Bustling spot with a warm atmosphere serving generous portions of Italian favorites.
Jim Spano
This is a beautiful restaurant me and my friends came here. For the first time. And it will not be our last We had a wonderful time. The food is outstanding. Service that was great and the manager was very accommodating. We had a vegetarian with us. And they made us a nice vegetable Lasagna. Thank you. And a shout out to the bartender in the front, she was very sweet And nice. Thanks for a wonderful evening.
… moreEric Lawrence
Just got home from a Valentine’s Day dinner with 3 other couples. I’m always disappointed when I go out on this night but NOT tonight. Love the family style portions. For eight of us we ordered 2 appetizers, 1 salad, 2 meat dishes and 2 pasta dishes, all shared. We were all full and satisfied. Everything tasted great, especially the chicken gorgonzola. We also had coffee and desert, no alcohol. We were all also pleasantly surprised that our bill was only $120 a couple including tax and we all ate like kings. Love this place, will definitely be back.
… moreDavid S
3 out 4 is pushing it but still worth a try for yourself.
Pasta was very good tasting. Chicken Parm. a little tough. Petite Filet was dry no taste!
Salmon cooked nicely!
2 out of 3 but we only tried 3 dishes out of many, I’m sure there are many others that are better…
This was only
Service was good but not very attentive, very hard to get eye contact.
Atmosphere was a bit stuffy.
… moreWilliam Rogers
Had lunch at the sayville location it was busy so we sat at the bar. They didn’t have a regular bartender so we bounced between which ever waitress was going by. The food was fine and the staff was nice enough we were given a gift certificate which was more than enough prices are good. I would go back but probably sit at a table the bar is very small. If you’re in the area stop in I wouldn’t travel to it but it’s a good local restaurant.
… moreLORI TRIAIL
Have gone to Butera‘s in Sayville time and time again and the food is always absolutely delicious! The staff is wonderful and attentive! Went there today for lunch as a little mini reunion with friends from years ago as teenagers and new friends! Paul, the manager is always so accommodating, friendly, and appreciative of our business! Thank you, Paul For allowing us to stay and get caught up! Your food is always delicious and cooked to perfection and the new blackened chicken on your menu that I had today was absolutely delicious!!!
… moreWar Ozz
Food was really good. The sauce is a little sweet for my taste but it was really good. Service was oitstanding. It’s family style so if your eating for yourself ask for half portions. They had no problem.
… moreJames Wood
My family and I came into Butera‘s for dinner after a funeral. The staff here were extremely helpful and friendly. they were very welcoming and accommodating for about 70 people. The restaurant is clean inside and out. All the food we had was delicious and fresh. I highly recommend Butera’s!!
… moreAlisa Kremer
Terrific family-style Italian food. The wait staff is friendly and accomodating, and the appetizers (stuffed mushrooms) and entrees (lasagna, eggplant rollitini, chicken parm, etc) are delicious. The warm rolls they bring to the table are tasty as well. We had food to take home and our daughters had it for dinner the next night.
… moreKirk Davidson
Amazing, food, service price and portions! Terrific! I’m going back, awesome value! Big portions, great flavors, food done well! Only thing missing was a little background music preferably Tarantella Napoletana on mandolin. Mama Mia! Best kept secret! Bring the whole family! We left full, food and drink per person was $43 per person!
… moreKimiko
Amazing lunch with huge portions at an affordable price! We got the grilled shrimp salad, mushroom asparagus and grilled chicken salad, and rigatoni alla rosa. The salad was perfectly dressed! The shrimp was slightly over cooked but till enjoyable. It also had 2 slices of bread that were really really hard which is I think their version of a crouton. We did ask for bread and it came with some olive oil. Definitely coming back for more affordable and delicious meal options!
FYI – Costco sells gift cards here at a cheaper price!
… more