Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1 American Dream Wy, East Rutherford, NJ 07073
Phone: (551) 248-4961
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
What’s the best pizza spot in the Rutherford/Newark NNJ area?
Down that way I’d try Arturo’s as well. The pizza is delicious but so is all the food.
Best Pizza at American Dream in NJ – New York Style Pizza
Best Pizza, established in 2010 by Frank Pinello in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is celebrated for its distinctive approach to classic New York-style slices.
Gusto Woodfired Pizza – East Rutherford, NJ
At Gusto Woodfired Pizza in East Rutherford, we embrace the simple joy of sharing delicious food with great company. Our wood-fired pizzas and homemade …
Reviews
Raj S
Located conveniently with American dream mall on the food court area.. kids wanted to have pizzas and this was a perfect spot.. I was surprised seeing a 2.7 star for this place… I think most of them have rated less for this place.. to me it’s a 4 Star Pizza Place .. lots of seats in the food court to sit and eat..
Service was a bit slow and billing was slow too .. had to stay in the line for 5 to 10 minutes to get the food.. guys there were working hard . Wish they had a couple more employees, especially during weekends and peak hours… we just loved the cheese pizza.. it was fresh and tasted so good.. the garlic knots and garlic bread was super Duper good.. We love the tomato basil sauce and it was very fresh… good experience overall.. 4 stars .. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreService was a bit slow and billing was slow too .. had to stay in the line for 5 to 10 minutes to get the food.. guys there were working hard . Wish they had a couple more employees, especially during weekends and peak hours… we just loved the cheese pizza.. it was fresh and tasted so good.. the garlic knots and garlic bread was super Duper good.. We love the tomato basil sauce and it was very fresh… good experience overall.. 4 stars .. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Tally N.
This place has so much potential but $7.50 for a tiny slice is definitely not worth it. The pizza is flavorful but there are better options for food. Staff isn’t so nice & always talking so everyone is just waiting around for their food.
… moreChuck Mound
I get it, the rent is super high at American Dream and it gets passed on to the Customer. But what does not get passed on is a good slice of Pizza. I ordered a Grandma Slice and a Soda which was $8. The Sauce on the Slice was cold and minimal. I could say the same about the Cheese. Non existent. The rest was a crust. This may called Best Pizza, but it is the only Pizza at the Mall. Its good to fill your stomach after the Snow, but other than that, its not the Best Pizza. The Server was really nice and thats was got them to 2 stars.
… moreTurner N Hooch
Slow service, over priced slice $5.25. Had them in Williamsburg, needed emergency pizza..in AMERICAN DREAM.
… moreEloy Yip
My partner and I decided to stop at this establishment located in Court A, Level 2 of the American Dream mall for lunch. Best Pizza is the first Jersey location for the award-winning shop by pizzaiolo and TV host, Frank Pinello. Everything looked tempting and settled on their vegetarian and grandma squares. Both were reheated and arrived warm. We loved the nice crunchy crusts. Grandma square was doughy, cheesy and topped with very good tomatoes. The vegetarian was loaded with a lot garlic and pepper. This might be called Best Pizza but was only good to fill our stomach as the square was just ok at best whose price was reasonable.
… morejames
I’ve eat here two other times in the past and the pizza was really good. I had pizza here Saturday, February 21 and the pizza was terrible and the guy handled the pizza was not very nice pizza was cold had to bring it back up put it back in the oven give it back and it was still cold . And it is super expensive so each time should be really good. I don’t like spending so much money and then the food is not good.
… morePratiksha Rathi
The best pizza stays up to its name. It’s delicious.
We tried the simple cheese pizza slice that had tomato sauce and cheese. Secondly, we tried cheese, grilled onions, and sesame and it was super nice.
We also tried garlic knots and it was so buttery and yummy!
… moreWe tried the simple cheese pizza slice that had tomato sauce and cheese. Secondly, we tried cheese, grilled onions, and sesame and it was super nice.
We also tried garlic knots and it was so buttery and yummy!
Adam Brodeur
I had a couple of pepperoni slices from Best Pizza and I thought they were absolutely delicious! I had a conversation with Pete who worked there and I thought he was very friendly. The next time I’m in the mall I would definitely come back.
… morePatrick Lewis (praxmoney7729)
As a Pizza aficionado, I decided to give a plain slice a whirl. Met with Steve at the counter, AWESOME guy. Steve gave me a brief history on the place and informed me how the name came about in addition to where their other locations are. The slice had next to no flop, tangy sauce, and the perfect amount of “char”. Can’t say I’ve had a better slice of pizza that’s ever come out of a mall.
3 cheers to Best Pizza, Steve and the rest of his crew. They are an AWESOME group of people and I can’t wait to stop back again!!!!
… more3 cheers to Best Pizza, Steve and the rest of his crew. They are an AWESOME group of people and I can’t wait to stop back again!!!!
Nancy Wong Shek
Best Pizza in American Dream so far has been delicious compared to the other pizza places I have tried in the mall. There’s options between thin and thick slices. I’m a fan of thin slices, delicious and fresh.
Staff is okay. They sometimes are distracted the few times I have gone even when there are no lines. All payments are accepted, a little less if you use cash. The pizzas are a bit pricey. However, you’re at the mall, so sometimes it’s as expected.
Parking garage is outside, plenty of floors to choose where to go. There is plenty of seating in the mall.
… moreStaff is okay. They sometimes are distracted the few times I have gone even when there are no lines. All payments are accepted, a little less if you use cash. The pizzas are a bit pricey. However, you’re at the mall, so sometimes it’s as expected.
Parking garage is outside, plenty of floors to choose where to go. There is plenty of seating in the mall.