Adam Piede
Best Pizza within 50+ miles. You simply won’t find a better pizza around. Great wings too. Top it off with a beautiful lake & marina setting.
Chad, Kelly & staff were great and very hospitable to my family & I.
We’ll be back!
… moreAlexander Harris
Chad and Kelly are the best. They’re making delicious pizza and wings (Chad is the chicken wing king) are on the menu by July 4th. We tried the cheese and white pizza. The white was out of this world good, we will be back for sure l. Recommend this local favorite to everyone on the lake!!
… moreLori Harvey
We go here quite frequently, we have taken our Youth group to enjoy the pizza and the lake. It is great to go somewhere that has Gluten Free pizza that doesn’t look like a personal pan pizza. Their flavors are so good, we have not been disappointed!! Great job guys!
… moreKristi Caudell
Billy Goat Island Pizza is that fun local spot you find yourself craving all week long. Chad and Kelly have created a place that feels relaxed and welcoming the second you walk in. It is the kind of pizza joint where you can roll in after a day on the water, grab a table with your people, and just enjoy really great food in a laid back atmosphere.
The star of the show for me is the Farmers Cheese Dip. Wowzer. It is one of those appetizers you think you are going to share, then suddenly you are guarding it with your life. And the Billy Goat pizza with hot honey is next level. Omg. Perfectly balanced, a little sweet, a little heat, and so much flavor. It is easily one of my favorite pizzas anywhere.
It is also the best place to watch football. Game days here are so much fun. Great energy and the kind of crowd that makes every big play feel even better when you are celebrating over amazing pizza and cold drinks.
Kelly is the sweetest. She was kind enough to special order my St Germain, which tells you everything you need to know about how they treat their customers. That kind of thoughtfulness and personal touch is rare and it keeps us coming back again and again.
… moreTerry Cape
Wood fired pizza tasted amazing! Lots of fresh toppings and bursting with flavor. Beautiful setting on the water. Must try!!
… moreAdam Carraway
Absolutely top-tier! The pizza and wings at Billy Goat Island Pizza Bar are incredible—crispy, flavorful, and clearly made with care. The frozen drinks are just the cherry on top, perfect for a hot day by the lake. Lake Burton is truly lucky to have a spot like this. Whether you’re boating in or driving over, it’s 100% worth the stop. Friendly staff, great vibes, and killer food. We’ll definitely be back!
… morewilliam byrd
This experience was amazing! Their food was priced great and talk about quality! There’s so many options for people who don’t eat meat (me) and my boyfriend loves the wings. Now let’s talk the pizza, they make their dough and sauce so fresh and you can tell it’s absolute DYNAMITE
The owners are absolutely killing it! Drink selection phenomenal and vibe on point!
… moreFrances Aiken
I just ate here with a group of my college friends, and it was amazing!! It wasn’t even supposed to be open, but they opened just for us. Chad and Kelly were the sweetest people ever, and the pizza was delicious! Everything was great, but I highly recommend the pizza with hot honey! This is a welcome addition to the lake, and we will definitely be back soon!
… moreryan warren
I found this place on Facebook. I love the area it’s in so I decided to drive out and try it. It did not disappoint! The woodfire pizza is great and the atmosphere is even better. Its right on the marina. The owners and staff are amazing people and really made the experience top notch. I drove 2 hours to get there from where I live and I will gladly do it again!
… moreramsey waters
If you’re anywhere near Lake Burton and don’t stop at Billy Goat Island Pizza Bar, you’re seriously missing out. This place is a special gem!
The pizza is next level.It’s a perfectly crispy crust with just the right amount of chew, loaded with fresh, flavorful toppings. I’ve tried the white pie and each of the wings, and both were absolute standouts. You can tell they use high quality ingredients, and the flavor combinations are on point.
As great as the food was, the service was even better. Friendly, fast, and genuinely welcoming. The staff (Chad, Kelly, Brett, Victoria, Olivia) are amazing! They all have a passion for putting out high quality product. You can tell this from the friendly smiles.
Add in the laid back lake vibe and beautiful views, and this was easily the best dining experience I’ve had at the Marina. Can’t wait to see what the future holds for this place!!
… more