Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 299 Bruynswick Rd, Gardiner, NY 12525
Phone: (845) 419-2012
Website: https://www.bentonbeergarden.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Benton | Discover Great Food — Visit Today
Explore Benton in Gardiner, NY, for delicious burgers, fries, and a welcoming beer garden atmosphere. Join us for outdoor dining and great food.
Benton Beer Garden in Gardiner NY Review – Facebook
Best smash burger we have had in this area for sure! Fries are literally perfect! I had a turkey sandwich..done like a Cuban and sooo good! And …
Benton Brings Canadian Roadhouse Vibes to Full Circle in Gardiner
In February 2025, Gardiner welcomed a fresh addition to its social scene with the opening of Benton, a laid-back bar and eatery co-owned by …
Reviews
Jeffrey Dunn
Benton’s may be a small room, but it’s a truly happening place. Full of local social flavor and winter warmth.
The clam chowder was incredible, the triple Belgian beer was delicious, and the evening ended perfectly with a gingerbread cookie.
What more could you ask for on a cold winter night in Gardiner, New York?
… moreThe clam chowder was incredible, the triple Belgian beer was delicious, and the evening ended perfectly with a gingerbread cookie.
What more could you ask for on a cold winter night in Gardiner, New York?
Jason Krieger
Little Burger spot within the Full Circle hub. Really tasty smash burger and fries (fries reminded me of Five Guys, in a good way). One fry is enough for two people. Plenty of seating outside and around the Full Circle area. A few seats inside at the bar.
… moreJeanette York
The food is awesome- highly recommend! It was the best chicken sandwich I have had in a long long time! Everything was such amazing quality a deal for the price point. Great staff- friendly and helpful with menu choices. Their themed fries are also a must try- this will become a staple stop for me when I’m in the Gunks.
… moreSarah Oomen-Gailie
Mixed Experience – Great Staff, Disappointing Value
The staff taking our order were great—friendly and helpful. Unfortunately, the food didn’t live up to expectations. I ordered a hot dog advertised as a “footlong,” but what I received was a very small, plain hot dog—definitely not what was described, and not worth the $8 price tag.
The $15 hamburger came with nothing on the side, and the bun was burned, which made it even more disappointing for the cost. The basket of fries (around $10) was actually good, probably the highlight of the meal.
What added to the frustration was that everything is self-serve—you pick up your own food and clean up after yourself, yet the prices feel like they should come with full service.
Overall, our meal came to $55, and for that price, the value just wasn’t there. Great service at the counter, but the food and overall experience didn’t match the cost.
… moreThe staff taking our order were great—friendly and helpful. Unfortunately, the food didn’t live up to expectations. I ordered a hot dog advertised as a “footlong,” but what I received was a very small, plain hot dog—definitely not what was described, and not worth the $8 price tag.
The $15 hamburger came with nothing on the side, and the bun was burned, which made it even more disappointing for the cost. The basket of fries (around $10) was actually good, probably the highlight of the meal.
What added to the frustration was that everything is self-serve—you pick up your own food and clean up after yourself, yet the prices feel like they should come with full service.
Overall, our meal came to $55, and for that price, the value just wasn’t there. Great service at the counter, but the food and overall experience didn’t match the cost.
Gianluca Scarno
I had a great experience here and would definitely give it 5 stars. During a snowstorm, when almost everything else in the area was closed, this place was one of the very few still open—which already says a lot.
They have an excellent selection of beers, and the food was more than solid, with generous portions that really hit the spot. The atmosphere is also a standout: very elegant, especially in the adjacent, separate space, which adds a nice touch if you’re looking for something a bit more refined.
Overall, a reliable and welcoming spot, even under tough conditions. Highly recommend!
… moreThey have an excellent selection of beers, and the food was more than solid, with generous portions that really hit the spot. The atmosphere is also a standout: very elegant, especially in the adjacent, separate space, which adds a nice touch if you’re looking for something a bit more refined.
Overall, a reliable and welcoming spot, even under tough conditions. Highly recommend!
Kyle Clagg
Top recommendation for all our friends and family to try while in the Hudson Valley. Greg and staff are friendly and the food is beyond excellent, best in the Hudson Valley by far. Green house is a favorite for us to spend time in especially when the snow is falling.
… moreD O
I think that’s the best burger I have had in the area . And the service is super amazing. The guys are attentive and I’m thankful for their attention to detail .. specially with allergens . Thank you so much!
If I were to mention something would be …. The greenhouse might have a wasp nest . I got stung while I was having lunch . But other than that …. Everything is nice and pretty perfect .
… moreIf I were to mention something would be …. The greenhouse might have a wasp nest . I got stung while I was having lunch . But other than that …. Everything is nice and pretty perfect .
Mallory Suarez
Absolutely love Gardiner bakehouse next door. Amazing spot. But this burger place wasn’t great. To be fair, we did not order a burger. Maybe it would have been better if we ordered a burger.
I ordered the blct sandwich and was disappointed. It is advertised as a bacon, lettuce, confit tomato sandwich. The tomatoes were sliced and uncooked. I wouldn’t have ordered that sandwich if I knew it was a plain blt. Because it is like a $12-15 sandwich… the bread was dry and huge and it was mostly lettuce. I did mention it to one of the employees and they said they were out of the confit tomatoes but this was after I had received and paid for my food. Not the end of the world by any means but not very considerate. No offer to correct or order something different.
My husband ordered the chicken and pickle sandwich. Not bad. But chick fil a is much better. But honestly the whole experience would have been better if we had a couple beers before our meal.
This place has a lot of potential. The space is beautiful and the neighbors have such a commitment to quality. It’s possible we ordered the wrong thing but it soured our experience that a menu item was not as it was described. Especially for the price.
… moreI ordered the blct sandwich and was disappointed. It is advertised as a bacon, lettuce, confit tomato sandwich. The tomatoes were sliced and uncooked. I wouldn’t have ordered that sandwich if I knew it was a plain blt. Because it is like a $12-15 sandwich… the bread was dry and huge and it was mostly lettuce. I did mention it to one of the employees and they said they were out of the confit tomatoes but this was after I had received and paid for my food. Not the end of the world by any means but not very considerate. No offer to correct or order something different.
My husband ordered the chicken and pickle sandwich. Not bad. But chick fil a is much better. But honestly the whole experience would have been better if we had a couple beers before our meal.
This place has a lot of potential. The space is beautiful and the neighbors have such a commitment to quality. It’s possible we ordered the wrong thing but it soured our experience that a menu item was not as it was described. Especially for the price.
Rebecca Perez
What an excellent spot! The staff were very friendly and the beer selection was great. The food was delicious as well. Can’t wait to come back!
… moreAriane Simard
This was a fun little bar to visit. I had a burger without the bun and they were very accommodating. Separate seating areas both inside and out. A lit of families wirh little kids and babies for a Saturday night. If you are looking for a place to hang for a bite and a drink, this is the place
… more