Dr. Mark Lindholm
One of the Best in Elkhart! We had a large family gathering and ordered 5 pizzas from Boomerelli’s and it was great. We are fortunate to have a number of great Italian restaurants in Elkhart so to say Boomerelli’s is one of the best pizzas I’ve had is very high praise.
Thinner flakier crust than other pizza in town. The sausage had great flavor and the spices in general were good without being over done.
… moreDave Pestrak
This little restaurant is probably a tiny kept secret, but I’ve heard that their lunch business from local factories is very strong. And we saw a ton of carryout orders come & go while we dined in.
We went for a pizza, which was great! Cheese was just right, sauce was a spicy (not sweet) pizza sauce. The crust was good and cooked just right. We asked for half one way, and half a different way and they did a great job at making sure they didn’t cross over. Square cut, which was a pleasant rarity.
The owner/manager/boss was not someone we met, but you could tell they cared about customers and their satisfaction. There was a delay with our order and they took good care of us. Far too good care of us IMO.
Jenna our server, was friendly and just the right amount of conversational. The decorating was not hip or trendy, it just looked like a little restaurant in the country.
Overall, heck yes we will be going back, for the food and the service which were both exceptional.
… moreRocki Stillson
From the outside you wouldnt think that this place had great pizza – to be blunt, the inside does not look any better. You probably wouldn’t know it was even there since there is not much retail around it. But if you decide to try it …you might be glad you did. Good pizza and good price…a surprise.
… moreCarol Kruggel
Amazing homemade pizza, crust slightly crispy, sauce has great flavor. Service has always been excellent.
… moreKarla Simmons
The everything pizza is amazing! Very friendly place with a home feel
… moreJudi H
A Chicago native, this pizza tastes like home. The thinness of the crust and authentic ingredients are great!! Wish we found them sooner. Our son from Detroit picks their pizza over my homemade calzones.
… moreArmando Gutierrez
We gave this place two tries and never again. The cheesy bacon hotdog comes with a slice of processed American cheese all hard on top of it with microwave bacon. I could’ve made it at home if I knew it was gonna be like that. The pizza is also taste like something I could’ve got from the freezer aisle. Very disappointed
… moreChris P
Delicious Italian food. Good price. Friendly staff. I usually get it to go. Dining room clean but lacking. Limited days is also unfortunate. Will continue to go back!
… moreJered Spansell
Real solid pizza. This was the first time we tried them. The toppings are 5 star. The crust could have more flavor. The texture was good. Too much flour under the crust. Great pizza overall.
… moreBruce Cluckie
The pizza was really good and it came out quickly. It was unique, not the cookie-cutter kind you expect everywhere in the big-name places. But still very good pizza. The garlic-cheese bread was better than elsewhere. The staff was welcoming and friendly. And the prices are less than expected – a good value for sure. The location is a bit off of the main drag but definitely worth going to. We were glad to have chosen Boomerelli’s.
… more