Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Bringing a true taste of New York to small-town Wyoming. Our New York-style pizzeria and tavern serves authentic, hand-tossed pizza with that iconic thin, foldable crust, baked to perfection and made fresh every time. Pair it with an ice-cold beer, including from Genesee brewery in New York, in a relaxed tavern atmosphere inspired by the energy, attitude, and grit of NY. Whether you’re stopping in for a casual night out or gathering with friends, we deliver big-city flavor, classic New York vibes, and genuine hometown hospitality—no subway ride required.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 877 Gilchrist St, Wheatland, WY 82201
Phone: (307) 269-4903
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Brooklyn’s Tavern | Wheatland WY – Facebook
Brooklyn’s Tavern · This Saturday! · Wheatland, Wyoming: Home to all your favorite vacation hobbies. · Sorry guys Brooklyn’s will have to closed tonight due to …
Brooklyn’s Tavern, 877 Gilchrist St, Wheatland, WY 82201, US
Brooklyn’s Tavern located in Wheatland WY is a cozy eatery that offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere perfect for friends and families alike.
‘Tossed’ into Wheatland: Brooklyn’s Tavern to serve up NY-style pizza
Wheatland WY 82201. Phone: 307-322-2627. Links of interest. Contact us · Terms of Service. Get Social. © Copyright 2026 Platte County Record- …
Reviews
Nancy Benton
Great local spot in Wheatland. All the staff were welcoming and nice. The supreme pizza was plenty large enough to have leftovers the next day and the garlic bread was so good again we had leftovers of the bread which we had with pasta the next day as well.
… moreTrista Katzer
Authentic New York pizza just like I’m back in Brooklyn. This is the best pizza in Wyoming state in my opinion. Thank you for sharing your pizza with us! The price is about the same as Dominoes or Pizza Hut and is so much better in quality. Their made in house crust is delicious . Pizzas are huge and slices are as big if not bigger than the plate. I love ❤️ it!
… moreJennifer Lowe
Please read! So, Saturday evening, we got here and we’re informed that they didn’t have a whole lot of options. I wanted the chicken wings or the fried ravioli and they were out of both and only had four pizza dough left before they were done for the day.
Now you would think I’m complaining but no, the staff was excellent! They explained the how and why they were in their predicament and went above and beyond to make excellent customer service for us. This is a business we will definitely be returning to!
… moreNow you would think I’m complaining but no, the staff was excellent! They explained the how and why they were in their predicament and went above and beyond to make excellent customer service for us. This is a business we will definitely be returning to!
Antoniobrady
I didn’t expect to find the best pizza I’ve ever had in Wheatland Wyoming. I wish I lived closer. It’s definitely worth going out of the way for.
… moreJay nallaranos
The supreme pizza was good, next time I will get a straight cheese to try the NY style Good to see a non chain restaurant thriving in Wheatland. Great pizza jint with other food and beer.
… moreJonathan Calkins
Fantastic place in town. Best Philly cheese steak sandwich ever, great pizza, super friendly staff. Homemade dough, cold drinks, nice atmosphere.
… moreJared Cleveland
Food was decent but the server had to ask us 4-5 times what drinks we ordered and then messed up one of the drinks when we did eventually get them. Floors had garbage on them and they started sweeping while we were eating. Only people in the place and I can see why
… moreJoshua LeBar
Looking for an authentic New York style pizza?? This is the place!! Perfectly cooked crust, right amount of toppings and the flavor is hard to beat! The owner definitely grow up in the right area to make pizza. Regional beers from NY that are hard to find out here. Thank you for the amazing food!!
… moreBryan Burns
Driving into Wheatland, you don’t think that you are going to have some of the best pizza you’d ever have. But wow, what a pleasant surprise. The place has that inviting familiar feel of the much loved neighborhood pizza joint. We got the buffalo chicken pizza and wings. Both were phenomenal. The crust was crispy, yet pleasantly chewy. The gluten was well developed in the dough, but it wasn’t over risen and heavy. Great flavors on the sauce and cheese as well. We will definitely find a way to drive up from colorado again to get a pie from this awesome establishment.
… moreEvan Bradley
Great food: the dough/crust of the pies is probably my favorite of anywhere I’ve eaten. The cooks are generous with the toppings. The pizza’s are huge and fresh. Every time I’ve gone I’ve watched the pizza come out of the oven and be slid onto my table in 20-30 seconds.
Great atmosphere: Authentic vibe from the moment you walk in. I love that it’s all open and you can chat with the cooks while you sip your drink and they make your food. It’s also a perfect balance of a spot between family friendly and bar scene. I’ve gone with my kids and seen my son talk and play with the employee’s kids and I’ve also gone and enjoyed company with friends after dark for beer and a late night slice.
Great service and people that work at Brooklyn’s. No fake personalities from any of the employees. The things they can do quickly, they do. The things that take longer, they frequently but not annoyingly touch base and let you know that you’re being taken care of.
I’m so glad this place came to Wheatland.
… moreGreat atmosphere: Authentic vibe from the moment you walk in. I love that it’s all open and you can chat with the cooks while you sip your drink and they make your food. It’s also a perfect balance of a spot between family friendly and bar scene. I’ve gone with my kids and seen my son talk and play with the employee’s kids and I’ve also gone and enjoyed company with friends after dark for beer and a late night slice.
Great service and people that work at Brooklyn’s. No fake personalities from any of the employees. The things they can do quickly, they do. The things that take longer, they frequently but not annoyingly touch base and let you know that you’re being taken care of.
I’m so glad this place came to Wheatland.