Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Best NY Pizza brings authentic New York–style pizza to Wesley Chapel and the Tampa Bay area with fresh dough made daily, premium mozzarella, signature sauce, and stone-oven baking. Our large, foldable slices and classic NY pies deliver the bold flavor, thin crust, and perfect chew New Yorkers expect. Choose from whole pies or giant slices, build your own, or enjoy favorites like Cheese, Buffalo Chicken, White, BBQ Chicken, Meat Lovers, Veggie Lovers, Hawaiian, and Sicilian pizza. Our menu also includes wings, garlic knots, calzones, stromboli, baked pasta dinners, fresh salads, and classic Italian comfort food. Family-owned and community-focused, we offer dine-in, takeout, delivery, and catering. Open 7 days serving Wesley Chapel & Tampa
Address and Contact Information
Address: 27429 Wesley Chapel Blvd, Wesley Chapel, FL 33544
Phone: (813) 994-2200
Website: http://www.bestnypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Best NY Pizza (Wesley Chapel) – Wesley Chapel, FL 33544 (Menu …
Online ordering menu for Best NY Pizza (Wesley Chapel). We serve Pizza, Calzones, Subs, Salads, Flatbreads and more here at Best NY Pizza in Tampa, Florida.
Best NY Pizza: Authentic New York-Style Pizza in Tampa & Wesley …
Best NY Pizza delivers the authentic NY-style pizza Tampa loves and Wesley Chapel craves, serving Tampa Bay communities with fast delivery, takeout, and full …
Menu Gallery | Best NY-Style Pizza
Authentic NY-style pizza menu in Wesley Chapel & Tampa! Hand-tossed thin-crust specialties, gluten-free options, appetizers, calzones, subs & Italian …
Reviews
Diana Sowell
5 ⭐
New York Pizza is one of my favorite places to go when I’m craving a really good slice. The pizza is consistently delicious and the sauce is perfect—not too much, just the right balance so you can actually taste all the flavors.
You can tell they know how to make a proper pizza. I always enjoy coming here and it’s definitely one of my go-to spots.
… moreNew York Pizza is one of my favorite places to go when I’m craving a really good slice. The pizza is consistently delicious and the sauce is perfect—not too much, just the right balance so you can actually taste all the flavors.
You can tell they know how to make a proper pizza. I always enjoy coming here and it’s definitely one of my go-to spots.
Chris and Tanya
Service was okay. Pizza was delicious! We bought the combo. The canolis were delicious! The ambiance could have been better. During our time there, we had to listen to the ladies at the counter gossip about the guy with the french bulldog that came in to order takeout. The manager tried to kick him out. The blond girl pretended to be friendly, but engaged in negative gossip after he left and we had to hear all about this. The Greek Salad was lacking. No potato salad. Wrong dressing. Ordering is easy. The wait time was reasonable. Overall, it was okay.
… morePaul Bartell
We have ordered pizza from there for years and decided to try their Hoagies. They are delicious! I have had the Ckn Parm and Meatball over the last few weeks. Pizza will now be a back up choice! A+
… morenishant narula
We were in the area and looking for a quick bite, so we searched nearby and found Best NY Pizza.
When we walked in, we were happy to see that, in addition to full pizzas, they also offered pizza by the slice. Instead of ordering a whole pizza, we went with slices.
From the available options, we chose a Cheese Pizza Slice and a Veggie Pizza Slice. The service was quick, and we got our slices in no time.
We started with the cheese pizza slice, which was delicious, perfectly made, and loaded with cheese. Next, we tried the veggie pizza slice, which was topped with a generous mix of fresh vegetables, making it satisfying.
The pizza slices were an excellent snack–tasty, convenient, and reasonably priced.
… moreWhen we walked in, we were happy to see that, in addition to full pizzas, they also offered pizza by the slice. Instead of ordering a whole pizza, we went with slices.
From the available options, we chose a Cheese Pizza Slice and a Veggie Pizza Slice. The service was quick, and we got our slices in no time.
We started with the cheese pizza slice, which was delicious, perfectly made, and loaded with cheese. Next, we tried the veggie pizza slice, which was topped with a generous mix of fresh vegetables, making it satisfying.
The pizza slices were an excellent snack–tasty, convenient, and reasonably priced.
Suzanne S
Overall, a pleasant experience and would recommend it to others, When we went, we ordered The Spaghetti and Meatballs meal, and it was the BOMB! So was the the garlic bread and the pizza!
The restaurant had little to no people when we first arrived but started filling up by the minute, Our Waitress Lacey was nice and friendly. The restrooms were clean, The service was fast and the food was great! This is a great place and again, We would really recommend this place to others!
