Chris Trethewey
Buff’s Ice Cream is a must-stop if you are in the Brookville area. The ice cream is fantastic. I ordered a Carmel sundae with vanilla ice cream. It was creamy, rich, and packed with flavor. The staff was very friendly! There is ample seating and even several seats outside. Buff’s not only has ice cream but there is food to order. You have to try Buff’s!
… moreAnthony Smith
Great little ice cream shop off the main road. The homemade root beer was excellent. I recently went back and have to say this is some of the best ice cream I have ever had. It is definitely the most creamy!
… moreTravel
Visited this store in the 60s! Can’t say enough about what a sweet spot this is! No pun intended. Employees are local students, ice cream is super good
… moreAustin Davenport Grier
I can’t recommend the soup, it tasted like it just came out of a can. But the people here are super nice and the shakes are lovely. The decorations inside are adorable as well. Blast from the past!
… moreElizabeth
Made a road trip pit stop to try their teaberry ice cream. It was delicious and had a creamy and airy texture. Definitely recommend! The one scoop portion was huge at a good price! Staff was very friendly!
… moreEm
Love to find a place with vegan options! Two teen boys behind the counter were very helpful and attentive
… moreLillee McLaughlin
Super cute little shop. Went with the family, the kids loved the ice cream cones! We also got a peanut butter pizza, which we ate whole. Delish! Blueberry shake is a must try! Definitely recommend this place to tourists and residents!
… moreDebbie Reid
Moved away from Brookville in 2006 stopped by when in Brookville to get my favorite home made ice cream. The young gentleman that waited on me was very nice and polite, good service
… moreJared Kronenwetter
Great, fast service and great ice cream. Staff was friendly and welcoming.
… moreKathy David
Quaint little ice cream and lunch place. Very homey with vintage Knick knacks and ice cream style tables and chairs. Chicken salad and BLT sandwiches were our choices with fresh fruit and macaroni salad. Best macaroni salad I’ve had! Delicious with lots of egg and celery. Friendly owners.
… more