Social Profile: 
… View more
Seasonally inspired gastropub fare & innovative cocktails in a woodsy space dating to the 1840s.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3747 Cedar Creek Rd, Slinger, WI 53086
Phone: (262) 247-0703
Website: https://www.bibingers.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: toasttab.comtripleseat.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Gastropub | Bibinger’s Bar & Restaurant | Slinger WI
Enjoy scratch cooking, craft cocktails & loyalty perks. Discover more! Contact for details.
Fresh Menu Options | Slinger WI – Bibinger’s Bar & Restaurant
The menu offers food for any occasion, from scratch-made appetizers and sandwiches to our signature entrees including steaks and seafood.
Bibinger’s | Travel Wisconsin
… WI Snow Report. Alt Text. 1 of 3. Restaurants • Southeast Wisconsin … bar has something for everyone, from craft cocktails to local brews. Read More. Cuisine …
Reviews
Lucas Weesen
Instantly one of my favorite restaurants! Just eating here for the first time the meatloaf and potatoes are amazing
Our waitress Gina was fantastic as well. Couldn’t be happier!
… moreOur waitress Gina was fantastic as well. Couldn’t be happier!
A O
Very good food. Very good service. All staff was friendly except the woman seating people. Tried a few selections cause everything looked so good. Only thing we didn’t care for was just how generally loud it was in there. Hard to have a nice conversation
… moreSteven Frey
Awesome food. Tuesdays are awesome for $5 Old Fashioneds, wish it was more days in the week! Great Old Fashioneds
… moreAaron Seiser
We stopped in here for lunch based on other Google reviews, and we were not disappointed! The building and decor are beautiful, nostalgic, and rustic. It was a very warm atmosphere accompanied by a wonderful server. She was kind, knowledgeable, and honest about all of the menu items. The Old Fashioned drink menu is extensive, and the 2 kinds we tried were out of this world! Almost all ingredients are made in-house, including the caramel drizzle on one of the best carrot cakes we have ever had! We went for lunch, which has a smaller menu than dinner. The service we had was complimented by the matching quality of the food. We will definitely be back for the dinner service to try more of the delicious sounding items that are not on the lunch menu!
… moreRobert Barkley
We haven’t been to Bibingers in a while. Last time we came was for breakfast and it was fine. We decided to try it for dinner tonight since it was so cold the trees are exploding.
We arrived for our reservation and we could barely hear ourselves think. There was a giant table full of lawless humans and their children that were incredibly loud and running around. It seemed as though the restaurant didn’t care. We almost decided to leave, but again, even Frosty the snowman is by a fireplace.
We ordered our drinks and appetizers. The pretzel covered cheese curds and b sprouts. The curdswere lacking flavor and the sprouts were just a swamp of a soggy mess.
Next, clam chowder. More like tasteless goop with a sliver of what is supposed to be a clam?
Okay, entree time. By this time the table of uncontrollable heathens had left. Phew, we can talk a bit. Still very loud though.
Kids Mac and cheese was the best meal presented to us. Sadly true.
The Caesar salad was a disgrace. It’s as if they threw wet lettuce on a plate and forgot to put flavor in their dressing. Must have bought their Parmesan cheese from a back alley somewhere.
Nashville hot chicken. It was meh at best. Not hot in any fashion, coleslaw was dripping everywhere and lacked any resemblance of substance. Fries were good.
Lastly, our server was great. We didn’t bother her with this information as none of this is on her.
Short version: Very loud, food stinks. Mac n cheese is good. Waitress is nice.
… moreWe arrived for our reservation and we could barely hear ourselves think. There was a giant table full of lawless humans and their children that were incredibly loud and running around. It seemed as though the restaurant didn’t care. We almost decided to leave, but again, even Frosty the snowman is by a fireplace.
We ordered our drinks and appetizers. The pretzel covered cheese curds and b sprouts. The curdswere lacking flavor and the sprouts were just a swamp of a soggy mess.
Next, clam chowder. More like tasteless goop with a sliver of what is supposed to be a clam?
Okay, entree time. By this time the table of uncontrollable heathens had left. Phew, we can talk a bit. Still very loud though.
Kids Mac and cheese was the best meal presented to us. Sadly true.
