Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
From these humble beginnings, we have continued to grow and expand in our never-ending pursuit for excellence, and have gained a loyal following. Chef Borgognone’s devotion, diligence, authentic recipes, and elegant presentations have allowed Buttercooky Bakery to earn its current high standards nationally and become one of Long Island’s landmarks, as it is known as today. If you ever have any questions or feedback for us, don’t hesitate to let us know!
Enduring bakeshop with French pastries, cookies & creative cakes, plus breakfast sweets & coffee.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 140 Plandome Rd, Manhasset, NY 11030
Phone: (516) 627-1600
Website: http://www.buttercookybakery.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Manhasset – BUTTERCOOKY BAKERY & CAFE
SAVOR OUR BUTTERCOOKY CAFE MENU · STAY A WHILE OR TAKE IT TO GO! · As seen on The Knot · FRESH BAKED PASTRIES, COOKIES, CUSTOM CAKES, AND SO MUCH MORE · Baked with …
BUTTERCOOKY BAKERY | Located in Floral Park, Manhasset, and …
Family owned and operated Italian bakery in Long Island, NY for over 50 years, with locations in Floral Park, Manhasset, and Huntington.
Buttercooky Bakery & Café (@buttercooky_bakery) – Instagram
Modern European Bakery & Café. Custom Cakes | Pastries | Coffee | Brunch + Lunch. Floral Park • Manhasset • Huntington. BC Bistro @bcbistrofp.
Reviews
Cool Dude
First time at this location. We just bought a cake and 2 pastries. They tasted good. Pricing seems reasonable. Pastries were dry. Either they were overcooked or stale. The strawberry short cake is good.
… moreAdriana Crino
I’m not one to write reviews but I was disappointed from my experience this morning. Tried the draft lattes and received cups that were 1/3 coffee and the rest foam. When I kindly asked the barista to top the cups off, as they were clearly not full, they shrugged, acknowledged that there was too much foam, and added only a tiny bit more coffee. I don’t mind paying for overpriced coffees if they’re made correctly but serving cups full of draft foam for $15 is just bad service.
… moreDavid Zinin
Okay. So dropped in today since it was “recommended” here is what my opinion is.
The atmosphere the staff top notch along with my cappuccino and regular black coffee. I will not take away from that.
I bought 4 pastries.
The pistachio with cream bun looking item.
It was my favourite of the four and id give it 4/5.
The honey comb peach in my opinion should not have almond in it for it takes away from the taste of the peach and pastry tasted synthetic. 1/5
The banana monkey bread looking pastry was okay minus almond once again, gave it a THC taste and felt like im eating and edible. 1/5
Last but not least the triple chocolate croissant was okay, too sweet for me and im a chocolate fan. 3/5
Overall this is my review , not to take away from your or anyone elses experience. Location, atmosphere, staff and everything looks so great. Just not for me.
I still give it 5 stars for it is worth a try. Goodluck
… moreThe atmosphere the staff top notch along with my cappuccino and regular black coffee. I will not take away from that.
I bought 4 pastries.
The pistachio with cream bun looking item.
It was my favourite of the four and id give it 4/5.
The honey comb peach in my opinion should not have almond in it for it takes away from the taste of the peach and pastry tasted synthetic. 1/5
The banana monkey bread looking pastry was okay minus almond once again, gave it a THC taste and felt like im eating and edible. 1/5
Last but not least the triple chocolate croissant was okay, too sweet for me and im a chocolate fan. 3/5
Overall this is my review , not to take away from your or anyone elses experience. Location, atmosphere, staff and everything looks so great. Just not for me.
I still give it 5 stars for it is worth a try. Goodluck
Richard Cooper
As someone who grew up in Boston with nice homemade bakeries available , to my delight I found my childhood dream at the Butter Cookie Bakery and Cafe in Manhasset , Nassau County ,New York .
