Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Delivery
… View more
Escape to Butterfish, an intimate Japanese dining experience where Miami cool meets LA chic. Opened December 2024, this hidden gem offers an elevated culinary journey within its twelve-table setting. Indulge in exquisite omakase and savor the freshness of fish and wagyu, flown in daily from Japan. Curated by a Two Michelin Star Chef, Butterfish promises an unforgettable dinner service, Tuesday through Sunday, at 15 Franklin Place, Rutherford.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 15 Franklin Pl, Rutherford, NJ 07070
Phone: (908) 549-2717
Website: https://thebutterfish.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Related Web Results
ButterFish Sushi: HOME
15 Franklin Place, Rutherford, NJ 07070 · [email protected] · 1.973.329.1112. Copyright © 2025 | Butterfish Sushi | Allrights Reserved
BUTTERFISH | Sushi & Omakase NJ (@butterfishsushi) – Instagram
The best sushi spot @butterfishsushi has a new venture @handrollhouse_ with a soft open next Tuesday the 17th Handroll House, 135 Park Ave East Rutherford, …
Book Your Butterfish Reservation Now on Resy
Located in the heart of Rutherford, NJ just off the beaten path of Park … Butterfish is NOT your mom and pop sushi joint. Open exclusively for dinner, …
Reviews
Nay Nay
A very cute small sushi restaurant in NJ. I had the premium omakase. I enjoyed everything but the salmon and burrata maybe if it had a crunch element . It was to one note flat tasting. Not for me. Also the uni wasn’t great. I eat uni almost everyday in the city and this had a rancid taste.
The oysters were amazing super tasty! Also, the rest of the Omakase was nice And fresh.
I would come back again. And the Service five star! All of the staff they are truly wonderful.
… moreThe oysters were amazing super tasty! Also, the rest of the Omakase was nice And fresh.
I would come back again. And the Service five star! All of the staff they are truly wonderful.
Bessie Hu
Had an amazing experience for dinner here! Jojo was an amazing host and explained every dish. Of the shared plates, my favorites are the scallop carpaccio, salmon belly crudo and truffle sashimi. I love their creative takes on these dishes without overpowering the highlight of the dishes which is essentially the fish itself. The quality of the fish used is so fresh as it is imported daily! Of the nigiris, my favorites are the A5 wagyu, toro, uni, scallop, and shrimp.
Overall, the food, service and ambiance were great. I can’t wait to come back again.
… moreOverall, the food, service and ambiance were great. I can’t wait to come back again.
Jenna Azzolini
Butterfish is a stunning hidden gem that balances a beautiful, cozy atmosphere with world-class flavors. We tried the omakase experience titled “The One.” The fish was incredibly fresh, featuring innovative twists that kept every course exciting—though the miso cod appetizer was so spectacular I could have licked the plate clean.
My absolute highlights were the surf and turf hand roll, the melt-in-your-mouth salmon belly hand roll, and the rich tuna toro. We finished the night with a trio of delicious gelatos—pistachio, black sesame, and biscoff—which were the perfect sweet end to the meal.
What truly sets this place apart is the warmth of the owner, Jojo, who makes you feel like family the moment you walk in. Paired with exceptionally attentive service, this was an unforgettable experience. I give Butterfish my highest praise and will be referring everyone I know!
… moreMy absolute highlights were the surf and turf hand roll, the melt-in-your-mouth salmon belly hand roll, and the rich tuna toro. We finished the night with a trio of delicious gelatos—pistachio, black sesame, and biscoff—which were the perfect sweet end to the meal.
What truly sets this place apart is the warmth of the owner, Jojo, who makes you feel like family the moment you walk in. Paired with exceptionally attentive service, this was an unforgettable experience. I give Butterfish my highest praise and will be referring everyone I know!
Jane C.
First time doing omakase so definitely not an expert but for us what a great experience! Such pleasant, friendly service. Went with the chef’s tasting and each course just kept getting better and better. Really appreciate that they were able to modify the tasting to accommodate any dietary restrictions. Really enjoyed celebrating my birthday here. Hope to come back soon. Thanks so much! God Bless 🙂
… moreitzelenaho
Would you expect a Michelin-level sushi experience in Rutherford Jersey? Just minutes from American Dream Mall, Butterfish Sushi delivers exactly that without the tolls, crowds, and chaos of Manhattan. Their Michelin-chef curated menu features omakase-style sushi crafted with premium ingredients flown in daily from Japan. Every piece is thoughtful, precise, and beautifully presented. Butterfish Sushi also stands out with some of the best mocktails around, which you can easily spike since they’re BYOB. From the impeccable service to the refined flavors and intimate setting, every detail feels perfectly dialed in. Whether you’re dining in or taking home their Omakase To-Go for a special holiday meal, Butterfish Sushi sets the bar for Japanese dining in New Jersey.
