Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4151 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43213
Phone: (614) 947-0065
Website: http://brooklynpizzeriaoh.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Brooklyn Pizzeria – Columbus, OH – 4151 E Main St – Hours, Menu …
Get 10% off your pizza delivery order – View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Brooklyn Pizzeria in Columbus, OH. Order online for delivery or pickup …
Brooklyn Pizza: Home
Online ordering menu for Brooklyn Pizza. At Brooklyn Pizza in Powell, we serve Pizza and a variety of other classics such as our Pesto Chicken Pizza, …
Brooklyn Pizzeria – 4151 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43227 – Slice
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Columbus, OH! Brooklyn Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive offers – satisfy …
Last Updates
Reviews
Jana Paster
(In my Beastie Boys voice)
Don’t. Sleep. On Brooklyn!
This place just opened a couple months ago and I’ve been meaning to stop. It’s the closest thing I’ve had to a NY slice in Cbus. The crust is foldable but not sloppy – just slightly crisp with those airy crusty bubbles. Cheese was all the way melted and sauce was that typical slightly sweet style that isn’t cloying. It’s $2 for a slice the size of the plate! I got one of each slice available: regular pep, beef pepperoni, cheese, and veggie. I do not enjoy fresh mushrooms on pizza because they always overpower the other vegetable flavors. I was so pleased to get my canned mushrooms, that blended well with the peppers, onions, and tomatoes. These slices were so good, only one of them actually survived the car ride home.
I only gave 3 stars for atmosphere because it’s a small, sparse space with limited seating. This place is designed for takeout: there is one table for 2-3 and a high top counter with chairs that might seat 4. But it’s one of those hole-in-the-wall establishments that does things really well. And for as small as they are, there is decent parking. They also have rib tips, wings, gyros, subs, salads, and dessert, whole pies custom or specialty, and even a two foot ‘monster pizza’. Go help out this small Eastside business and get a very tasty bang for your buck!
… moreDon’t. Sleep. On Brooklyn!
This place just opened a couple months ago and I’ve been meaning to stop. It’s the closest thing I’ve had to a NY slice in Cbus. The crust is foldable but not sloppy – just slightly crisp with those airy crusty bubbles. Cheese was all the way melted and sauce was that typical slightly sweet style that isn’t cloying. It’s $2 for a slice the size of the plate! I got one of each slice available: regular pep, beef pepperoni, cheese, and veggie. I do not enjoy fresh mushrooms on pizza because they always overpower the other vegetable flavors. I was so pleased to get my canned mushrooms, that blended well with the peppers, onions, and tomatoes. These slices were so good, only one of them actually survived the car ride home.
I only gave 3 stars for atmosphere because it’s a small, sparse space with limited seating. This place is designed for takeout: there is one table for 2-3 and a high top counter with chairs that might seat 4. But it’s one of those hole-in-the-wall establishments that does things really well. And for as small as they are, there is decent parking. They also have rib tips, wings, gyros, subs, salads, and dessert, whole pies custom or specialty, and even a two foot ‘monster pizza’. Go help out this small Eastside business and get a very tasty bang for your buck!
Belinda Perry
Not a place to dine in. But there pizzas are off the chain. Great place to grab food they have a variety of other things to choose from. Give them a try bet you’ll like them.
… moreMejdi Catoua
I ordered pizza and Stromboli they were very delicious with nice ingredients it taste like New York five stars is not good enough and it was delivered on time I will definitely will order again and try other varieties from the large menu thank you.
… moreJames Matheny
Ordered 6 pizzas for my dealership. They delivered 4, we went back to pick up the other 2. Nothing offered for an inconvenience. Not that we were looking for it, but its good to have good customer service. Pizza was less than desirable. crust was the best part as it was a bit crispy with minimal flex or sag. toppings, there were very little toppings, light cheese and the sauce, yuck. Tasted like they had the top come off of the oregano and pour into the sauce. We tried.. definitely wont be back. to many other good places to help out.
… moreRichard Collins
Great pizza. I love NY style. I love that I can get two veggie pizza slices for $6 and they’re big. The mushrooms are canned, but again, it’s only $3 a slice right now!
… moreNiranjan Shivaram
The veggie pizza was very good. For $2 per slice this was great value for money! We were driving past Columbus and stopped here because it was close to the exit.
… moreMomna
Been there a few times for the new york style and tbh it hits everytime. Recently got their monster pizza for thanksgiving and everyone in my family enjoyed it. A must visit.
… moreMicheal
one of the best pizzas I’ve had in Columbus. The slice is huge, the flavor is consistent, and it’s worth every dollar. Highly recommend.
… moreShamika Preston
Slices are a nice size decent price. $3 for a slice of pep $2 for a slice of cheese. Favor is good. Good New York style pizza
… moreDaisha Norwood
I couldn’t even give this place a try because they do not open at 11!!!!! I called and this man had the nerve to tell me to wait until 11:45!! No thank you! No explanation, just expected me to wait! Ridiculous! The crazy part he was in the restaurant!! Make this make sense! So make sure to go after 12! Good luck!
… more