Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Big Nic’s Pizzeria & Sub is a local pizza shop in Colonie serving authentic New York-style pizza and thick Sicilian pizza made fresh daily. Located on Everett Rd, we offer classic pizza by the slice or whole pies along with hot subs, wings, and comfort food favorites. Known for generous portions, fast pickup, and reliable delivery, Big Nic’s is a go-to spot for customers in Albany and Colonie looking for real New York pizza. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick slice or ordering for family and friends, we focus on quality, consistency, and friendly neighborhood service.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 109 Everett Rd, Albany, NY 12205
Phone: (518) 459-0500
Website: https://www.bignics.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Big Nic’s Pizzeria | Albany, NY | View Menu & Order Online
Order Online for Pickup or Delivery from Big Nic’s Pizzeria in Albany. View their menu, specials and coupons. Big Nic’s Pizzeria is Hot Wings, …
Big Nic’s Pizzeria Delivery Menu | 109 Everett Rd Albany – Grubhub
Best Sellers; Pizza; Gourmet Pizzas; Sicilian Gourmet Pizza; Calzones; Strombolis; Big Nic’s Pinwheel; Buffalo Wings; Appetizers; Salads; Italian Dinners …
Order Big Nic’s Pizzeria – Albany, NY Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from Big Nic’s Pizzeria at 109 Everett Rd in Albany. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Last Updates
Reviews
Deniz Kana
After my uncle and a coworker told me to try out this place under new ownership, I had to give it a shot. They know me to be a pizza snob, this place didn’t disappoint! The pie and the calzone were top notch, quality ingrediants backed up with real flavor. I will be returning and I recommend giving this place a try!!
… moreTIMDOG
Hands Down…
NY Style & Sicilian
Slices… Of Pizza
A Wide Selection Of Pizza’s, Subs, &
Some Home Cooked Dinner Dishes,
I’m Yet To Try!!!
I was referred by a Local Business a Stones Throw Away, &
Big Nic’s Pizzaria Is Under New Managment & Less Greasey, & Mangai…
Much Thxs, TimDog
From “Destination Kia- The Photographer & Catering Driver ” &
The Referred is “Madison Sudz” Detailing.
2nd. Time Stopped For Lunch…& Now A 3rd. & Ordered A 12cut Sicilian… Mangia
I Also Recommend The Sub Platters & Sides…
” Two For TimDog ” Meatlovers &
… moreNY Style & Sicilian
Slices… Of Pizza
A Wide Selection Of Pizza’s, Subs, &
Some Home Cooked Dinner Dishes,
I’m Yet To Try!!!
I was referred by a Local Business a Stones Throw Away, &
Big Nic’s Pizzaria Is Under New Managment & Less Greasey, & Mangai…
Much Thxs, TimDog
From “Destination Kia- The Photographer & Catering Driver ” &
The Referred is “Madison Sudz” Detailing.
2nd. Time Stopped For Lunch…& Now A 3rd. & Ordered A 12cut Sicilian… Mangia
I Also Recommend The Sub Platters & Sides…
” Two For TimDog ” Meatlovers &
Glen Brittell
Don’t come here on a Sunday. The plain cheese pizza tastes like they made too many pizzas the night before and reheated it. Chewy middle dough, and a very hard crunchy crust. The wings were somehow crispy and soggy at the same time. Paid $41 for an 8 cut and 10 wings and a piece of cake (that was very good actually) even though a sign on the wall says “sat sun: 8 cut and 12 wings for $20
I never write reviews but dang… I will ever never be back.
… moreI never write reviews but dang… I will ever never be back.
Adam Dangerfield Vertical Media Solutions
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Big Nic’s has become my go-to spot. The new owners are genuinely good people and they’re doing it the right way — great pizza, real portions, and real customer service.
I’ve lived in Brooklyn/NYC for years and I’ve had pizza all over the place… this pizza is legit. Big slices, great flavor, and the crust has that perfect balance (nice bite, not dry). Sauce is on point too.
