Jennifer Salazar
Flew in from Texas to visit Niagara Falls Aug 25-28th. My husband found Broadway Pizza online with good reviews for good New York Pizza and it was close to our Hotel. Gave it a try. Its a small place, but the service is wonderful. The lady taking our order was very helpful on helping us decide on what to get. Since it was our first time at the restaurant and in New York. She also gave us some places to go to see, while visiting. She was very kind and funny. The gentleman making our pizza and wings did an outstanding job. Got the combo with 1 large Pizza and 10 wings. We got pepperoni and lemon pepper wings. And OMG. The pepperoni pizza was cheesy and delicious and just enough mariana sauce the crest was so good. And the slices were pretty big. The wings were saucey and had a great taste. We don’t normally eat wings with blu cheese. But for some reason their blu cheese had a really good taste. It was alot of food for just us too. But it was so good that we only had 2 slices of pizza left. Which we saved for night snack.
Broadway Pizza was so good. That before we flew back home. We stopped by again and had some more pizza and wings. The lady and gentleman remembered us from the other day. So that was pretty cool. When you buy by the slice. Goodness they are some big slices. We got 2 each plus 20 wings this time. But still delicious. Would definitely go back again. Hands down to Broadway Pizza. Would definitely recommend to anyone that is in the area looking for some good Pizza and wings.
… moreMrViri11
Pizza was amazing everytime we visit this area we are always going out of our way to eat here.
… moreTashia Carron
After being a loyal customer to another pizzeria across town I decided to stop in here and mix things up. So glad I did!! The employees are kind, helpful and diligent. The atmosphere is pleasant and clean with a few tables for dining in. Slices at the counter are huge! Really huge! One slice is filling. Try the Buffalo Chicken…sooo good!!
A few days after stopping in here, we ordered delivery on a Friday night and again, were very pleased. Large pizza and wings, arrived in a reasonable time, hot, cooked to perfection and so much leftover. Don’t expect to fit the pizza box in the fridge…you’ll need a platter to put leftover slices on.
If you’re looking for an authentic Italian pizzeria with great food give Broadway Pizza a try!
… moreJulie Doucette
Absolutely the best Pizza in the Buffalo area hands down! The staff is equally amazing, especially the man making the pizza.
This pizza is so mouthwatering delicious, you can’t stop at one or two slices. The pizza was thin crust and crispy, a ton of mozzarella cheese and yummy pepperoni, and the pizza sauce was so frigen good. We ordered a small 16” pepperoni pizza 8 slices and demolished it (I could only eat 3 slices but hubby didn’t hesitate to finish the rest we stopped in for late dinner from our shopping in the US from Toronto and it was a fantastic choice! Also close to the outlets and other great stores. Enjoy all, we will definitely be coming back to Broadway Pizza
… moreNicolas Gambino
This is one of my favorite spots for pizza since they have opened, the pizza is always thin, crispy, and tastes great. The grandma’s pie is my personal favorite I get it 9/10 times. The smell in the car is ridiculous. If you like pepperoni add it. And the owners are great, hardworking people that are there every day, which I heavily respect.
… moreStu W.
Well what can I say it definitely not New York style pizza for anybody that’s been to New York City as many times as I have trust me when I say that this is the farthest thing from New York style pizza as I’ve ever seen hard dry flavorless crust the next day you could literally break this pizza in half. Don’t be fooled by toppings if you’re looking for New York style pizza place this is not the place! Real pizza connoisseurs will tell you that!
… moreRyan Amatuzio
I went there for lunch today and ordered a stinger sub ( hero ) and there was literally one steak-um and one chicken finger chopped up on it with massive amounts of lettuce to make the sub look bigger. I wouldn’t eat there ever again. Shorty behind the counter was nice and she didn’t make the food so nothing wrong with service but whoever made this sub should be jailed for robbery.
… moreDerick Woodard
Great little dive for a great slice of pizza. The owners are friendly and the pizza guy was amazing
… moreJoe Nelsen
hands down , best crust i have ever had ! top notch customer service and the pizza slices were more than delicious, heaven i would say
… moreChris Hunter
The crust and cheese are the star of the show here they are excellent the sauce and pepperoni not so much sauce lacked personality was very flat in flavor pepperoni ok but not very flavorful cool spot with great staff though
… more