Walter Deecki Jr
Brother’s Pizza in Warren is a solid choice when you’re craving something good, simple, and budget-friendly. It has that same familiar charm as a classic, old timey pizza place–nothing fancy, nothing over the top, just good pizza at a good price.
What Brother’s does well is consistency. The pizza is reliably tasty, satisfying, and exactly what you expect from a classic local budget spot. It’s the kind of place you can count on for a quick pickup, a family pizza night that won’t break the bank, or an easy meal when you want something where the service is dependable and quick.
It isn’t aiming to compete with gourmet or specialty pizzerias, but it doesn’t need to. Brother’s stays in its lane and does it well. For affordability, flavor, and that nostalgic local-pizza feel, it earns a solid four stars in my book.
… moreMick Robinson
Absolutely terrible customer service. My order was incorrect. I called to explain the situation to them and I was mistreated and called ignorant by the woman on the phone. I have been in sales for 20 years. The customer is always put first and treated with absolute empathy and urgency to fix there issues. You want to make them want to come back and tell everyone they know to become customers. I will never ever spend another dollar at this place. I will only do business at the Cortland location. They know how to treat there customers. Pass this place right up and go to Sunrise. Don’t spend your money here.
… moreRyan Amos
I’ve never eaten here before because I’ve heard your pizza sucks. But I did hear your subs are great. So I think you just need to either change your pizza style and recipe or just have subs and name the restaurant brothers with a slogan saying famous for our subs.
… moreWilliam Mazza
Best pizza ..in town thin cheese meatball on the side an good subs
… moreMichael Jerryson
I have cooked at Chicago pizza restaurants, sampled pizzas in New York, and Italy, and tried very different pizzas in the Youngstown/Warren area. This is by far the best thin crust traditional pizza around. They make their crust from scratch, their sauces are very well seasoned, and they have quality cheese. The pizza tastes very close to the Italian varietals I have sampled in parts of Italy. It is moderately inexpensive (a 16-inch cheese pizza is $12.95). The place is quite rundown as a sit-in restaurant. The outside looks weathered, the interior is too, but the tables are fine (and clean). There is no WIFI access provided in the restaurant and they do not have a website, but they have been around for quite a long time and have a consistent and loyal customer base.
The service is similar to New York pizza parlors. Some of the servers are not very chipper, but they are all cordial and try to help you as fast as possible. Considering the quality and prices, I could not ask for anything better (save for beef ingredients on pizzas, which is a no-no in traditional Italian pizzas).
… moreAnthony Irizarry
I’ve been coming here since I could remember, around 15+ years, their ny style pizza, pepperoni rolls, strombolis and subs are my absolute favorite. The only place that came close to Brothers in my opinion is a place in Dallas Texas. The owner and staff truly do care about their customers and have always gone above and beyond to keep us happy. This is my only review about a restaurant that I’ve ever made so it goes to show how much I love this place. Oh and also their white pizza is to die for.
… moreJeff Cleer
I love big slices of thin crust pizza that you have to fold in half to eat. Brothers has an option for just that! Everything we’ve tried so far has been exceptional! Love the pepperoni roll too!!!
… moreDonna Yates
The only reason for one star is cause can’t post with out a star. It was like no sauce on the pizzas couldn’t see or taste the sauce and the dough was rubbery. It was so spicy that my kids couldn’t eat it so they had roast. It’s pretty bad when little ceasers has better pizza. I’m going to make sure I tell everyone I know to stay away and if I see anyone looking for a good pizza / sub place I’m going to tell them the same stay away from Brorhers
… moreCathy Kaiser
Terrible, i thought i would try them again had been a few years as i usually go to Tommy’s Brother’s pizza next door. Ordered a tuna and Italian sub, could hardly find any tuna! Maybe a thin smear on one side of bun. The Italian hardly had any meat or cheese mostly all lettuce on another hard bun. Will continue to go to Tommy’s in future.
… moreNickole Paulsey
We order from brothers weekly, if not more. Last week we had our usual order, except our large cheese pizza with extra cheese had no cheese left on it. It was all inside the box, of the side of the pizza like the driver was of road racing through the jungle. We called, for the very first time, and were told there would be a replacement whenever we wanted it. We had purchased enough other food, so we waited. We call today, and they refuse our replacement. Guess we won’t be eating here anymore.
… more