4.4 – 133 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Buffalo Pizza and Subs offers a delicious selection of handcrafted pizzas, delicious subs, and mouthwatering calzones, pastas, salads and wraps, Known for our fresh ingredients and friendly service, we provide a cozy atmosphere perfect for dine-in or takeout. With a casual vibe and friendly service, it’s perfect for a quick lunch or a cozy dinner. Stop by and see why we’re a local favorite!
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
slicelife.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reviews
Eric Narciso
Buffalo’s Pizza is hands-down one of the best local spots we’ve tried. Everything on the menu is consistently amazing, but the buffalo fingers truly live up to the name. They’re the perfect balance of sweet and savory, with just the right amount of heat—enough of a kick to satisfy, but still mild enough that even our kids loved them.
You can tell there’s real care put into the food here. Whether it’s pizza night or a quick bite, Buffalo’s always delivers. Highly recommend this place for families, foodies, or anyone who just appreciates quality comfort food done right.
… moreKriz Bee
Everything you’d expect from a family-owned pizza shop!
Friendly staff, fair prices, hometown feel, and amazing food with quality ingredients.
First time here.
I ordered the steak and cheese quesadilla, my gf got the meatball sub.
The quesadilla was great. The hot sauce was tasty and just the right level of hot.
About me: I am NOT a big fan of salsa. Apparently, I’ve never had an AMAZING salsa!
I ate it all up…and, I’ve tried a lot of different salsas over the decades! Their stuff is hands down the best!!
My gf ordered a meatball sub, lightly toasted.
I tried it, and it was also delicious!
She did order it lightly toasted, but it came to our table more on the well-done side.
Stephanos (I hope I spelled that right) was more than happy to correct the error, and my gf had her sub back (just the way she wanted it) in just a few minutes.
Now the best part:
* DESSERT *
I’ve been eating baklava since the 80’s, when an older Greek pizza-shop owner (ironic, I know) turned me onto it. And I haven’t found any that’s even close to his…until 2024, at Buffalo’s in Norwood!
Taking pics was an after-thought, sorry.
It’s what we had left when I took my phone out
We will be back for sure!
… moreGabriel tazuy
i love buffalos pizza so much. they have the best customer service ever. I LOVE ordering the steak and cheese because the love and passion they put into the food. Best in town.
… moreCaitlyn Carr
So happy I found their menu! So so so good!! Been dying so a steak and cheese calzone with the melted cheese on top. Also I dip my steak and cheese calzone in blue cheese and they didn’t forget the blue cheese! Everywhere else does. I wish I could of finished the entire thing. The bbq finger, cheese pizza, fries and curly fries are great!
… moreMarina Saravanos
Amazing food and friendly people. The steak and cheese calzone is absolutely delicious. I definitely recommend to anyone.
… moreCaroline Crimmins
Hi! Love buffalos. Usually amazing! BUT I ordered a veggie calzone around 8:30 on 5/24 and I got some sort of sausage onion pizza thing. Called but you’re closed so I’ll eat this and obviously it’s tasty. But just a heads up I think I got someone else’s food!!!
… moreS B
The fish fry and the haddock dinner were both huge. Perfectly cooked, delivered hot, onion rings were great, steak fries were good as well. The slaw was awesome, it was so good my Wife actually likes it, she does not generally like coleslaw. We have also had their buffalo chicken calzone and twice we had their spinach and mushroom pizza. They were also delicious and delivered hot. Highly recommend this place.
… moreYesenia Gonzalez
Do not get their steak tips!!!!!! They are dry unseasoned and taste old. Had a terrible experience and called back to be told that’s how their steak tips are. Never again!!
… moreJeramie Irving
Salad is nice and fresh but a steak tips salad came with maybe 1 oz of steak tips looks like one steak tips cut into 5 peices and for a 6 dollar add that is kind of crazy… whats the point in asking how I want them cooked if they are steak slivers and not tips… sub shops really need to establish what a steak tips is and not a steak sliver..
… moreGabi Sussman
I got the buffalo fingers and steak fries and the portion was massive, enough for 2 meals – which is awesome for the $16 price point. The chicken fingers themselves were super juicy and they did not skimp on the buffalo sauce. The steak fries were perfectly done. Also, the staff here were very kind, and the service was fast.
… more … View more