Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Straightforward restaurant offering pizzas, beverages & more in unfussy digs with outdoor seating.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3835 US-209, Stone Ridge, NY 12484
Phone: (845) 687-4243
Website: https://www.bennyspizzany.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bennys Pizza – Stone Ridge
Welcome To Pizza At It’s Best! ; Phone. (845) 687-4243 (845) 68-PIZZA ; Location. Route 209. Stone Ridge Towne Center Stone Ridge, NY 12484 ; Hours. Sunday thru …
Bennys Pizza | Stone Ridge NY – Facebook
Voted best pizza in the Hudson Valley! For over 25 years, Benny’s Pizzeria has served our community.
Benny’s Pizzeria in Stone Ridge, NY – Ulster County Tourism
Benny’s Pizzeria open Sunday thru Thursday, 10:30 am – 10 pm Friday and Saturday: 10:30 am – 11 pm.
Reviews
Joanne Krom
Fast and friendly, this pie is thick AND ABSOLUTELY LOADED!, just blows my mind! SO !!!! WORTH A TRIP FROM LIKE ACROSS THE PLANET
I took two bites and I’m full. SO, worth it to come see,
We can enjoy this on Sabbath????
WHAT???
Thank you Jesus
and then Benny
and hosts.
Simply delicious, nothing simple about this pie!!?!?!?!?? Super fresh ingredients and the Pie is almost like , would feed an ARMY. I’m so, greatful to God!!! I lIve down the road best in Hudson valley, it’s even FAR beats Picnic pizza in Kingston, Id’e say, serious competition, I VOTE BENNY’S ALL THE WAY !!! No cheapy going on here! So splurge, so worth it. Did I say that already, sorry just I’m really amazed. Ok goodnight.
… moreI took two bites and I’m full. SO, worth it to come see,
We can enjoy this on Sabbath????
WHAT???
Thank you Jesus
and then Benny
and hosts.
Simply delicious, nothing simple about this pie!!?!?!?!?? Super fresh ingredients and the Pie is almost like , would feed an ARMY. I’m so, greatful to God!!! I lIve down the road best in Hudson valley, it’s even FAR beats Picnic pizza in Kingston, Id’e say, serious competition, I VOTE BENNY’S ALL THE WAY !!! No cheapy going on here! So splurge, so worth it. Did I say that already, sorry just I’m really amazed. Ok goodnight.
Karamo Kourouma (Blackflash22)
The house salad was great, the Philly cheese steak was alright. The wings were great.
… moreEverett VanOrden
I visited Benny’s for the first time last night, it was crowded and very busy. I was a few minutes early for my pickup so I waited and rang out while the food was being prepared. Come to find out that one of my items was missed, like I said… they were VERY busy, so no big deal. It was immediately prepped and cooked for me. When it was ready I realized I forgot the sodas and ordered them. When I tried to pay for the sodas, the Owner wouldn’t hear of it. He didn’t have to do that at all. I wasn’t upset in the least, but it was a very nice gesture.
This is a true “Family run Restaurant”.
I was very happy and impressed with the service I received and the food was simply amazing! I will be recommending Benny’s to anyone and everyone. Truly a great experience.
I’m definitely going to come back again and again!
… moreThis is a true “Family run Restaurant”.
I was very happy and impressed with the service I received and the food was simply amazing! I will be recommending Benny’s to anyone and everyone. Truly a great experience.
I’m definitely going to come back again and again!
Brian Fryer
Up in Accord for the New Year’s cheer,
With my Manhattan friends, grabbing pizza and beer.
The crust is perfection, a crispy delight,
The sauce isn’t heavy, the cheese is just right.
Margherita was fresh, and the Pepperoni had heat,
(With jalapeños added, a spicy treat).
No grease on the fold, just flavor and crunch,
Benny’s is the spot if you need a good munch.
…
In all seriousness, the crust was perfectly crispy and the ratios were spot on: perfect amount of sauce and melty cheese that didn’t taste greasy. I grabbed a pepperoni slice with jalapeños and my buddy got the Margherita; both were on point.
Highly recommend if you are in the area!
