Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 205 NE Commercial Cir, Keystone Heights, FL 32656
Phone: (352) 478-8140
Website: https://brooklynboyskeystone.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Brooklyn Boys! – Keystone Heights
Brooklyn Boys was originally established in Lake City, FL 2007, backed by his mother and father, Anita & Frank Tonetti, Nicholas Tonetti and his two …
Brooklyn Boy’s Pizza/ The P.IG. | Keystone Heights FL – Facebook
Brooklyn Boy’s Pizza/ The P.IG., Keystone Heights. 3643 likes · 103 talking about this · 6662 were here. Homemade bread, sub rolls, sauces and more….
Brooklyn Boys / The P.I.G. – Authentic NY-style Italian Sushi …
Discover Brooklyn Boys / The P.I.G. in Keystone Heights, FL, where mouthwatering Italian dishes meet fresh sushi. Enjoy a warm atmosphere, friendly service, …
Reviews
Colson Socoloski
We wanted to try a new place as my son’s looooove pizza so we picked here!! Definitely glad we did. The lady who answered the phone was amazing very kind. When we went in to get the pizzas the lady that asked what we ordered had a bit of at-ti-tuuude but she may have been having a tough night there was a lot of people there at the time!! We will most definitely be back soon to try more things and I just gloat about how great the garlic bread was that was given for free yuuuuummmmy!!! We will definitely be recommending to others and can’t wait to go back so are the boys!!❤️
… moreAl Hall
Let me say first everything had the makings of a really good pizza restaurant and pizza. The Brooklyn story got me there. I have eaten some of the best pizza in the country including New York and South Jersey. Wood fired oven baked I have had it all. I seen all these good reviews and after eating a pizza last night could not understand why. Jeff Dee’s review was the only honest review I could see. I agree 100% the toppings on the meat lovers were so minced up it was just like a frozen grocery store pizza. When you order toppings they should be big enough so that every topping has and creates a different flavor in your mouth. Not just ground up all together. I like to chew my own pizza not have it pre chewed. I read your reply to Jeff and it was a bit disrespectful. Spoken like a true New Yorker. You might have a lot of good food there but that pizza is not.
… morePaula D.
My friend Ron Jones introduced me to Brooklyn Boys. At first, the atmosphere struck me as a bit unexpected for an Italian restaurant, but the food certainly did not disappoint. I ordered the eggplant parmigiana and asked them to hold the extra pasta. The large, soft garlic roll was outstanding. Ron had the lasagna, and both portions were enormous.
Dani, our server (pictured), was completely on top of everything—very personable and clearly a hard worker. As a restaurant columnist for Ocala’s Good Life magazine, I’ll definitely be back with more praise, I’m sure. I only wish I’d had room for the cannoli.
… moreDani, our server (pictured), was completely on top of everything—very personable and clearly a hard worker. As a restaurant columnist for Ocala’s Good Life magazine, I’ll definitely be back with more praise, I’m sure. I only wish I’d had room for the cannoli.
Trish Ames
This little hole in the wall was a good find. The portion sizes are definitely worth your money, the food was delicious. The wait staff were friendly and knowledgeable of their menu.
The frozen strawberry margarita was delicious as well as the chicken broccoli stromboli that I ordered.
… moreThe frozen strawberry margarita was delicious as well as the chicken broccoli stromboli that I ordered.
Constantino Usaga
Lasagna and pizza was delicious and the staff is so friendly. We came all the way from Orange Park and Fleming Island area. We are Mellowmushrooms pizza fans and will definitely be back here.
… moreDavid
Had great food here! Also we love the politically incorrect posters and aura of the place. Cash is preferred here as credit card use is an extra 3% charge
… moreGary Jamieson
Brooklyn Boys is awesome! The chicken cordon bleu stromboli was seriously amazing, and the white mussels were loaded with garlic, a perfect starter. Love that they serve beer in frosted pint glasses, super cold and refreshing. If you’re around Keystone Heights or over at Camp Blanding, definitely worth stopping in!
… moregregg pap
in the area. I was surprised by the looks of it. You would think that it isn’t an Italian restaurant, but when you eat the food. It’s simply amazing. My wife always judges an Italian restaurant by its sauce. And she loved it. So we knew the food was going to be great. We had a really good talk with the stepson of the owner as he was our server, and we learned a little bit about the restaurant . supporting local business is important. Are food came out hot tasty, with more of the tasty sauce for dipping. I know next month. Where will we take a large party to this restaurant after our event. If you’re in the keys, don’t area or passing through. It’s definitely worth a stop. They’ve got some really cool signage and have a full bar .
… moreJessica Shifrin
Food was so good and they treat you like family. We had a big party and they accommodated us no problem. They also helped us with the cake I made for my son’s birthday. Made it a wonderful experience and we will definitely be back.
… moreLorry Williams, Realtor
Best kept weekday lunch secret in Keystone. Food was fresh and amazing flavor. Felt like I was at a speak easy w the entrance kinda hard to find look for the dine in sign and door sign warning you of drinking and inappropriate conversations. lol… it’s obvious they make everything fresh. Margarita was ok .. full bar , large beer selection , whisky , they have wine just not on the menu. Server and manager checked on us many times to be sure all was great
… more