The Caesar salad was a disgrace. It’s as if they threw wet lettuce on a plate and forgot to put flavor in their dressing. Must have bought their Parmesan cheese from a back alley somewhere.
Nashville hot chicken. It was meh at best. Not hot in any fashion, coleslaw was dripping everywhere and lacked any resemblance of substance. Fries were good.
Lastly, our server was great. We didn’t bother her with this information as none of this is on her.
Short version: Very loud, food stinks. Mac n cheese is good. Waitress is nice.
LJ Excursions
Bibinger’s is a fun pub with good food and great service. Love the atmosphere and our server was fantastic
The Nashville hot chicken was really good and yes it is spicy. The Blueberry Basil Salad was ok. We also had the Brussel Sprout appetizer which was quite tasty.
Not too crowded on a Sunday night.
… moreThe Nashville hot chicken was really good and yes it is spicy. The Blueberry Basil Salad was ok. We also had the Brussel Sprout appetizer which was quite tasty.
Not too crowded on a Sunday night.
Jenny V
I’d like to add this review as the friend mentioned in Paula J.’s review a couple weeks ago, to clarify a few points in response to the restaurant’s reply.
Paula’s original review accurately reflects our experience. Her intention was not to disparage Bibinger’s, but to inform future diners of a policy that was never communicated to us prior to or during our reservation.
We fully understand that Friday evenings are busy and that table turnover is important. At the time we were asked to leave, there were multiple empty tables in the dining room, no visible line, and no guests waiting at the door. If we had seen diners waiting, we would have gladly wrapped up much earlier.
I have waited for reservations at busy restaurants many times, but I have never experienced a manager asking seated guests to leave, especially when the restaurant was not visibly full. That interaction was unexpected and uncomfortable, and it overshadowed what had otherwise been a very enjoyable meal.
While my dining experience itself – great food and service – would have warranted a higher rating, I am leaving a one-star review specifically due to the tone and content of the restaurant’s public response to Paula’s review, which I found dismissive and unnecessarily confrontational. How a business engages with feedback is just as important as the experience it provides in the moment.
… morePaula’s original review accurately reflects our experience. Her intention was not to disparage Bibinger’s, but to inform future diners of a policy that was never communicated to us prior to or during our reservation.
We fully understand that Friday evenings are busy and that table turnover is important. At the time we were asked to leave, there were multiple empty tables in the dining room, no visible line, and no guests waiting at the door. If we had seen diners waiting, we would have gladly wrapped up much earlier.
I have waited for reservations at busy restaurants many times, but I have never experienced a manager asking seated guests to leave, especially when the restaurant was not visibly full. That interaction was unexpected and uncomfortable, and it overshadowed what had otherwise been a very enjoyable meal.
While my dining experience itself – great food and service – would have warranted a higher rating, I am leaving a one-star review specifically due to the tone and content of the restaurant’s public response to Paula’s review, which I found dismissive and unnecessarily confrontational. How a business engages with feedback is just as important as the experience it provides in the moment.
Amber J.
Food is pretty tasty. Don’t expect to see the full menu online as it changes. Apparently they pull back the menu when they are having events. Slightly disappointed because we didn’t get the memo for our first visit. We were told only high tops were available and we watched several low tops sit empty as we suffered through the uncomfortable high top seating. That being said the food was very tasty even with limited choices. We had come for a Friday fish fry anyway. And the staff made sure to get me all the extra toppings for my baked potato… so overall a place we would go again. Definitely will call ahead and make sure there aren’t any large events next visit. I’d like to taste more of their advertised menu.
… moreTee Nips, MD
We came here for a drink after a long day of house remodeling work and ended up staying for dinner. The old fashioneds are definitely a highlight. Pretzel curds were delicious and a hefty portion for an app. I had the seasonal salad off the specials menu and it was awesome. Fiance had a chicken sando–bread was over toasted and cut up his gums, and the piece of chicken was tiny in proportion to the bread which is why I am not giving the food 5*. That said, we would definitely go back and give it another try. Staff was friendly and attentive; service was wonderful.
… moreD Lucille
Friendly staff, tequila old fashioned is a must try! Had the pulled pork sandwich, the macaroni dish with pork and panko was awesome. Loved the Brussel sprouts, so flavorful and much better than the ones Mom made you eat. 🙂 Great dining experience. Get the carrot cake. YUM!
… more