Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2 Van Derveer St, Amsterdam, NY 12010
Phone: (518) 842-7780
Website: https://www.facebook.com/p/Bottistis-Pizzeria-100063657004730/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bottisti’s Pizzeria | Amsterdam NY – Facebook
Bottisti’s Pizzeria. Family owned and operated Italian Restaurant with Quality ingredients and fair pricing. Pizza place · $$ · (518) 842-7780. .
Bottisti’s Pizzeria, 2 Van Derveer St, Amsterdam, NY 12010, US
Bottisti’s Pizzeria, nestled in the heart of Amsterdam, NY, beckons pizza enthusiasts with its mouthwatering aroma and inviting ambiance.
Bottisti’s Pizzeria – Montgomery County
Bottisti’s Pizzeria. Family owned and operated Italian Restaurant with … Amsterdam, NY 12010. Central New York Logo.
Reviews
iMacOfDeath
A real classic feeling pizzeria.
Walked past this location a few times and was always curious how it looked inside, well a couple years since that first time I passed by it and I’ve finally picked Bottisti’s as my Friday dinner and got to see.
Ordered over the phone going with a 6-slice Sicilian Style with Mushrooms, Peppers, Onions, Meatballs, and Ricotta cheese. Altogether coming to just over $25, a price you’d expect from a much larger pizza but I loaded on the toppings so this was to be expected.
Finally I got to see inside and I was not disappointed. It was like I walked back in time to a far more simpler time, with memories from childhood of classic pizza joints springing up. Italian themed decorations, homely seating area, and a kitchen that was easy to see into. Really liked it, totally want to come back and dine in sometime. But I was here for takeout, so I paid for my pie and was back home.
Opening up the box told me I was in for a good time. Nice thick looking pizza crust, my toppings heaping across the pie, cheese and sauce still showing through, and a delightful smell. First bite I was able to get it all in and it rocked, a slight crunch to the crust but not super tough, the sauce was a little sweet but this was good as it countered the more savory cheese, the toppings weighed down each slice adding in the spicy meat, the dry ricotta splotches, and mix of vegetables adding in a ton of body. Delicious.
Overall I was not disappointed at all in any aspect of this meal. A reasonable price, friendly service, a real quaint location, and the pie itself nailing everything I wanted.
… moreWalked past this location a few times and was always curious how it looked inside, well a couple years since that first time I passed by it and I’ve finally picked Bottisti’s as my Friday dinner and got to see.
Ordered over the phone going with a 6-slice Sicilian Style with Mushrooms, Peppers, Onions, Meatballs, and Ricotta cheese. Altogether coming to just over $25, a price you’d expect from a much larger pizza but I loaded on the toppings so this was to be expected.
Finally I got to see inside and I was not disappointed. It was like I walked back in time to a far more simpler time, with memories from childhood of classic pizza joints springing up. Italian themed decorations, homely seating area, and a kitchen that was easy to see into. Really liked it, totally want to come back and dine in sometime. But I was here for takeout, so I paid for my pie and was back home.
Opening up the box told me I was in for a good time. Nice thick looking pizza crust, my toppings heaping across the pie, cheese and sauce still showing through, and a delightful smell. First bite I was able to get it all in and it rocked, a slight crunch to the crust but not super tough, the sauce was a little sweet but this was good as it countered the more savory cheese, the toppings weighed down each slice adding in the spicy meat, the dry ricotta splotches, and mix of vegetables adding in a ton of body. Delicious.
Overall I was not disappointed at all in any aspect of this meal. A reasonable price, friendly service, a real quaint location, and the pie itself nailing everything I wanted.
Sal’s Maintenance Solutions
This pizza is delicious. I ordered a pie with extra cheese, mushrooms, and sausage. Everything tasted fresh and the crust is thin and crisp, not doughy. I would definitely recommend this place for pizza. Can’t wait to try other items on the menu. Speaking of menu, it’s kind of difficult to find one online. However, if you go to their Facebook, you’ll find some information on what they sell there. Also, orders will take approximately 35 to 45 minutes. They’re busy at times. I don’t blame them, it’s that good.
… moreJosh Leone
Best Pizza in the 518 when done correctly, thin round cheese pizza always hits.
… moreStewarts Pond
WHAT A DINNER !! Our church group had dinner on Sunday at the restaurant and it was a absolute pleasure from the start. The servers, cooks were pleasant and friendly and Oh the food! Recently went to Olive Garden and there is no comparison, the portions were huge, Tastes fabulous and reasonably priced. Been going for a couple of years but this dinner experience tops its.
… moreMary Jane
My husband wanted the biggest circular pizza they had and this was what he got for roughly $30! Bacon and pepperoni for toppings… you can’t beat that price! What a deal! This place has the best pizza in town! Thanks Bottisti’s!
… moreJeffrey Bagdon
Grew up on this pizza in the 70s and 80s moved south and been all over the world. I think this is the best in the world bar none NYC and ROME included. The sausage is something else.
… moreSue Pacillo
YOU WILL NOT BE DISAPPOINTED!
We hadn’t been to Bottisti’s years.
Then in May 2025, we meet Justin Bottisti.
He told us he was working there now and the whole place had had a new look. and Pizza was back!!!
And, Boy was he right. The pizza was so good my husband n I ended getting it several times( so far) .
Thx, Justin and the whole staff,
You are all doing a great job!
Sue n Nick Pacillo
… moreWe hadn’t been to Bottisti’s years.
Then in May 2025, we meet Justin Bottisti.
He told us he was working there now and the whole place had had a new look. and Pizza was back!!!
And, Boy was he right. The pizza was so good my husband n I ended getting it several times( so far) .
Thx, Justin and the whole staff,
You are all doing a great job!
Sue n Nick Pacillo
Kevin Reilly
My wife is from Amsterdam we live in queensbury now. So when passing thru we usually stop and get pizza. Who wouldn’t want a great slice from a get place. Well staffed and great pizza!!
… moreR Scott
Since I was a young boy growing up in the city of Amsterdam Bottisti, pizza has always been the go to for consistency and a great pizza. Since his dad started the business many years ago. Gary has kept the greatness of pizza going never changing always the same. Great delicious pizza.
… moreBrittany Macfie
Pizza is so so good! Girls inside were friendly!
… more