Pizza, heroes & other Italian specialties from a casual take-out counter with a few seats.
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Order and Reservations
Reservations: bestpizzaon1stavenue.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Where to Find the Iconic Pizzerias of New York City – Eater NY
Lombardi’s Coal Oven Pizza … Lombardi’s is not the best coal oven pizza joint in town, but it is the oldest, and its charred pies do not …
The 22 Best Pizza Places In NYC – New York – The Infatuation
The 22 Best Pizza Places In NYC · Sign up for our newsletter. · THE SPOTS · Lucali · L&B Spumoni Gardens · Una Pizza Napoletana · Di Fara Pizza · L’ …
The Absolute Best Pizza In NYC, Ranked – Tasting Table
New Yorkers are famously hard to please, especially when it comes to pizza. But L’Industrie opened in Brooklyn’s hip South Williamsburg …
Reviews
Mateo M
Amazing food. The chicken vodka was great, and the pizza, oh the pizza! The name doesn’t lie. There was one downside, however. It was amazing, but when I stepped outside, I smelt a disgusting, putrid smell. I’m assuming this was because of the fact that it is in NYC though. other than that, the food, and the restaurant itself were amazing! You guys should relocate, or open more stores, the smell is horrible. Also, I live in NJ, so I never get to come here. When I did come though, it was great. 9.7/10.
… moreCharlie Counter
There is a human carcass stripped of it’s bodily organs in a dumpster behind Best Pizza, Manhattan, in New York City, New York at 40.713050, -74.007230
… moreNonStopLofi
Great pizza! Very well seasoned and the cheese is amazing. It distracts me from the fact that There’s a human carcass in the dumpster behind the establishment
… moreShane Pally
The flavor, texture and quality. All remind me of what pizza used to taste like in New York City. Absolutely fantastic.
… moreAadityaa Senthilkumar
This is definitely the pizza of all time. In fact, I loved it so much, that I ignored the human body without organs in the dumpster behind the store!
… moreAmanda Do
Hands down the best pizzas I’ve ever tried! I ordered the Margherita + pepperoni and Cheese. The cheese they use on both are so delicious and the base is perfectly thin. For the price, it’s a steal
… moreKerwin Arenas
Awesome pizza, I work down the block and with all these pizzeria selections I’m faithfully to best pizza. For the price and the slice nothing on 1st ave beating this place
… moreSophia Yannopoulos
Great pizza but their new hours after the pandemic aren’t great. Come back past 10p!! That’s when people want their pizza. Come on guys! Don’t drive away in your Porsche and leave us in the dust.
… moreAlbert Pae
Great guys, good pizza, good price point. Loved the crust and the pepperoni slice. The chicken vodka was ok. It lacked a little flavor, but it’s a specialty pizza which I’m not crazy about anyway. Slices were at perfect temperature even after walking on a cool day.
… moreDavid Chin
Had the meat lovers pie for an afternoon/evening of championship football, the combination was wonderful. Was expecting some heartburn later in the night but it never came. Very pleased with the overall experience.
… more