… moreWith my Manhattan friends, grabbing pizza and beer.
The crust is perfection, a crispy delight,
The sauce isn’t heavy, the cheese is just right.
Margherita was fresh, and the Pepperoni had heat,
(With jalapeños added, a spicy treat).
No grease on the fold, just flavor and crunch,
Benny’s is the spot if you need a good munch.
…
In all seriousness, the crust was perfectly crispy and the ratios were spot on: perfect amount of sauce and melty cheese that didn’t taste greasy. I grabbed a pepperoni slice with jalapeños and my buddy got the Margherita; both were on point.
Highly recommend if you are in the area!
James Lanier
To anyone who has left less than a 5 star review for this place- BIG EYEROLL. I’d like to start by saying that the owner is such a delight! We had the pleasure of meeting Benny in his restaurant today. He is a passionate, selfless, hard working man who loves what he does and gives back to the community AND THAT is something to be admired and respected. Sadly, some people have nothing better to do than give bad reviews to business’s that have been operated by a family that loves their community for 30+ years because their pepperoni was upside down. The staff were all happy and helpful. We ordered a Large Sicilian chicken bacon ranch pizza and a gluten/dairy free veggie and chicken pizza. When our order first came out I noticed that my pizza had cheese on it. I ((kindly)) let Benny’s daughter know and she immediately offered to remake the pizza. I told her that they did not need to remake the pizza and that i would just have a salad. She insisted on remaking the pizza AND and a beautiful salad made for me. I was also brought a grilled chicken breast to have with the salad. The veggies, chicken and dressing was SO GOOD! Benny told me that the balsamic vinegar at dressing was made in house. I asked if i could buy some and he told me that they did not sell it but gave me two additional cups to take with me. I was still eating when my husband and girls had finished. The girls were offered ice cream once they finished. Two homemade cannolis were brought out with my brand-new pizza! We were sent home with so much food and treats at not additional cost to us. Im so grateful for the love that we were shown today. It was a wonderful experience and we will be sending recommendations to anyone we know visiting the area. Im telling you all of this to say “Don’t be a jerk and you might be surprised at how people want to treat you.” There are good people in the world and we need to be good to them.
… moreODell Gordon
In response to my previous post (mozzarella sticks $8.75, ginger ale $3.75, tax 1.00, credit card fee $1.50 = $15. I wasn’t commenting or coming from a place a malice. I was merely pointing out the fact that times have change and the cost of these items have increased dramatically. I chose to pay with a credit card because I don’t carry cash. But please don’t mistake me for someone who needs or wants a discount. I do well for myself. However, if you want I can exercise that offer and stop in for that discount and post on how generous it was…. Let me know thank you.
… moreJenn Markett
Stopped in after seeing rave reviews on Facebook – not from the area so was curious to try. Pizza was delicious! Toppings so generous and the owner was such a nice man and very kind to include some samples to try ! My whole family thoroughly enjoyed! Definitely will be back when I am in the area!
… moreJohn Pomeroy
This place has the best pizza. It has been the better part of a decade since I have had this wonderful pizza. I moved out of the area but this used to be a normal dinning spot for me. I was back visiting family and this place was on my bucket list. The pricing is good. They have indoor and outdoor seating. The staff is friendly and efficient. Honestly when I ate here it was if nothing changed. I mean this in 100 percent positive way. What they have works and works well. You will not be disappointed if you are looking good pizza.
… morecasey sutton
The Chicken Bacon Ranch, and Buffalo Chicken Pizza are the best I’ve ever had by far, always get a slice or pie once a month, this usually would be enough to convince you to try, but if you like wings…. they are huge, and sauced perfect and crispy! Don’t complain about price when your getting gourmet meal experience. Never change your recipes, and look forward to seeing a combo of the 2 pies I enjoy, a Buffalo chicken/bacon/and ranch or even blue cheese would be awesome.
… moreangelo bonello
Absolutely love this hidden gem.. pizza is phenomenal also had the chicken Rosalie hero, it was huge, very flavorful with fresh basil from the outside garden. If you like fresh mozzarella, chicken cutlet, fresh roasted peppers then you must try it
… more