leftover from day before or even the day before that. Very bad. Also, they advertise aperol spritz but don’t carry aperol or were out of aperol so we resorted to some knock off? Youve been warned. Photos for context. We won’t even rate the pizza or paninis. Won’t be back.
… moreWendy Silva
Fantastic choice for a quick lunch. We ordered a vegetarian calzone and a prosciutto calzone which were simply delicious. I also ordered a Caprese sandwich with a side pasta. I was not impressed with the sandwich but the pasta salad was out of this world ✌ good drinks too!
… moreBrandon Herrera
The calzone was super delicious, Jennifer was a great server, definitely visit if you go to St Thomas
… more