… moreReyna Nunez
Butterfish delivers luxury in the most effortless way. From the moment you arrive, the energy is refined, intimate, and perfectly curated. The service is polished yet warm, making you feel both indulged and at ease.
The food is unforgettable, beautifully executed, bold in flavor, and meant to be savored. Every dish feels intentional, elevated, and indulgent without trying too hard.
A special thank you to Danny, whose impeccable service, attentiveness, and grace elevated the entire evening, and to Jojo, the General Manager, for running such a seamless, world-class operation. It shows in every detail.
Butterfish isn’t just a place to dine, it’s a destination. If you appreciate exceptional cuisine, elevated ambiance, and true hospitality, this is where you belong.
… moreThe food is unforgettable, beautifully executed, bold in flavor, and meant to be savored. Every dish feels intentional, elevated, and indulgent without trying too hard.
A special thank you to Danny, whose impeccable service, attentiveness, and grace elevated the entire evening, and to Jojo, the General Manager, for running such a seamless, world-class operation. It shows in every detail.
Butterfish isn’t just a place to dine, it’s a destination. If you appreciate exceptional cuisine, elevated ambiance, and true hospitality, this is where you belong.
Camille Villavicencio
Butterfish is truly one of those rare gems that makes you feel so grateful you discovered it. From the moment I walked in, the entire experience was nothing short of exceptional. The food and service were absolutely top notch genuinely some of the best I’ve had in a long time.
You can immediately tell the quality is on another level. Their fish is incredibly fresh and thoughtfully sourced, even shipped straight from Japan, and it really shows. Every dish was outstanding the product truly speaks for itself.
What made the experience even more special was the service. The staff were so warm, thoughtful, and knowledgeable, with amazing storytelling around each dish that made the whole meal feel immersive and intentional.
And a huge shoutout to the owner, Jojo he is amazing. You can feel how deeply curated every detail of the experience is. He took the time to personally explain everything, share the story behind the food, and even made me the most incredible mocktail. That level of care and passion is so rare and so appreciated.
I left feeling genuinely happy and inspired so grateful to have found this place. Butterfish is doing something really special, and I cannot recommend it enough. Truly a must-visit. ✨
… moreYou can immediately tell the quality is on another level. Their fish is incredibly fresh and thoughtfully sourced, even shipped straight from Japan, and it really shows. Every dish was outstanding the product truly speaks for itself.
What made the experience even more special was the service. The staff were so warm, thoughtful, and knowledgeable, with amazing storytelling around each dish that made the whole meal feel immersive and intentional.
And a huge shoutout to the owner, Jojo he is amazing. You can feel how deeply curated every detail of the experience is. He took the time to personally explain everything, share the story behind the food, and even made me the most incredible mocktail. That level of care and passion is so rare and so appreciated.
I left feeling genuinely happy and inspired so grateful to have found this place. Butterfish is doing something really special, and I cannot recommend it enough. Truly a must-visit. ✨
Tatiana Parreira
Butterfish was such an incredible experience from beginning to end! The food was absolutely amazing, beautifully done, full of flavor, and clearly made with care. Every dish felt special and intentional, and it’s the kind of meal you actually want to slow down and enjoy.
What really made the night stand out was Jojo, the General Manager. Jojo made a point to check in on every single table, and you could feel how much he genuinely cares about the guest experience. That level of attention and warmth is rare and made the whole evening feel extra special. It was truly the cherry on top of an already amazing food experience!
Wonderful experience. I can’t recommend it enough, and I can’t wait to go back! ♥️
… moreWhat really made the night stand out was Jojo, the General Manager. Jojo made a point to check in on every single table, and you could feel how much he genuinely cares about the guest experience. That level of attention and warmth is rare and made the whole evening feel extra special. It was truly the cherry on top of an already amazing food experience!
Wonderful experience. I can’t recommend it enough, and I can’t wait to go back! ♥️
B Baimaii
We had such a wonderful experience! Marilyn took amazing care of us.
she helped with the wine and made sure our order was perfect. Leo was so friendly and kind, and Ryan kept checking in to make sure everything was going well. The food was absolutely delicious..especially the sushi, which was incredibly fresh and flavorful!
The cozy atmosphere made everything even better.
Thank you all so much for such a lovely night!
… moreshe helped with the wine and made sure our order was perfect. Leo was so friendly and kind, and Ryan kept checking in to make sure everything was going well. The food was absolutely delicious..especially the sushi, which was incredibly fresh and flavorful!
The cozy atmosphere made everything even better.
Thank you all so much for such a lovely night!
Lydia Roca Alcayde
Really good Omakase experience, I would definitely repeat! And the service is incredible, they explain every plate perfectly and adjust to allergies really well! We ordered the Omakase experience “Premium” you can’t pick what you get, it’s chefs option, but very very good!
… more