Andrew Galida Jr.
When you open the box the pizza looks really good. Undercarriage is good. There is absolutely no taste on the plain pie. I’d recommend putting more tomato sauce on and add more seasoning. Dave Portnoy gave it a 7.9. Definitely not that score. Needs some work for sure. Solid 5.0. Who knows dine in may be better!
… moreIsaiah L
Great overall slice, you get a 6th of a pie for 4$ which honestly is really great. The taste was pretty decent; nothing too special but nothing too bad. It did have a great crisp and undercarriage, and is overall a great slice.
I came in soon after they opened and didn’t have the time to wait for a new pie, so I ended up getting just 3 plain slices which came out bubbling hot.
The inside is unassuming with minimal decor and a couple of chairs, but still has a clean feel to it. The people inside were nice as well, creating a nice atmosphere.
Overall, this place is a great spot for a great slice. If you’re in the area, I would recommend to check it out.
… moredj smith
2nd location? How lol. Surf city pizza is better. If you want good pizza, visit the mainland or another place as the owner isn’t about quality or taste, just about the money. Over priced and limited hours, food isn’t consistent etc.
… moreJRP
Amazing toppings, sauce and crust. Best pizza on the island!! Grandma pie is incredible – sauce is so delicious and crust crisp and perfect. The people saying it’s frozen or bad are delusional. It’s a huge upgrade to the pizza culture on LBI. Hours are limited and sometimes the website says they aren’t taking orders when they are – best to call. No real place to eat inside – takeaway only.
… moreWilliam Coonan
Got two pies. Plain cheese and pepperoni. Horrible! Way overcooked. Pepperoni was burnt. Couldn’t even slice through pizzas the bottom was so over cooked. Trouble BITING through pizza bottom it was so hard. Severely disappointed. A waste of $50. We ate 4 slices out 16 and the rest went into the trash. and didn’t even finish those 4…
… moreNicole Marie
This is possibly the worst pizzaria I’ve ever been to and I’ve been to a LOT. Not only is the pizza dry and tasteless, the place is filthy and the owner is rude. I don’t know what happened here but BLVD pizza has gone WAY downhill.
… moreMorgan
Have been coming to LBI for 10+ years and this is easily the best pizza on the island — and I don’t say that lightly! The Jersey Plum is HEAVENLY and the staff couldn’t have been nicer!
… moreJohn LaBarca DDS
Best pizza on LBI!!! Reminds me of a large New Haven style! Crisp bottom, tender and bubbly under the sauce!
… moreVikram Arora
Stumbled upon BLVD Pizza. It’s a hole in the wall but man, was I delighted!
Ordered a pepperoni slice of “Brooklyn’s Finest’ and finest it indeed was! Have never had a pizza as crisp as this one! Super delicious! Very much recommended.
… moreDavid Mikulka
Even on a holiday weekend, they turned out an absolutely outstanding pizza – fresh ingredients, perfectly crispy crust. Best pizza on LBI and one of the best I’ve had anywhere!
… more