Dan Hartman (Overlord of Evil)
A little local pizza joint with some beer and a limited liquor selection, but very friendly and clean. Pizza was pretty good too.
… moreKelly Jackson
I used to love Buckeye Pizza in DeGraff. They’ve starting to getting stingy with toppings. I always order extra sauce on my pizza, ordered the same way tonight and the pizza came so dry it was like they thought I said no sauce. I called to ask and I was told it’s because their cheese soaks up all the sauce. I’ve ordered extra sauce for a long time and it was never this way. I was very disappointed in not only the quality of what I ordered but the way it was flippantly handled when I did call.
… moreGregory Seyer
Wow. What happened to your pizza sub???? New cook??… use to love getting the pizza sub!! Was cooked perfect and cut into little pieces. Now its like a upsidedown pizza. Bread cheese and pizza sause on top?? My cheese wasn’t even melted under all that sauce.. usually eat it all! Threw half of this one away….:(
10/20/24
Went back in and ordered a pizza sub!! Thanks so much for going back to the way it was!! Very delicious!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Now!…
… moreJeremy Withrow
This place charges you full price for half toppings don’t do it it’s a trick.They charged me 31.20 for a 15 in pizza in my eyes this is wrong they don’t even tell you when you order.
… moreTravis cox
The food here was excellent, and the service was top notch. Our order was prepared quickly and brought to our table. I would recommend stopping here if you’re driving through Degraff
… moreLauren Ransome
This is the best pizza in Logan County, hands down! The sweet sauce is phenomenal and every item on their menu is absolutely delicious. I can assure you, if you eat here once – you’ll definitely be coming back for more!
… moreJulia Spigelmoyer
There pizza was great we get one there every two wks.
… moreBen K
Great Pizza, Cool Atmosphere/Building, Friendly Staff, Clean Facilities, Fast Service, Good Parking, Plenty of Buckeye Swag
… moreHeather Eley
Tonight was our first time eating here and the pizza and breadsticks were really good. We will be back!
… moreTiara Lester
I called multiple times to place an order around 7:44pm until 8:30pm. It would either go to voicemail or it would ring nonstop when I called for the final time to place an order. Somebody answered and screamed stop calling and then hung up the phone and believe me it was the correct phone number because the voicemail was Buckeye Pizza of Degraff. It’s a shame when you called to order a couple subs and some breadsticks over an hour before they close (9pm) and that’s the kind of service you get.
… more