Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 86 Vineyard Ave, Highland, NY 12528
Phone: (845) 691-7213
Website: https://www.brenniespizzeria.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Brennie’s Pizzeria – Highland, NY – 86 Vineyard Ave – Hours, Menu …
Brennie’s Pizza · Best Seller. Cheese Pizza. Classic cheese or create your own pizza. $16.95 · Best Seller. Sicilian Pizza. $19.75 · Best Seller. Grandma Pizza.
Brennie’s Pizzeria – 86 Vineyard Ave, Highland, NY 12528 – Slice
Family Specials · Best seller. Small Family Special. 1 large pizza, dozen wings, 2-liter soda, garlic knots, and an order of fried dough. $38.99 · Best seller.
Brennie’s Pizzeria | Highland NY – Facebook
Brennie’s Pizzeria · Brennies pizzeria Super bowl orders do need to be pre-ordered as we will have limited staff 845-691-7213 845-691-8446 · Get your super …
Reviews
Steven James
Meh. Pizza is subpar, lacks flavor and is quite greasy. Nice staff, but unfortunately I don’t see any reason to go back as there are much better offerings just a short distance away.
… moreAmberlea A
We are visiting the area and ordered the large family meal our first night here. It did not disappoint. Absolutely delicious pizza, wings, knots and fried dough. They even walked the order out to my vehicle for me. Extremely friendly and fantastic food. We are still talking about how good it was. Thank you!
… moreTimothy Evans
Unfortunately who ever is making the pies tonight has no clue what they are doing. They made it to big to fit in the pizza box so half of the pie was folded. Wasn’t cooked all the way through and the favor was foul. The place used to be good. Now it sucks like all the other pizza places in Highland Unsatisfied customer to never return.
… moreWesley D
Stopped in, my wife and I were down the road at a hotel. This one got recommended to us, and I’m not disappointed. Great people, great food, and a KILLER price. Love it.
… moreBonnie
Our first visit to this establishment. We were surprised & disappointed when the price they quoted us over the phone turned out to be much higher when we went to pay for our order.
The pie was quite delicious but among the most expensive we’ve paid for a medium size.
We were happy to see this establishment was handicapped accessible which is a plus.
… moreThe pie was quite delicious but among the most expensive we’ve paid for a medium size.
We were happy to see this establishment was handicapped accessible which is a plus.
Paul Hein
My go to for local pizza. There are lots of options but this is in the top 3 for the area. The pizza is always good their dough is top notch. They make lots of different foods as well and the price is reasonable. Always happy to do business with these guys!
… moreTheresa Lutz
Oh my gosh I’ve been hooked on their Pizza it’s just so good you have to try there sausage and peppers pizza and add onions cooked crispy its the best
… moreB.H. H
I dont usually review things so you know this place is bad. To be fair ill only refer to the Pizza. They just dont know how to cook one. Backstory..First Pizza i ever ordered from them was burnt, Called them up and they so “oh, you must want it lightly done, so ask for that next time”. Im thinking in my head, im 60 years old been eating Pizza since i was a kid, never once had to ask for lightly done..but ok. So we did, the next couple of times, the Pizza was ok. Then we got another burnt one, we called and they did send us out another. but when you have to wait another hour..we wernt happy. Another month or two goes by and we order Pizza again last Friday night. and specifically Ordered “Lightly cooked,” well Guess what ..its Frickin Burnt!! Sorry BRENNIES you guys CANNOT COOK A PIZZA!! thats it man 3 strikes your out. I am taking my business elsewhere. Theres other choices for Pizza in Highland and surrounding areas, People go somewhere else.
… moreMarcus Williams
Last night order the special it was the one Pizza pie garlic knots, wings and Fried dough out it also came with a soda. The price was good. Can’t complain about that. The food was not good the pizza, garlic knots and fried dough was chewy did not enjoy it at all. I will give this place another try like I do to other places but not getting the same thing going to try a sandwich of some kind. When I do, I will leave another review review
… moreE Vaitkus
We had the buffalo chicken pizza, ham and pepperoni roll, and the ravioli dinner (yum, with mozzarella cheese and sauce on top). All were excellent. We did a pick-up order, and noticed when we got home that the salad was missing that went with the ravioli dinner. We called, and what seemed like only moments after I put down the phone, the doorbell rang with the salad and bread and apologies delivered — great service!
… more