Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Steaks, seafood, pasta & specialty cocktails served in modern, beach-themed surrounds with a patio.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 265 E Marina Cove Dr, St. Augustine, FL 32080
Phone: (904) 547-2723
Website: http://theblackmollygrill.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Black Molly Grill
Black Molly Grill is located in on Anastasia Island, nestled between State Road 312 and the Antigua Subdivision in St. Augustine. Owners Jason Hamilton and Ryan …
The Black Molly Grill | Saint Augustine FL – Facebook
No photo description available. 128 · 11 · 5. The Black Molly Grill. Nov 26, 2025 . . No photo description available. 311 · …
The Black Molly Grill – St Augustine, FL on OpenTable
Get menu, photos and location information for The Black Molly Grill in St Augustine, FL. Or book now at one of our other 2002 great restaurants in St …
Reviews
donna lamont
Excellent across the board. Great food and great prices. Best trout almondine I ever had. It was a lunch special and oh my was it good. Our favorite restaurant in the Anastasia area of St. Augustine. A must visit if you are in the area. We are looking forward to our visit in September for the James Taylor concert.
… moreTrevor DeHaan
Absolutely amazing place, awesome decor very chill vibes and the stuffed mushrooms were amazing. Jay our server was very busy, but we weren’t in a rush and he was very attentive. The steak was to die for absolutely the best steak I think I’ve ever had. Cooked to perfection with so much flavor. Definitely going back in the future to try some different entrées.
… moreRuud Noordzij
Super! Colin was our server, he was extremely witty and helpful. Same for Laree that filled us in on the amount of shrimp in the shrimp and grit cakes. And yes, we ordered those and the red (drum) fish. Pear sangrias as our drinks that were delicious as they were not overly sweet. Food was awesome, the cakes firm, shrimps better than the ones at the Reef Restaurant in the same town but that restaurant has the better sauce and cakes. Red Drum, super flaky and fresh, beet and broccoli salads fresh, crunchy and tasty. Lastly, the restaurant has beautiful art hanging on the walls and I’ll add a few in this review. 10/10, highly recommended.
… moreHarold Labelle
They have a happy hour special, buy one get one free on certain drafts, house wines and most cocktails. You can’t beat that! We all had burgers and they were fantastic! Great wait staff, food and drinks amazing. Took a long time to get a drink.
… moreNikki D
It was a great experience! The food was amazing. It was busy when we arrived, but the wait was short—less than 15 minutes. The mahi mahi was absolutely delicious, while the Datil chicken was okay. Definitely loved the seafood more than the chicken!
Service was great as well—our server kept checking on us and was very attentive. Overall, the ambience was really nice too.
Highly recommend!
… moreService was great as well—our server kept checking on us and was very attentive. Overall, the ambience was really nice too.
Highly recommend!
Wesley Cover
New in town and we gad heard great things about Black Molly Grill. We absolutely loved it!! The food was incredible and the service was top notch and the prices were more affordable than most places. Top rated restaurant to visit!!!!
… moreDouglas L.
So here is the deal St. Augustine, when it comes down to unimaginable flavors prepared perfectly every time, outstanding service and a great atmosphere, Black Molly Grill never misses. If you live here and aren’t eating here regularly, what are you doing with your life? Go right now!
All fun aside, great restaurant that delivers the best this area has to offer and has a staff that is second to none.
… moreAll fun aside, great restaurant that delivers the best this area has to offer and has a staff that is second to none.
Teona Goebel
Never have I ever been more happy that my back needed an adjustment than this week. Went in for an adjustment and got a recommendation to try this spot. OH MY GOODNESS!!! We were soooo delighted!!!
Only a short 5 min wait, then we were seated. The steaks were what were touted. Because we went there at lunch, they presented the lunch menu, but ask for the dinner menu to get this baby! Note, only lunch sides are available at lunch. Back to the steak!!!
So delicious and flavorful!! The dry rub created a crust with magic in every bite. Hubby took the first bite, and immediately was like, bump everything else – EAT THE STEAK!!!
The choice was close, but I still enjoyed my salad – get the house dressing!! But the steak, people, get the steak. Come here quick, fast and hungry! I normally can’t finish all my food but I devoured the 12oz mass of flavor. Because it was juicy, flavorful and cooked too perfection, I had no choice!! Our tummy was so full when we left!!
If we can make one recommendation, it would be to open a location in Columbus, GA!
… moreOnly a short 5 min wait, then we were seated. The steaks were what were touted. Because we went there at lunch, they presented the lunch menu, but ask for the dinner menu to get this baby! Note, only lunch sides are available at lunch. Back to the steak!!!
So delicious and flavorful!! The dry rub created a crust with magic in every bite. Hubby took the first bite, and immediately was like, bump everything else – EAT THE STEAK!!!
The choice was close, but I still enjoyed my salad – get the house dressing!! But the steak, people, get the steak. Come here quick, fast and hungry! I normally can’t finish all my food but I devoured the 12oz mass of flavor. Because it was juicy, flavorful and cooked too perfection, I had no choice!! Our tummy was so full when we left!!
If we can make one recommendation, it would be to open a location in Columbus, GA!
Mark Hoffman
We finally decided to give this place a try! After a small wait, we were seated & what seemed to be a good experience- when down hill quick – our service was initially good – then we got to see things other tables were getting- my wife’s drink was empty for most of her meal – thank goodness we called right away & found out that our 1st experience was not typical- Maria quickly took the blame & offered us a return visit- so I will update this after our next time- food was very tasty & the spinach artichoke dip was one of the best we have had! Her salmon was excellent & my pasta was quite loaded
… moremaria jones
I don’t usually do this and but the way the host reacted to my matter was very unacceptable so here I am to make sure whoever eats here is aware. Yesterday evening I went to lunch with my coworkers and we had ordered several appetizers and I ordered chicken tenders & my lovely waitress Sarah allowed me to get something off the kids menu since due to my diet I couldn’t eat the other options they offered ( very grateful she accommodated me) well since we had so many appetizers I was super full and didn’t get to finish eating my actual meal. So we left and went on about our day. So maybe an hour later I started to get hungry and went to eat my leftovers. Well as I’m eating the food I noticed the chicken was very rubbery and I looked down and see this ! This honestly is my worst fear !! So I panicked because I had eaten some of the raw chicken already. I immediately spit it out and contacted Black Molly. Very calm after witnessing that I informed the host who picked up the phone what I encountered & you wanna know what her approach was ? She began questioning me as if I was lying about what I ordered. “ are you sure you had chicken tenders because that on the kids menu “ “ maybe it was something else you had?” I proceed to advise her it was the chicken tenders and my lovely waitress allowed me to get it due to my diet. Instead of apologizing for what I experience she continued to question me about what I was telling her. As if I’m lying about getting chin tenders. Which was highly unacceptable. So she gives the phone to a manger and his name was Robert sweet guy he immediately took accountability and apologized for what I experienced and offered to take it off the bill and stated he would speak to her about her behavior and make sure his cook was aware. Now guys I wasn’t frustrated or upset !! I was very calm and understanding of the situation things happen it wasn’t the end of the world. But for the host to treat me that way was upsetting. So overall I won’t be eating here ever again !
… more