Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1523 PA-715, Stroudsburg, PA 18360
Phone: (570) 420-7770
Website: http://bennyspizzapa.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bennys Pizza
Benny’s Pizzeria 715. 1523 ROUTE 715, STROUDSBURG, PA 18360. 570•420•7770. Benny’s pizzeria 115. 2660 ROUTE 115, EFFORT, PA 18330. 570•730•4343. © 2025 Benny’s …
Benny’s Pizzeria | Stroudsburg PA – Facebook
We’re OPEN! The ovens are hot and we’re ready to serve you! Come grab your favorites at Benny’s — see you soon! Lisa Morykan and 16 others.
Benny’s Pizza, 1523 Route 715, Stroudsburg, PA 18360, US
Benny’s Pizza in Stroudsburg, PA offers a delicious selection of pizzas and other Italian dishes in a casual dining atmosphere.
Reviews
Angel Sanchez
My family ordered a Margherita pizza and an order of garlic knots. You can tell the flavor is really there, the sauce and ingredients tasted fresh and the seasoning was pretty good. That being said, there was way too much sauce on the pizza. It was so overloaded that every slice was unfortunately soggy, which took away from our experience. I do plan to come back and give them another try because the flavor was genuinely good, just hoping for a better balance next time.
… moreJessica Amico
I can’t say enough good things about Benny’s; this place blew me away!
I had noticed on the menu there was a Sloppy Joe Pizza and Benny had kindly let me know they aren’t offering it any longer. I had asked if I could bring the ingredients he would need to make it for me and he had one of his drivers go pick up what was needed to make the pizza and it did NOT disappoint!
Every bite was packed with flavor, clearly made with fresh ingredients and a lot of love; it was out of this world.
Whether you’re local or just passing through, do yourself a favor and stop at Benny’s. It’s the kind of place you tell your friends about and find yourself craving days later. I’ll definitely be back!
… moreI had noticed on the menu there was a Sloppy Joe Pizza and Benny had kindly let me know they aren’t offering it any longer. I had asked if I could bring the ingredients he would need to make it for me and he had one of his drivers go pick up what was needed to make the pizza and it did NOT disappoint!
Every bite was packed with flavor, clearly made with fresh ingredients and a lot of love; it was out of this world.
Whether you’re local or just passing through, do yourself a favor and stop at Benny’s. It’s the kind of place you tell your friends about and find yourself craving days later. I’ll definitely be back!
Mark Sell
I was away for a weekend vacation and came across bennys. My family and I had the pizza. We loved the pizza and found it was delicious. If I’m around there again I will definitely go back.
… moreAnggy Victor
It’s amazing place to eat, pizza tastes so good. We ordered margarita pizza and Hawaiian pizza (personal each one) (it’s have 8 slices) and also we ordered bacon cheddar cheese French fries. We’re plenty happy with that. And kind attention as well.
… morePyro Cinical
We found Benny’s on our way to the mall. Decided to sample their pizza first. We’re glad we did as we thoroughly enjoyed their Meat Lover pizza. They also offers a good variety of sandwiches and Italian dishes as well.
Staff was friendly, and service was fast. It seems to be family owned and operated. At the time of our dining, interior was well decorated for Halloween, which gives a nice touch for the season. They may not be the best in the area, but they do provide a quality pizza at a good price.
… moreStaff was friendly, and service was fast. It seems to be family owned and operated. At the time of our dining, interior was well decorated for Halloween, which gives a nice touch for the season. They may not be the best in the area, but they do provide a quality pizza at a good price.
Jason Myers
We were staying at Kalahari Resort in the Poconos and we were looking for a place to get pizza. After searching google maps, we found Benny’s. It was a about a 20 minute drive, and the reviews were good, so we took a chance on driving a little further. It was well worth the drive. We ordered a cheese pizza, a taco pizza, fries, and Chicken Marsala. The pizzas had amazing flavor, the fries were good, and the Chicken Marsala was excellent. The pizza crust was great, and the edge of the pizza was just right, not to thick, not thin, and it wasn’t dried out like a lot of pizzas. We are from South Central PA, we have plenty of pizza restaurants in the area, but none of their pizzas compare to Benny’s.
The staff was very friendly. It’s a little off the beaten path, but worth the drive. The outside of building could use a refresh, which makes you wonder, but the inside is very nice and looks like it was updated recently. If we travel back to the area, we would dine at Benny’s again.
We definitely recommend Benny’s to anyone that is looking for great food at a good price.
… moreThe staff was very friendly. It’s a little off the beaten path, but worth the drive. The outside of building could use a refresh, which makes you wonder, but the inside is very nice and looks like it was updated recently. If we travel back to the area, we would dine at Benny’s again.
We definitely recommend Benny’s to anyone that is looking for great food at a good price.
Debby Park
Always friendly. They treat you like family. Owner’s family comes to the table to talk to you. Love their pizza and sandwiches when on the go. We ate in this time. Great atmosphere and decorated tactfully for the holidays.
… moreJeff Blackburn
Don’t let the outside appearance fool you this local restaurant is not just a pizza joint, their also servings up some fantastic pasta dishes. We had 4 different pasta dishes and everyone of them was made to perfection. The Penna al Volka was so flavorful that it matched what I’ve had in many high priced restaurants that charge twice as much. The menu has a good selection of items to pick from and the service was outstanding. I wish I lived in the area so I could go back and try every item on the menu.
… moreExecutive Jeff
Benny’s was the first stop out of 5 stops in an effort to try 5 different pizza spots in an hour. The crust at Benny’s was super light, crispy,and delicious. Out of the 5 stops I would put this place at 4th place, and it’s all due to the lack of sauce or flavor of it…its hard to tell. The sauce was kinda absent, but if there was more of it, maybe I would have liked it more…idk. maybe because there wasnt enough for my liking that’s why I liked the crust so much? Either way,this was still a good slice. What I could taste of the sauce that was on it, it wasnt bad. Staff was super nice and friendly. They had a couple of small dining rooms with some tables for in house dining. Pretty decent slice, gonna go with a flat 7 outta 10….
… moreMaggie J
We loved our ghost pizza tonight. Kids thought it was so ghoul
… more