… moreThe restaurant had little to no people when we first arrived but started filling up by the minute, Our Waitress Lacey was nice and friendly. The restrooms were clean, The service was fast and the food was great! This is a great place and again, We would really recommend this place to others!
Alex Vondormon
Pizza was passable 3/10, wings were 3/10, knots looked good but were dry and tasteless. For $60 it’s definitely not worth it. I understand prices have gone up but I expect quality. Trying to support local is tough, truly wish them the best, but not worth it for me.
Service was ok, they were attentive.
Ambiance was depressing, no music, some kinda news or talk show at low volume. Maybe it was a slow night but at least make it lively, italian pizzeria music is easy to find on youtube or spotify.
TLDR: After a long day, to spend $60 on mid pizza, wings and meh knots, it’s not worth it. But give it a shot, might be for you. Again, wish them the best
… moreService was ok, they were attentive.
Ambiance was depressing, no music, some kinda news or talk show at low volume. Maybe it was a slow night but at least make it lively, italian pizzeria music is easy to find on youtube or spotify.
TLDR: After a long day, to spend $60 on mid pizza, wings and meh knots, it’s not worth it. But give it a shot, might be for you. Again, wish them the best
WIL ARIAS
I have been living in Florida for about four years and, I’ve eaten at over 100 different pizzerias looking for a taste from home. I am brown the Bronx. This pizzeria tastes exactly like Yankees pizza in Morrison Ave, Bronx, N.Y. Thank you for making such amazing tasty and very airy pizza. The search is over I will exclusively buy pizza from here from now on.
… moreRalph Caridad
Let me start this off by saying I am from Brooklyn. Williamsburg Brooklyn. I grew up everywhere in Brooklyn. East NY, Bensonhurst, Coney Island … I was a messenger n my early years so I ate all over Manhattan. I know where the Real Rays Pizza is.
Since I moved to Florida, I have been looking for authentic NY pizza. Please don’t tell me it’s about the water. It’s about the sauce, the taste of the crust and the cheese. I ordered from here and I’m sorry, there was nothing NY I remember about this place. The pizza was ok to good, but not what a slice from Lenny’s or Rays taste like. I will continue my Tampa Bay Area year to find pizza that takes me back to Brooklyn circa 1986.
… moreSince I moved to Florida, I have been looking for authentic NY pizza. Please don’t tell me it’s about the water. It’s about the sauce, the taste of the crust and the cheese. I ordered from here and I’m sorry, there was nothing NY I remember about this place. The pizza was ok to good, but not what a slice from Lenny’s or Rays taste like. I will continue my Tampa Bay Area year to find pizza that takes me back to Brooklyn circa 1986.
Jacki Deck
This place was always are go to but we have been doing 900 degree lately cause sometime its hit or miss on the pizza an tonight it was the best we ever had just like when they 1st opened and it was a Saturday evening!! Shout out to the cooks tonight. Hope there being recognized for their hard work.Best NY is definitely the best in Chapel
… moreLauren Baggio
A customer of mine ordered a pizza that was the best thing I’ve ever had from NY Best Pizza and when I tried to reorder it last night, I felt absolutely taken advantage of ! Apparently this pizza is called “grandma’s sicilian” well, I ordered “grandma’s style” joseph even went through all the ingredients (as I’m waiting on the other line at work, in the bar) light cheese, light marinara, basil pesto, etc. I’m assuming he was making sure the kitchen could make it. I’ve worked in restaurants my whole adult life, I understand the ins and outs of a restaurant, the issue I had is that I paid $51 for that pizza and 20 boneless wings. Boneless wings were $18 (plus the extra charge for two dipping sauces that were different sizes, 4 oz & 2 oz, & the boneless did not come with dipping sauce). Thinking I was going to get a sicilian, grandma’s sicilian, I was absolutely shocked when I saw that we received a circular pie with only 8 slices and it was thinner than their normal pizzas. I called them back immediately (40 min after placing our order) and was placed on hold, I guess it makes sense because it was 15 min til closing and they probably weren’t taking new orders. If I wasn’t busy at work and if NY pizza wasn’t closing, I would’ve walked down to complain. My coworkers and I paid $30 for this pizza that was delicious, but not a sicilian. We would’ve gotten 15 plus pieces with the sicilian and we only received 8. I guess I was hoping for what my customer received and didn’t realize I needed to explicitly say sicilian, even though the only style of the “grandma’s pizza” was sicilian. I will let my customers buy food from them, but I will never spend my money there again, nor will I recommend my customers to go there. They close early anyway (10pm) and they don’t walk the pizzas down the plaza, whereas other pizza places around us are open til 12 and will deliver it. I might as well save money going elsewhere to ensure I get what I order and have no surprises.
… more