Steve Stutzman
So i think a lot of folks are missing the point here at this place. It is Old West by design. Old cowboy cranking out the breakfast, not a chef. Old West decor, and attitude.
Its worth a meal there just for the decor, twisted humor, and gorgeous scenery.
If you are big on presentation and pampering, not your place.
If you want a sort of “experience” its awesome.
Breakfast is about twice what small-town cafe in Wyoming would be.
… moreSohel Dhanani
Nestled in Buffalo Valley Cafe, you’ll find a warm and inviting space with friendly folks who are always ready to lend a hand. The food, particularly the lunch choices, is simply divine. If you’re seeking a laid-back dining experience with a touch of rustic charm, this is the place for you!
… moreBrent Howard
Horrible food, way overpriced, bad service. I wasn’t expected 5 star food or service, but when the food and service at McDonalds is better, we have a problem. It is basically frozen food, superheated and served with mo flavor. Worst $100+ I have ever spent on a meal for my family. Plus they charge 20% gratuity automatically and don’t do anything to deserve a gratuity. You order yourself, find your own table, and after the food arrives, you never hear from them again.
… moreMelissa Beer
If you’re looking for a fine dining experience, this isn’t your place. We came for a good burger and a cold drink after a day of hiking and it was perfect! Very authentic atmosphere if you want to feel like you’re at a ranch in Wyoming!
… moreBryan Welchman
Come get your burger and flies!! Yes flies, they are everywhere!! Counted 10 on me at one time. 45% gratitude fee, $58 for two burnt hamburgers!! This place needs a health inspection or something, never been so disappointed.
… moreThomas Ryan
This place has character and a great small saloon bar feel to it. I looked around for a wait to be seated sign, but there was none. I kind of lingered waiting for a welcome to our restaurant, seat yourself or some type of greeting. The only server was just pushing plates out, so I figured I grab some menus and seat ourselves. After sometime waiting and ready to order, I saw another person order at the bar…pissed away about 5+ minutes waiting. However the burgers were really good and the cold can of $8 beer was refreshing. The kids didn’t like the soggy greasy thin fries, but I liked that style.
… moreMatt Snow
Absolutely amazing place to go and visit. Food was great. You had to order at the bar and walk back to get refills but oh well. Definitely worth it. We go lucky enough to be there when they let the horses out to the pasture. Amazing experience to see. All the workers worked on the ranch and it was fun getting to talk to them. Would recommend it to anyone.
… moreRupack Halder
We were searching for a good food place in this remote area after crossing Yellowstone, and this popped out. At first we didn’t think it would be good (and also the price was a bit high from the menu), but the chef was good and the cashier was very friendly as well. The food tasted really good. Serving time was a bit high, and my order got delayed somehow. But would definitely try again!
… moreNick M
Horrible place that used to be good. Auto gratuity 20 pct and charging $3 for a water because they say they don’t have any glasses. What type of cafe doesn’t have glasses. The service is terrible too. The guy demanded food to be ordered at the bar, dropped the food on the table and walked away as quick as possible when serving… what’s the 20 pct for again? Restaurant was also filled with flies and disgusting yellow spray foam insulation roof
… moreYanasa TV
Better food at close by locations. But what makes me give this place 1 star is that the menu item descriptions do not match the actual menu item… leading one to believe what they are ordering is something else. For example the Buffalo Sirloin and Eggs with lettuce tomato and bacon is in fact a ground bison with bacon, no lettuce, no tomato. I have very little respect for misrepresentation of something as simple as a menu description. The server did give us a free water bottle. Which pushed my review to a 3 star due to friendly service. And although the menu item was misrepresented, the food wasn’t bad… kind of a shame could have gone much higher.
… more