Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Pizza, heroes & other Italian specialties from a casual take-out counter with a few seats.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1038 1st Ave, New York, NY 10022
Phone: (212) 644-8400
Website: https://www.bestpizzaon1stavenue.com/?utm_source=gbp
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: bestpizzaon1stavenue.com
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
NYC: Best Pizza – The Carboholic
Rubirosa (235 Mulberry St.) Rubirosa is one of the few NYC restaurants I feel is worthy of all of it’s hype. I’ve dined here on 10+ separate …
NYT – The 25 Best Pizza Places in New York Right Now : r/FoodNYC
267 votes, 269 comments. Andrew Bellucci’s Pizza Arturo’s Coal Oven Pizza Chrissy’s Pizza Dani’s House of Pizza Denino’s Pizzeria & Tavern …
The Best Pizzerias of New York City – Eater NY
Pugsley Pizza · Mama’s Too · Don Antonio · John’s of Bleecker Street · Joe’s Pizza · Ops [East Village] · Arturo’s · Chrissy’s Pizza.
Last Updates
Reviews
Chris Singleton
BP on 1 is elite. My local for 8 years now and has never once disappointed me in the slightest for our (pretty much weekly) deliveries. I’ve also stopped in a couple times in person and it always hits in person too.
… moreAndrew J.
Great shop. Traditional NY pie…great crust and bite.
Service: …
… moreService: …
Rob Haas
I’ve had a decent slice here, so I decided to try a chicken parm hero. Big mistake. The chicken was hard, dry, left-over little pieces of misery. How they can serve this? Menu said 12 but I had to pay 13 cash. Not sure why – for take out? This was my neighborhood go-to but now I’ll be moving on…
… moreAle Carrillo
I tasted a best pizza in NYC, better than much, I walked around the streets and I find some pizza slides in there, tourist should taste them!!! Nice guys snd service. Blessings
… moreAbigail Diaz
This really is the best pizza on 1st. Have been ordering from them for years. The pizza is even better when you order a whole pie.
… moreE R
It was mediocre at best. They were nice but I did not enjoy the slice I ordered and it was just warm even after putting it in the oven. It had a nice crust but the sauce did not do it for me and the chicken was blah.
… moreMike Biagio
We were around there last month, we ask for 2 pastas and a hero, and trust me, we will not come back again, old man in the register gave us attitude, and like he was doing a favor to us, food it was nothing outside the world and even it was overpriced, just a little bit of ingredients and a lot bad attitude from this guy, seems like he’s the ownwer.
… moreLiz Myers
Super yummy pizza! We crushed it before I thought to take pictures of the actual pizza served to us but this is the pizza before the reheat it in the oven!
… moreAmanda Do
Hands down the best pizzas I’ve ever tried! I ordered the Margherita + pepperoni and Cheese. The cheese they use on both are so delicious and the base is perfectly thin. For the price, it’s a steal
… moreshawn
Whenever I’m in the neighborhood, I make it a point to stop by this pizzeria. They serve a solid New York slice—crispy, flavorful, and consistently good. I’ve tried just about every slice they offer, along with their rolls, and I’ve never been disappointed. Next up: the dinner menu. definitely recommend if you’re in the area.
… more