Address and Contact Information
Address: 50 Buffalo St Suite 300, Hamburg, NY 14075
Phone: (716) 388-1775
Website: https://www.blueeyedbaker.net/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Hamburg Location – Blue Eyed Baker
At the heart of Hamburg, NY · ONLINE TAKEOUT + DELIVERY · CUSTOM ORDERS · MENUS.
Blue Eyed Baker
LIVE MUSIC WITH BELLO STUDIOS AT HAMBURG … At Blue Eyed Baker, “homemade” isn’t just a buzzword. It is the foundation of every single bite and sip you take.
Day Cafe // Rooftop Restaurant + Bar. (@blue.eyed.baker) – Instagram
17K followers · 2.3K+ posts · EA + Hamburg bakery | breakfast | lunch | dinner | dessert handcrafted espresso bevs + cocktails. classes, events + more.
Reviews
Melissa Schlierf
The macrons were absolutely delicious! My husband ordered the BLT. He liked it except the bacon was deep fried and not from a grill.
Overall this place was a delight. We will definitely be back.
… moreOverall this place was a delight. We will definitely be back.
Zack Schneider
Blue Eye Bakers’ Hamburg location is firing on almost all cylinders—exceptional food, stellar coffee, and a staff that actually cares. Just maybe invest in a kitchen door.
Pre-Bills game breakfast with my sons Enzo and August has become something of a ritual, and the new Hamburg outpost of Blue Eye Bakers seemed like the perfect spot to fuel up before watching our team do their thing. We snagged seats at the bar, ready to carb-load with purpose.
The food? Outstanding. The kind of breakfast that makes you wonder why you ever settled for mediocre eggs. The coffee hit exactly right—strong enough to make you feel like you can take on the day, smooth enough that you want another cup. Their drinks menu shows the same thoughtfulness, and the staff brought that rare combination of attentive service and genuine warmth that you can’t fake.
Here’s where my inner operator kicks in. While we’re settling in, the restaurant starts their early wrap-up (game day protocols, totally understandable), but there’s this bizarre audio situation happening. Kitchen music. Dining room music. Both competing for dominance in the same acoustic space. It’s like someone forgot that sound travels, or that customers can hear multiple sources at once.
When I mentioned it? Got the casual shrug. The “yeah, I hear you, but I’m not doing anything about it” shrug. Look, I get it—it’s not life or death. But when you’re executing at such a high level everywhere else, this kind of easily fixable atmospheric fumble stands out. Close the kitchen door. Turn something down. Run a single playlist through the whole space. This is Hospitality 101, not quantum physics.
Blue Eye Bakers Hamburg is doing almost everything right, which makes the audio oversight more frustrating than if they were generally sloppy. This is a team that clearly knows how to deliver—they just need someone to care about the details the same way they care about the food.
Would I go back? Absolutely. Would I hope they’ve sorted out the competing DJ situation? Also absolutely.
… morePre-Bills game breakfast with my sons Enzo and August has become something of a ritual, and the new Hamburg outpost of Blue Eye Bakers seemed like the perfect spot to fuel up before watching our team do their thing. We snagged seats at the bar, ready to carb-load with purpose.
The food? Outstanding. The kind of breakfast that makes you wonder why you ever settled for mediocre eggs. The coffee hit exactly right—strong enough to make you feel like you can take on the day, smooth enough that you want another cup. Their drinks menu shows the same thoughtfulness, and the staff brought that rare combination of attentive service and genuine warmth that you can’t fake.
Here’s where my inner operator kicks in. While we’re settling in, the restaurant starts their early wrap-up (game day protocols, totally understandable), but there’s this bizarre audio situation happening. Kitchen music. Dining room music. Both competing for dominance in the same acoustic space. It’s like someone forgot that sound travels, or that customers can hear multiple sources at once.
When I mentioned it? Got the casual shrug. The “yeah, I hear you, but I’m not doing anything about it” shrug. Look, I get it—it’s not life or death. But when you’re executing at such a high level everywhere else, this kind of easily fixable atmospheric fumble stands out. Close the kitchen door. Turn something down. Run a single playlist through the whole space. This is Hospitality 101, not quantum physics.
Blue Eye Bakers Hamburg is doing almost everything right, which makes the audio oversight more frustrating than if they were generally sloppy. This is a team that clearly knows how to deliver—they just need someone to care about the details the same way they care about the food.
Would I go back? Absolutely. Would I hope they’ve sorted out the competing DJ situation? Also absolutely.
Sam Morgan
From breakfast to lunch to dessert-we love BEB! Just had our first cocktails and they were delish. We love their kids space too. This is a new location and it seems people have been way too quick to judge. Don’t complain about what they don’t have and try something new! I have never been disappointed in their quality or service. Can’t wait to keep coming back
… moreMarc Dombrowski
We had the Eggs Benedict on a croissant and it was fantastic! Also the Pork Belly Hash….all so good
… moreEmily Abbey
Loved the chocolate cupcake with raspberry frosting. I got 4 different cupcakes to try. Your frosting does not need sugar crystals I would reconsider adding those again. Very good flavor nonetheless and would recommend
… moresilo5051
I have been to this location 3 times since it opened in october/november of 2025 and I have been more disappointed each time I visit. I can understand that a new launch will have growing pains but this is a second location so those problems should mosty be figured out at this point. When considering that and the prices, I feel compelled to voice my frustration as a consumer.
