Kristen
Local establishment that never disappoints. Generous pours, great menu and food. Pizza’s are their specialty. Very cool atmosphere. Jukebox, ATM, keno. Multiple TV’s for watching games. Great place to watch Superbowl. Outside is a pet friendly secure area patio area.
… moreDiane Fox
We live near by and friends have been telling us to go here for pizza. We finally stopped in for dinner and we were glad we did. The waitress was so friendly. Her reccomendations were spot on. My husband’s martini was perfect. Really enjoyed the patty melt and the pizza was the best we have had in a long time. We will definetly be back!
… moreLauren Jonielunas
If you blink, you’ll miss it, but that’s half the charm. Once you grab a seat, order a drink, and take a bite of the pizza, you’ll wonder why you ever went anywhere else.
The bar itself is no-frills: dim lighting, and locals who look like they’ve been coming here for decades. But the pizza? Absolute magic. Crispy, slightly charred crust, just the right amount of cheese, and toppings that taste way fresher than you’d expect from a place where the beer is cheaper than water.
It’s the kind of spot you almost don’t want to tell anyone about, but the pizza deserves the spotlight. If you’re into character, cold drinks, and food that blows expectations out of the water, this hole-in-the-wall might just be your new favorite place.
… moreJoel Bernier
Super bowl pregame meal, great energy, the food was really tasty, fresh tasting, though waitstaff was over taxed for time. Was overall a very good experience definitely coming back more often! Patty melt, the black sheep cheese burger, Chicken Caesar salad, chili cheese fries, yum! The drinks were well poured, the price was moderate! We are coming back again!
… moreJesse Algarin
Our first time here, we asked the bartender / waitress a couple questions about the menu we decided on homemade Cheeseburger pizza & 2 cocktails. The pizza was outstanding one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had nice crust crispy on the bottom.
… moreGeorge K
Great spot to stop in and pick up food to take home. I work nearby but live 35 minutes away. The pizza is always a hit at home. Servers are friendly and accommodating.
… moreHeather Piper
Tonight we ate nachos with chili. Really good. Chili was flavorful. Also tried the BBQ bacon chicken pizza. All I can say is wow!!!
… morebrian paxton
a friend has been raving about the pizza here for a while i finally was in the area and gave it a try i would have to say its probably the best pizza i have had in a long time and would highly recommend it to anyone.
… moreLee Roberts
Food was great and we had different entrees. Molly the server had good recommendations. Great maple cream brûlée. We had 2 innkeepers recommend and understand why.
… moreEric B
Outstanding tavern in Sterling. If you’re out and about and want good food, a fun atmosphere, and you don’t want to break the bank, Black Sheep Tavern is your destination. The bar has 20 seats and 5 tvs, and there are plenty of tables to seat your family or your team. Enjoy some Keno. Big parking lot.
… more