Sheila Chin
Best Pizza & wings experience in Oswego! We went at 700PM on Sunday, had the place to ourselves. The owner took great care of us. We got the small pepperoni pizza & 10 wings special! Everything was piping hot, delicious and superb! We will be returning when we are back in town! A highly definitely recommendation!!!
… moreRebekah Manwaring
The pizza is delicious! I am very picky on chicken wings but Bridge Street Pizza has the best chicken wings I have ever had! Highly recommend!
… moreAnthony
Best Pizza & Calzones in Oswego. Family owned and ran small business. Good New York vibes.
… moreMichelle Lau
As a Brooklyn native, this is GREAT pizza. I never got the hype around Cam’s— their slices are tough to chew on, especially the crust. Pies Guys is also alright, but has a heavy hand with their sauce.. Bridge Street Pizza is crispy and does it just right.
They no longer serve individual slices, and their hours are a little out there, but I think it’s still definitely worth getting. I also enjoy Riverwalk and their margarita pizza, but I would choose BSP for their NY style (their 10” smallest pie is also cheaper than Riverwalk at $8). Would definitely recommend!
… moreJohn Charlton
We were looking for a classic style NY pie before heading north across the lake. Bridge Street Pizza turned out to be the perfect spot. I have a list of just over 100 Pizza shops I have been to over the past few years and would not hesitate to place them in the top 5. We ordered a simple sausage and black olive. The crust was perfect and and toppings were just the right ratio. I’m glad we had a couple of slices left over for lunch the next day.
… moreBilly Cronin
I ordered around 7:15 and specifically told the driver to ring the doorbell and leave the pizza in front of my door. The driver did not ring my door bell so the pizza sat outside for who knows how long. Boxes were soaked and the box on the bottom had water soak through and that pizza ended up soggy. Wack.
Edit: Owner called me back and gave me credit for two more. Really appreciate that, thank you.
… moreJason Pixler
Big pizza fan. So the family eats a lot of it . This place is awesome. Pizza was really GOOD! Best I’ve had in a while. The deals are good for your pocket.
… moreMike
This is the best pizza in all of Oswego Ny and a great price as well!! I mean that’s what I would expect coming from a guy who works the front counter with a Yankees shirt on.(ALWAYS). Now I’m from longisland so I know real pizza. This is real pizza. Anyone who walks around in this town and says hmmm let me get some cams doo doo or some pie guy trash (they cut their pizza in rectangles…)
I’m convinced they don’t know what true authentic NY pizza is!! I kid you not this is the best there is in this town. It’s a shame I see people walking into any of the other pizza restaurants in this town they are unworthy. Their market is for drunks this Yankees dudes market is quality… trust me I know… so if you ever want REAL NY style pizza this is your place.
… moreChristina DeLeon
First time ordering from here. I think everytime I wanted to order from here they were closed. Ordered two large pies and 40 wing combo. SO AFFORDABLE! I was shocked at the great price, considering I was paying almost $100 or more at other pizza spots. It was ready, on a Sunday, in 25 minutes! The pizza is amazing with a nice thin crust and the perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni. True to NYC style, the slices folded perfectly in half! The wings are delicious. I tried their honey bbq wing sauce and it was so savory. My son had the hot wings and enjoyed those as well! We will be back-keep up the great work!
… moreSeth Skinner
Their hours are the least explicable hours I’ve ever seen in my life. I’ve had to set reminders on my phone to make sense of what’s even happening with them. That being said, it’s probably the best pizza spot overall in town. They just don’t have anything that’s not great, and their prices are very reasonable. This would easily be five stars if their hours of operation were anywhere near acceptable.
… more