Patrick Hull
For health reasons, I get pizza once a year, and by pizza, I mean real pizzeria pizza. This year I ordered from Brooklyn on Supper Bowl Sunday. I completed the order online and when I arrived, it was ready to go. I love the crust: not too thin, not too thick. Crispy but not crumbling. Love the sauce and the cheese. Great all around, I may have to rethink this once-a-year thing….
… moreLorenzo Jackson
I was a fan and a loyal customer until I ordered on doordash and received my pizza ALL wrong. they sent me a cheese pizza with the toppings on the side. they admitted to reading my instructions wrong and I was going to reorder until they told me they wouldn’t do anything to compensate for their mistake and my time being wasted. most places at least offer a free drink or something. they did not take accountability and definitely lost a customer which sucks because this is the only
place that actually tastes like pizza from up north . No one deserves to have their money wasted.
… moreTina Byrd
FANTASTIC food and the owner Leo is AWESOME! Fresh, made to order, large variety, and authentic to up North!
Hands down the pizza is superb and can order by the slice, the hot subs are huge a foot long (steak and cheese hint hint), and the baked dishes are hand made not frozen!
Give this place a try! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!
… moreVince Scamacca
I have had OK pizza at Brooklyn and excellent pizza. Today the pizza was excellent. Brooklyn makes a NY style pizza.
Today, the crust was perfect with a nice cook. Thin with a nice crisp. No flop and no issues. Had pizza here a few times where the bottom was black and tad greasy, like the oven needed to be cleaned.
The sauce was spot on with a nice tomatoey taste with a hint of oregano. Not too watery. The cheese was good, but was not the star of the show. Overall, the perfect cheese to sauce ratio.
If you are in the area you should check this place out!
… moreFINAO718
This place is a piece of New York City in South Carolina! Only place I’ve found yet, that makes chicken rolls! Pizza and Beef patties w cheese delicious!
… moreMike Morrell
Best New York style pizza in York County, bar none. Thin crust, great sauce, quality cheese, cooked right. They also have fantastic calzones, and antipasto!
… moreHumble Mom12
My family tried the pizza for the first time today. The pizza did not look that fresh when we first entered at 1 pm, but it was good once heated. Crust was better than an Empire pizza to compare. We are Italian and excited to try out this new spot. I felt like the place itself was very underwhelming and we had no where to sit because they allowed a large group to move all the chairs to one side. It looked like there were three tables total. The girl at the counter was busy chewing gum and just standing there and could care less. Eventually my teen got stuck carrying a heavy chair back as people started to walk out. Nobody at the place walked over to move a chair, this was so rude. Most likely we would not return.
… moreDr. Vonetta Chisholm
Just don’t order after 6:45pm. These guys are already ready to close up shop. I was told to pick up in 30 minutes, got there only to wait another 15 for a pizza that was not fresh out of the oven, but left over after they cleaned up everything before 7:30!!! My pizza barley had any of the toppings I ordered! Sadly I come to this place for a NEWYORK pizza. I did not get that at all… went home only to have to add my own toppings to make it what I asked for!
… moreHamilton Davis
Before ordering pizza from a large corporate establishment, try this place first. The pizza was gigantic, delicious and very reasonably priced. The staff was nice and they had my pizzas ready exactly when I wanted to pick them up.
Our first time with New York style pizza, but I have to say it was great and more than enough food. Thank you!
… moreT MT
I got a meat lovers pizza and it was mid at best. I was told it was the best pizza in the area and reminiscent of NY style, which I’ve never had. For the price, I expected more flavor and the only saving grace was the grated Parmesan cheese.
… more