4.5 – 371 reviews • Fine dining restaurant
Seafood & steaks are the specialties of this polished, maritime-themed eatery with a piano lounge.
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reviews
Katrina Molloy
The food was delicious. I had the lobster bisque and king crab legs with butter pecan pie for dessert – all to die for. My husband had french onion soup, surf and turf, and the cheesecake and loved it all as well.
Very attentive, formal service that you don’t find in many places these days – I never had to ask for a thing as someone was always right there anticipating my needs.
The price point is on the higher end (especially if you order king crab) but I felt it was worth the quality of food and service.
Will dine again!
… moreMarc Robyn D.L
Decent steak house. Nice atmosphere. Nothing out of the ordinary or impressive and the food was kind of bland.
Table side ceaser salad was decent but nothing to brag about. The check is not itemized and just says food and liquor. Technically you dont really know what your paying for. And if you ask for a breakdown of your bill, they will get upset and tell you there register is from the 80s.
Good spot to check out once but I wouldn’t go again.
… moreHappy Vaughan
Had an amazing dinner!
Shout out to the amazing experienced staff. They were all dressed in suits and were long time employees. One gentleman said he had been there for 49 years and made us a Caesar salad right at our table including fresh made salad dressing.
Sam was our main waiter and was great with a great personality. They were all very attentive and made sure we were well looked after.
… moreKD A
Outstanding experience! The service was exceptional, the staff warm and welcoming, and the food superb. My husband and I celebrated our anniversary in St. Catharines and discovered The Blue Mermaid by chance—absolutely delicious. We will definitely be back!”
… moreCarson Kaufman
Best dining experience in Niagara! Always a special time here, unbelievable service and food. You can’t get a better steak anywhere else!
… moreLorrie Goldman
Another wonderful dining experience here at the Blue Mermaid. The whole staff was warm and welcoming and the food was outstanding. Our waiter Gus was nothing less than spectacular in every way. Please trust me you won’t be disappointed.
… moreMandie Purdy
Wow! Best meal, service and atmosphere I have ever experienced in the Niagara Region. They treat you like royalty no matter who you are. The food was out of this world and I just loved the restaurant itself. Outside isn’t much to look at but once inside, just wow. First class. Can’t wait for next years birthday!
… moreAlejandra Bauer
Great, local white table cloth steakhouse in St. Catharines. Personally preferred the laid-back lounge, but apparently that’s been closed. Nevertheless, they’ve brought the piano upstairs to create a cozier atmosphere. We thoroughly enjoyed our appetizers and mains; however would have preferred the gravy on the side. Otherwise, another delightful evening at Blue Mermaid.
… moreSamantha Sielicki
My fiancé and I just celebrated our birthdays at the Blue Mermaid. The food was delicious, the atmosphere was lovely, and the best part… the service! Our waiter, Gus, was fantastic. He made our experience even more enjoyable. Thank you, Gus!
… moreDerek Rankin
Simply amazing …incredible food and always entertaining with Gus,Nick and the late Tom . We are a long time customer 25 + years and look forward to many more !
… more … View more