Hours
| Monday | 4–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Boxcar Pizza | Garrett IN – Facebook
Beautiful ☀️ day! Don’t waste it in the kitchen! Order some ! Open 11am – 10pm 260-357-6666 105 N Randolph St Garrett.
Order Boxcar Pizza – Garrett, IN Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Boxcar Pizza at 105 N Randolph St in Garrett. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Boxcar Pizza | Garrett IN – Facebook
Boxcar Pizza, Garrett. 2382 likes · 185 talking about this · 21 were here. Your hometown pizza place! Home of the Gut Buster pizza! Take out or dine in!…
Reviews
Curtis Carr
First time I’ve visited Boxcar Pizza. Unfortunately, it will be my last. Very underwhelming, run of the mill, pizza. Not impressive. I could jazz up a Tombstone better than that, for half the price. I could go on and on. However, I’ll just say, if you’re looking for a great pizza in Garrett or Auburn area, go to Coterie.
P.S. I picked up. I did not really get to experience the atmosphere. However, it’s not going to make up for the pizza. That’s the reason for the low score on that.
Ordered 2 personal pizzas and the crazy dough.
… moreP.S. I picked up. I did not really get to experience the atmosphere. However, it’s not going to make up for the pizza. That’s the reason for the low score on that.
Ordered 2 personal pizzas and the crazy dough.
Carlee Reed
great pizza, great service! sausage was HUGE and loaded FULL of toppings!! yummy!!
… moreAlisonS. Burge
My first time trying this place, Boxcar pizza. I was super excited, I love trying new places. Called in to place my order, told the girl I had never had it before but I wanted a cheese pizza & breadsticks. After paying almost 28 dollars for 2 items…I get home & check it out. Pizza was ok, not worth the price in my opinion but then see the breadsticks & I thought they made a mistake and gave me a small thin crust pizza instead of bread sticks so I called them nope thats what they consider breadsticks. I’ve never had such a thin breadsticks nor with cheese just automatically on them. Come to find out after calling they don’t even have “real” breadsticks. Girl just said sorry. No offer to give my money back or give me a different item since I paid for something they don’t even sell. So 28 bucks pretty much down the drain. Customer service is pretty much key to a business. If they would have done me right I probably would consider going there again, maybe. Never, ever again so good luck if u try them 🙂
… moreZachary Preuss
A cozy restaurant filled with tasteful memorabilia of the trains of old.
Got the Mic pizza, a pizza similar in taste and flavor with a big Mac. Delightful and portioned well for the price.
Will definitely support this business going forward. A must revisit to try their Chicago style pizza next.
… moreGot the Mic pizza, a pizza similar in taste and flavor with a big Mac. Delightful and portioned well for the price.
Will definitely support this business going forward. A must revisit to try their Chicago style pizza next.
beverly gunion
Had the supreme pizza today. Picked up. I have to say it was hot and I ofctge best pizzas we’ve ever had. Worth every penny
… moreRyan C
I ordered a Chicago style 2 topping from here, and it was great. Compared to Timmy’s, it is more expensive, but much heftier. Three slices from Timmys and I am full. I barely got 2 slices before I was done. Highly recommend!
… moreKyle Mannikko
We got the chicken bacon ranch deep dish pizza and it was amazing! The staff was very friendly!
… morenathan bowker
Pizza is amazing, and a nice little place to dine in. Very friendly staff. Will definitely be back for more!
… morecameran spence
$50 for pepperoni pizza, mac pizza and 6 wings
Floppy thin crust barely any pepperoni, mac pizza no sorry, wings rubber, far from a good smoked wing.
… moreFloppy thin crust barely any pepperoni, mac pizza no sorry, wings rubber, far from a good smoked wing.
Trever Rhodes
Decided to try them for dinner tonight. Greeted with a smiling face when I walked in the door. I ordered a 12” chicken bacon ranch and an order of crazy dough. Both were delish. This is my new go to pizza place!
… more