4.4 – 144 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Social Profile: 
Welcome to Big City Slices!
We’re the Alencaster Family, new owners as of 2/1/25! With 20+ years of experience making NY-style pizza, we’re excited to serve the Oakhurst community and beyond!
We offer pizza by the slice starting at $4.50 (6 crust, 12 long), 12, 18, and 24 pizzas, including gluten-free (12” only). Choose from specialty pies or build your own. We also serve wings, garlic knots, salads, and desserts like cannolis.
As the sister restaurant to Tacos El Peladito in Concord, NC , we’re committed to high-quality, affordable food. Stop by and grab a slice!
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
Menu Photos
bigcityslicesclt.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Last Updates
Reviews
Cynthia R
I truly wanted to like this place but it just missed the mark for me. Positives are the place was clean and the cashier was extremely nice. But the food fell flat for me. I tried the cheesesteak and it was just so boring to me. Didn’t really have a huge flavor. Had no “personality” and sooooo much cheese with little meat under it. The bread to meat/toppings ratio was off. When I think cheesesteak I think an ooey gooey mess of deliciousness. This sandwich was dry and definitely didn’t have any “mess” factor. I went during lunch hours on a Friday and it was practically empty, just me and another lady. Idk, hopefully things get better but I doubt I’ll be back.
… moremelissa bogan
Basic quick eatery but everything we’ve eaten so far has been excellent! We’re working our way around the menu. So far pizza, meatball hero and now calzone and a stromboli. The crust is tender and not overworked. Meatballs are our favorite and they’re all beef!
… moreVincent Brown
The food here was incredible! The pizza slices were enormous and full of flavor, with a crust that had just the right crunch. Both the buffalo and lemon pepper wings were packed with taste and cooked perfectly. It’s a cozy place that’s perfect for a quick meal any time of day. Dalia was super kind and made the experience even better. I’ll definitely be visiting again soon!
… moreGeorge Rodriguez
For pizza by the slice Big City Slices gives you a huge slice of pizza for a very reasonable price. The dinning area is small but has 5 tvs on the walls, so always something to watch. I had the Brooklyn style slice that had fresh toppings and served nice and hot. Have I mentioned the pizza slices are huge! Stop in if a slice of pizza is what you want.
… moreCeaira Meyer
The pizza is amazing, From the sauce to the pineapple to the crust!!! I got a Buffalo Chicken Slice with added pineapple!
I also had the pleasure of trying a Garlic Knot & Red Sauce 1000/1000! The dough is sooo good!
Customer service was fabulous, everyone was so sweet!
I’m from Brooklyn & when I tell you this pizza reminds me of home! 2x customer so far & many more visits to come! Thank you✨
… moreJ. Reynolds
I have been wanting to try Big City for a while. I did not get a whole pizza, but 3 slices to go. The restaurant is nice and clean with plenty of sports on the TV’s. The slices were legit huge. 2 slices are half a pie. The pizza was delicious and fresh. I definitely want to get a pizza and eat it there. Overall, the first impression is very good.
The employee who took my order was super nice and kind.
… moreLisa Craig
Definitely higher quality than a standard strip mall pizza joint. Modern, clean, very friendly staff and 4 TVs in the dining area (a hit with my kids). My only suggestion would be actual plates and metal cutlery for dine-in customers. Overall a very positive first time experience here.
… moreAmelia Ryan
The reason for this review is hopefully the management will relay this info to their staff in regards to what we received (& correct it).
My husband picked up two slices of cheese pizza. First time we’ve tried this place & well…the pics show how extremely thin part of the slices were & also the raw crust.
Whoever boxed the slices should’ve known better.
… moreGeorge K
Best NY Pizza I’ve had out here in CLT area! And I’m a NYC native. Great crust, sauce and cheese. By far the closest to hometown NYC slices I’ve had here and it’s my new favorite!
… moreSam Porter
Almost always great! Couple times in the afternoon I have gotten slices that were clearly made way earlier and everything was dry. But most the time food is great
… more … View more