At reasonable prices , salads , specially breakfast and lunch items of the quality made and freshness I remember and cherish growing up, specialty smoothies and heavenly coffees are there to provide a country bakery experience with freshness from all the ingredients .
An important part of the mix are the yummy and
fresh assortment of anyquality French , Italian and old fashioned American baked goods including pastries you could find in Paris , all at reasonable prices .
The bakery restaurant is spotless and its available dining area is cozy and inviting to spend time making your experience there a real treat .
The staff are all lovers of what they prepare and sell and are knowledgeable about the ingredients and taste experiences of their offering . Take out orders are also provided in the same honey and warm manner . Parking and location is very convenient.
… moreAt reasonable prices , salads , specially breakfast and lunch items of the quality made and freshness I remember and cherish growing up, specialty smoothies and heavenly coffees are there to provide a country bakery experience with freshness from all the ingredients .
An important part of the mix are the yummy and
fresh assortment of anyquality French , Italian and old fashioned American baked goods including pastries you could find in Paris , all at reasonable prices .
The bakery restaurant is spotless and its available dining area is cozy and inviting to spend time making your experience there a real treat .
The staff are all lovers of what they prepare and sell and are knowledgeable about the ingredients and taste experiences of their offering . Take out orders are also provided in the same honey and warm manner . Parking and location is very convenient.
Hope Jung
Moldy Cake and Disappointing Customer Service
For years, my friend has been ordering cakes from this bakery to be delivered to his friends and acquaintances on their birthdays. On my birthday this year, he once again had a cake delivered from this bakery. Despite being in extremely poor health and even visiting the emergency room that same week, he still remembered my birthday and made sure a cake was sent to me.
However, when I opened the box that evening for my birthday party, I was shocked to discover severe mold growing on the fruits covering the cake. I didn’t want to tarnish the reputation of a bakery I’ve loved for years, so I quietly reached out through email and Instagram, hoping for a resolution. After receiving no response, I called the store directly.
They told me that the person who made the purchase needed to contact them, so I—very reluctantly and feeling terribly sorry—had to explain the situation to my friend and send him the photos as evidence. This was emotionally difficult for me.
Even after he contacted them, they refused to offer a refund or any resolution, saying too much time had passed. Eventually, I received an email stating that if I came to the store, they would provide a replacement cake.
But when I traveled a long distance to get there, they denied me again and sent me away empty-handed.
This experience was deeply disappointing and upsetting.
I strongly urge others: If you buy a cake from this bakery, please make sure to check carefully for mold.
… moreFor years, my friend has been ordering cakes from this bakery to be delivered to his friends and acquaintances on their birthdays. On my birthday this year, he once again had a cake delivered from this bakery. Despite being in extremely poor health and even visiting the emergency room that same week, he still remembered my birthday and made sure a cake was sent to me.
However, when I opened the box that evening for my birthday party, I was shocked to discover severe mold growing on the fruits covering the cake. I didn’t want to tarnish the reputation of a bakery I’ve loved for years, so I quietly reached out through email and Instagram, hoping for a resolution. After receiving no response, I called the store directly.
They told me that the person who made the purchase needed to contact them, so I—very reluctantly and feeling terribly sorry—had to explain the situation to my friend and send him the photos as evidence. This was emotionally difficult for me.
Even after he contacted them, they refused to offer a refund or any resolution, saying too much time had passed. Eventually, I received an email stating that if I came to the store, they would provide a replacement cake.
But when I traveled a long distance to get there, they denied me again and sent me away empty-handed.
This experience was deeply disappointing and upsetting.
I strongly urge others: If you buy a cake from this bakery, please make sure to check carefully for mold.
Sammie Benson
They offer many gluten free, dairy free, vegan, and vegetarian breakfast options. There are gluten free cookies but for other dietary restricted baked goods you must pre-order. I had the potato Latke pancakes and tried a hazelnut and French vanilla oatmilk lattes. Both were phenomenal! The potato pancakes have avocado and poached eggs on them. The taste, texture, and presentation were amazing! They have iced oatmilk draft lattes! The staff are friendly and welcoming. They answered all my questions! The staff interacted with regular visitors like family making the whole atmosphere friendly and cozy!