Their subs are excellent — and what really stood out to me is they use homemade bread for the heroes. You can taste the difference immediately. I’ve had a few sandwiches (cold subs and hot like chicken cutlet / chicken parm) and they don’t skimp on ingredients.
But beyond the food, these guys have that old-school neighborhood style where they’ll actually work with you and treat you like a person, not a number. That matters.
If you’re in the area and you want a solid slice or a real sandwich, support this place. You won’t regret it!
… moreBig Nic’s has become my go-to spot. The new owners are genuinely good people and they’re doing it the right way — great pizza, real portions, and real customer service.
I’ve lived in Brooklyn/NYC for years and I’ve had pizza all over the place… this pizza is legit. Big slices, great flavor, and the crust has that perfect balance (nice bite, not dry). Sauce is on point too.
Their subs are excellent — and what really stood out to me is they use homemade bread for the heroes. You can taste the difference immediately. I’ve had a few sandwiches (cold subs and hot like chicken cutlet / chicken parm) and they don’t skimp on ingredients.
But beyond the food, these guys have that old-school neighborhood style where they’ll actually work with you and treat you like a person, not a number. That matters.
If you’re in the area and you want a solid slice or a real sandwich, support this place. You won’t regret it!
Stephanie and Sandeep Arepally
Okay. So we went there last night. FANTASTIC SERVICE, FOOD WAS BEYOND ON POINT! I have never in my LIFE had perfect crust on a calzone like that. I mean, flaky perfect crust. Insides screaming to be eaten! Will absolutely be back! 100%
… moreAnılcan Hindi
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Absolutely love this place!
Big Nic’s Pizzeria has that perfect local vibe — friendly faces, amazing smells, and food made with real care. The pizzas are spot-on: fresh, loaded with quality toppings, and the crust has that ideal balance between crispy and soft. The cheese melts perfectly, and the sauce has just the right flavor.
It’s not just pizza either — their calzones, wings, and strombolis are all top-notch. Everything tastes homemade and authentic. The prices are super fair, the portions are generous, and the service is quick and friendly.
Honestly, Big Nic’s is one of those hidden gems in Albany where you can actually taste the effort and passion in every bite. Keep it up, guys — you’re doing an amazing job!
… moreAbsolutely love this place!
Big Nic’s Pizzeria has that perfect local vibe — friendly faces, amazing smells, and food made with real care. The pizzas are spot-on: fresh, loaded with quality toppings, and the crust has that ideal balance between crispy and soft. The cheese melts perfectly, and the sauce has just the right flavor.
It’s not just pizza either — their calzones, wings, and strombolis are all top-notch. Everything tastes homemade and authentic. The prices are super fair, the portions are generous, and the service is quick and friendly.
Honestly, Big Nic’s is one of those hidden gems in Albany where you can actually taste the effort and passion in every bite. Keep it up, guys — you’re doing an amazing job!
Sefa KOÇAKOĞLU
“The new management has made a huge difference! The pizzas are absolutely fantastic and full of flavor. Their weekly specials are a must-try — extremely recommended! Definitely one of the best spots around.
… moreNicat Esgerli
Really enjoyed this place! The pizza was fresh, cheesy, and full of flavor. Service was fast and friendly, and the prices were reasonable. Great spot for a casual meal—will definitely come back!
… moreJoemoo
I’ve went here for years, best parmagiana hoagies in the area. When they I realized they changed management I got worried that it wouldn’t be as good, but I was very wrong! The bread they use is still the same thankfully, and just as good as ever. Good luck guys, still killing it!
… moreKristopher Kolonko
Big Nic’s Pizza is where I go when I want that classic American style pizza that focuses on cheese and is light on the sauce. It’s also home of the pizzaboli, a massive combo of half pizza and Stromboli that can feed a large gathering. Another unique pie to try is their pocket pizza, which has a top crust and is filled with ham, pepperoni, tomatoes, and garlic. Big Nic’s delivers a consistent product and great service.
… more