The biggest issue I have is a lack of care from the staff as evidenced by:
Issue #1- I arrived at around 1:00pm on monday 12/29 and was able to walk right up to the counter and ask for a plain bagel toasted with cream cheese. I was told by the cashier that they did not have any bagels left and that they did not know when more would be coming out. I was disappointed so the cashier offered that I could purchase a gluten free bagel which she told me are kept in the back and not put in the up front display cases. I am not gluten free and thought it was odd to not have them out with the other bagels but I figured I would give it a shot. Please see the attached screenshots for what I recieved for $7.25. The google ai suggested caption for this is “plain baked round bread”. It appears that I was sold an untoasted hamburger bun and the person making this did not even soften the cream cheese so that it would spread correctly.
Issue #2- I ordered a 20oz light roast drip coffee black and a 16oz chai latte. The cashier asked if I wanted these to go which I confirmed yes, please make them to go. The chai latte was interpreted by the barista to be an online order and was placed on the online order rack where it would sit for 15 minutes while the kitchen processed my bun. It was only until I asked the cashier for an update on my drinks that the barista and the cashier realized that no one made the drip coffee and that the chai on the rack was actually for me.
My past experiences have been very similiar to this and I will not be coming back until I know they have made some improvements in these areas.
… moreThe biggest issue I have is a lack of care from the staff as evidenced by:
Issue #1- I arrived at around 1:00pm on monday 12/29 and was able to walk right up to the counter and ask for a plain bagel toasted with cream cheese. I was told by the cashier that they did not have any bagels left and that they did not know when more would be coming out. I was disappointed so the cashier offered that I could purchase a gluten free bagel which she told me are kept in the back and not put in the up front display cases. I am not gluten free and thought it was odd to not have them out with the other bagels but I figured I would give it a shot. Please see the attached screenshots for what I recieved for $7.25. The google ai suggested caption for this is “plain baked round bread”. It appears that I was sold an untoasted hamburger bun and the person making this did not even soften the cream cheese so that it would spread correctly.
Issue #2- I ordered a 20oz light roast drip coffee black and a 16oz chai latte. The cashier asked if I wanted these to go which I confirmed yes, please make them to go. The chai latte was interpreted by the barista to be an online order and was placed on the online order rack where it would sit for 15 minutes while the kitchen processed my bun. It was only until I asked the cashier for an update on my drinks that the barista and the cashier realized that no one made the drip coffee and that the chai on the rack was actually for me.
My past experiences have been very similiar to this and I will not be coming back until I know they have made some improvements in these areas.
B
Many items listed on the menu in store were “unavailable”. It was not posted anywhere and we were only informed when we tried to order. Made ordering a little difficult as we had to run though a few different sandwich options before landing on a pizza. Pizza was good. Poor cashier seemed new. Seating is tight. Hamburg location
… moreJason Ashton
They have tons of treat options including some gluten free options. They also have tons of coffee options along with a bar. First time we were there was when they first opened and the people working didn’t call out to let us know our coffees were done and sitting on the counter right in front of where we were standing. We waited for quite a bit while 3 employees were there standing and talking. It wasn’t until the woman who checked us out came over to ask them about something that she realized we were still there and figured out that our coffees were there. I caulk that up to its hard to find good help and maybe they were new.
The second time there were no issues at all but a lot less busy. We will be going back soon. Check it out.
… moreThe second time there were no issues at all but a lot less busy. We will be going back soon. Check it out.
Matthew Latawiec
Very disappointed with our experience.
Came in around 2pm for a breakfast sandwich and coffee. After 40 minutes, the breakfast sandwich never arrived.
Was trying to be respectful of the kitchen if they were busy. Went up to the cashier to ask if the order was ready. She went back to the kitchen. Came back and said oops something wrong with our system. Printed a new ticket and walked it back to the kitchen. Said it would be out in 2 minutes. No apologies. Waited another 5 minutes, croissant cold, food presentation very poor and placed in a to go container since it was now closing time.
… moreCame in around 2pm for a breakfast sandwich and coffee. After 40 minutes, the breakfast sandwich never arrived.
Was trying to be respectful of the kitchen if they were busy. Went up to the cashier to ask if the order was ready. She went back to the kitchen. Came back and said oops something wrong with our system. Printed a new ticket and walked it back to the kitchen. Said it would be out in 2 minutes. No apologies. Waited another 5 minutes, croissant cold, food presentation very poor and placed in a to go container since it was now closing time.
Adam Hintz
I wish I had a better experience.
Showed up at 5:30 on Sat 12/20. I drove past the first time because the sign is not illuminated in any way and the storefront itself was quite dark. Not ideal for a business open until 10 or 11pm.
But that wasn’t really my big complaint. I looked over the menu and decided to order a pizza. At that moment, the kitchen yelled “no more pizzas!”
At 5:30, this is more than half the menu. And it was still hours ahead of an 11pm close time. And the menu suggested the menu was available “-close.”
I went elsewhere. Disappointing outcome.
… moreShowed up at 5:30 on Sat 12/20. I drove past the first time because the sign is not illuminated in any way and the storefront itself was quite dark. Not ideal for a business open until 10 or 11pm.
But that wasn’t really my big complaint. I looked over the menu and decided to order a pizza. At that moment, the kitchen yelled “no more pizzas!”
At 5:30, this is more than half the menu. And it was still hours ahead of an 11pm close time. And the menu suggested the menu was available “-close.”
I went elsewhere. Disappointing outcome.