Sara Daniels
First time at this location. Staff was great. Fresh ingredients. My only complaint is that I got onions on my sub. I didn’t order onions. But we were chatting with the girl who was making our subs and we probably all got distracted. It’s ok, the onions were delicious, but I could smell them for the rest of the day.
… moreLisa Jarmuz
We have been going here every Monday for an over a year now and every single week food is amazing. We make sure to get enough for lunch and dinner along with lunch for the next day or two as well The staff is alway super friendly and helpful. Nicole has been our sandwich maker pretty much every week. Susan the manager is always super helpful and friendly! We look forward to seeing them every week!
… moreSiege Johnson
Stopped in to pick up lunch and was very impressed. The corned beef sandwich was amazing, and the bread was also wonderful and clearly very fresh. The staff were extremely friendly and happy to check on ingredients when asked about allergens. Definitely generous portions and DO NOT skip the pickles!
… moreDavid Barber
Clean and friendly environment with tasty food. We frequent the various other locations but this is our favorite. My son ordered 1/2 salami sandwich and a chicken noodle soup. I had a whole ham + cheese sandwich. Ingredients were fresh and filling. Staff was attentive and welcoming.
… moreJean Horton
Bland. Bread and baked goods were pretty stale.
Homemade pasta salad is macaroni and mayo and half inch huge chunks of onion. The end.
Generous portions just not very good. Hard to find the tomato in the sandwich.
Wouldn’t eat here again.
… moreAuburn Reviewer
Absolutely incredible BLT stacked to the sky with bacon. Worth the high price tag to get two of them for pickup—definitely an indulgence. The staff was friendly and didn’t care that my left shoe was falling apart
… moreOscar Esteves
Superb Experience! Came with low expectations because it is simply a sandwich spot, left happy and satisfied. I ordered their Classic Pickle Sandwich with a cheese cake and water for about $24. Worth it!
The location was clean and spacious. The parking lot is also spacious. The Staff was super friendly and helpful. The portions are generous, I ordered a whole sandwich and was only able to eat half with the cheesecake. There’s also outdoor seating.
Recommend arriving before noon as it gets packed. Be prepared to spend a minimum of $15.
… morePeter Flood
Good lunch spot with quick service that I’ve been to many times. I was passive aggressively asked to tip when paying by the staff today. They started talking about tipping and looked at me and said “hint hint”. I only pay with a card and they don’t give you an option to tip on the receipt. This made me very uncomfortable and I will not be returning due to this which is unfortunate. I’ve even brought up the card tipping situation before to another staff member and they said don’t worry about it. Get with the times of digital tipping or pay your staff more so they don’t have to beg for tips and make people uncomfortable.
… moreE S
I finally got to visit the Brooklyn Pickle. The place definitely stood up to the reputation. Somebody told me they had a good Reuben sandwich. It wasn’t on the menu but it was available. It was big and it was really good. The place can get packed during lunch but that’s a good thing, right? I will definitely come back to try more things from this menu.
… moreKurt Parker
Newer location, and the food is always good. If you want a meat mountain in a sandwich, go for the Brooklyn Pickle Special. It’s just a pile of pastrami. Get it. It’s good!
… more