Brandon D
Fine pizza. Fine pricing.
A little over $5 for a slice. Taste is good. Cooked well. Not too crispy; not too chewy.
7.3/10
… moreSarah Hager
TERRIBLE PIZZA, WHAT A SHAME! Brooklyn Pizza was my go-to pizza place in the past and I would recommend them to everyone. I’m not sure if the ownership or management has changed but the pizza ingredients certainly have, and for the worst! It doesn’t taste anything like it used to! The dough is soggy and boring. The cheese was way too salty and wasn’t completely melted which tells me it is a cheap substitute from what they used to use. Even the sauce was different. It was extra greasy which contributed to the soggy crust. In the past, that crust stayed crispy no matter how much grease touched it! The bottom of the crust was absolutely burnt and it tasted awful. Of course the prices have skyrocketed….$24 for a large pepperoni?? It used to be either $16 or $18. Overall, it tasted like a Chef Boyardee or Red Baron frozen pizza. Unbelievably disappointing. Bye Brooklyn, it was nice knowing you.
… moreNicolas King
Pizza has gone down hill over the years. I’m not sure if it’s the oven temperature or what but they never melt or brown the cheese anymore. Pizza is super floppy. This place used to be 5/5. They need to step their game back up
… moreSandr Thatsme
Absolutely love their pizza specially the 4 cheese pizza but all their food is amazing. Very friendly employees owner is an amazing guy. Place is very clean You won’t be disappointed. Can’t get enough of this place but thank God I don’t live that close to there or it would be dangerous hahaha.
… moreChloe Garcia
We got pizza by the slice on a busy Friday night. Order at the counter and pick a table. They call your name when your food is ready. It was ready quickly. It’s first come first served for the tables so there’s a good chance to not get a table while it’s busy but there a beautiful outdoor park area a block away so you can always take it to go. 10 tables or more average group size of four. Food on one side, drinks and ice cream on the other. The pizza was thin and soft and yummy! Loved the texture. Little expensive for a slice so I think buying a whole pie is the better value. There were other food options grab and go style. Atmosphere was bright and busy.
… moreJ R
Ordered Hell Boys pizza crispy, really good and came out to order. They were on time with the pizza when I went to pick it up, great atmosphere in the restaurant. Authentic oven made will be coming back
… moreJeff Wayne
Now charging $1 for a cap full of Parmesan??? Ridiculous.
Mediocre pizza. It’ll doing a pinch. It’s not bad. Just nothing to write home about. It’s no one’s “favorite” pizza, but if you’re in the mood for an expensive slice and an extra dollar to sprinkle on some Parmesan for an extra buck, this is your place.
… moreVB
All 3 pizzas were good. We had the 3 cheese 3 mushrooms pizza, buffalo chicken and the pepperoni pizza. The sides were extremely overpriced, just 3 tiny pieces of bread. Service was good
… moreDD T (DD)
I saw one review that I 200% agree with!
I think that they have changed owners. I did not recognize anybody behind the counter.I used to go here because the owner worked in Brooklyn, New York and we would talk about how delicious New York pizza was. As soon as I walked into Brooklyn Pizza tonight and I saw the pizza I knew it wasn’t going to be good as it used to be. My suspicions were correct …It was not the Brooklyn Pizza that I remember – was hoping it was a one off night, but according to at least one of the reviews, I think that this is now the norm. I used to refer Brooklyn Pizza to everyone.
… moreKii
Veggie Pizza was beautiful and bland! First time visiting this place and seasonings were not easily accessible. However the Buffalo chicken pizza was extremely flavorful. Atmosphere is nice as well but customer service was a hit or miss one guy was rude but the cashier was somewhat nice…
… more