… moreAlexis
UPDATE: While I have yet to revisit the cafe, I was contacted by a manager with a very thoughtful and genuine offer to make up for our disappointing experience. The folks over at Buttercooky seem to care, and that most certainly makes a difference! Looking forward to giving it another shot.
This review is for the cafe only … Love the bakery and decided to try the cafe today for a take out order. I’ll keep it short: my tiny $19 salad was mostly cabbage ribs, the bread on my $19 pressed sandwich was burnt. I thought this could be a new go-to for sandwiches and salads since my preferred place is right around the same price point, but we did not find the same quality that we enjoy at the bakery. Would have shown a manager had I not taken the food to go.
… moreThis review is for the cafe only … Love the bakery and decided to try the cafe today for a take out order. I’ll keep it short: my tiny $19 salad was mostly cabbage ribs, the bread on my $19 pressed sandwich was burnt. I thought this could be a new go-to for sandwiches and salads since my preferred place is right around the same price point, but we did not find the same quality that we enjoy at the bakery. Would have shown a manager had I not taken the food to go.
N
Edit: Interesting how other POC reviews have trouble with this cafe
ORIGINAL:
seems like a copycat of an asian bakery. Should just keep the same style as the queens one.
Service is like can I get you anything? no we’re sold out. Line is disorganized. Wait long and I get skipped over for help cuz I’m not white. I think these guys are overworked and done with their jobs or maybe the ppl they have to help i feel bad.
Pastries fantastic, sandwiches are great. Wish there were more vegan varieties but hey its a pastry shop, so happy there’s some food there as an option
Cakes are great but when ordering one if advance the price doesn’t really match, it lowkey breaks the bank and you can find so many bakers making great quality cakes with beautiful presentation. I think they need to work on their pricing quotas. Not worth it esp if its ur grad, wedding, birthday cake.
… moreORIGINAL:
seems like a copycat of an asian bakery. Should just keep the same style as the queens one.
Service is like can I get you anything? no we’re sold out. Line is disorganized. Wait long and I get skipped over for help cuz I’m not white. I think these guys are overworked and done with their jobs or maybe the ppl they have to help i feel bad.
Pastries fantastic, sandwiches are great. Wish there were more vegan varieties but hey its a pastry shop, so happy there’s some food there as an option
Cakes are great but when ordering one if advance the price doesn’t really match, it lowkey breaks the bank and you can find so many bakers making great quality cakes with beautiful presentation. I think they need to work on their pricing quotas. Not worth it esp if its ur grad, wedding, birthday cake.
Kosta Rica
Pretty efficient and pleasant service. Lots of space inside and outside. Conveniently located bakery. Lots of options. A pleasant experience.
… moreFrugal Cyclist
Elegant & upscale bakery
Buttercooky has many high caliber offerings from donuts, croissants, tarts, & sandwiches.
How to decide when so many items look so very delicious?
I settled on a broccoli egg croissant tart . Rich & decadent. I wanted another…
Awesome venue with comfortable leather bench seats. Plenty of sunlight radiating through. I can easily sit here for an hour.
Very friendly staff. Nice setup with complimentary self service lemon water.
It’s no wonder they have been in business since 1962. My only gripe is I did not see a price list or tags for the pastries. Did I overlook it?
… moreButtercooky has many high caliber offerings from donuts, croissants, tarts, & sandwiches.
How to decide when so many items look so very delicious?
I settled on a broccoli egg croissant tart . Rich & decadent. I wanted another…
Awesome venue with comfortable leather bench seats. Plenty of sunlight radiating through. I can easily sit here for an hour.
Very friendly staff. Nice setup with complimentary self service lemon water.
It’s no wonder they have been in business since 1962. My only gripe is I did not see a price list or tags for the pastries. Did I overlook it?