Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 327 Thelma Dr, Casper, WY 82609
Phone: (307) 337-1335
Website: http://bennymontanaros.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Benny Montanaro’s
Benny Montanaro’s is located at 327 Thelma Drive, in the Plaza East Shopping Mall. Benny guarantees you won’t be hungry when you leave. Menu …
Benny Montanaro’s | Casper WY – Facebook
Located at 327 Thelma drive Casper, wyoming 82609. Pizza place · $. . Follow. Details. . 94% recommend (14 Reviews). . $. . 327 Thelma Dr, Casper, …
Order Benny Montanaro’s – Casper, WY Menu Delivery … – DoorDash
Benny Montanaro’s delivered to your door. Benny Montanaro’s. Store Info. Trending Restaurants. KFCWendy’sLoaf N JugPizza HutTaco Bell. Top Dishes Near Me.
Reviews
CybrSlydr
It says on the website that the pizza is 28″, but it doesn’t really compute until the little delivery gal shows up with this ridiculously too big box.
I mean… I knew it was big, but wow! For a single guy like me, there’s enough food in one pizza for a whole week.
One slice is an entire meal. I tried to put the left overs in a gallon ziploc bag, but they wouldn’t fit.
Good news is the pizza tastes great. Super foldable but solid enough it doesn’t fall apart. Sauce is good. Dough is good.
If I ever have a party or something, this would be perfect. Save yourself and just order it by the slice. 😀
… moreI mean… I knew it was big, but wow! For a single guy like me, there’s enough food in one pizza for a whole week.
One slice is an entire meal. I tried to put the left overs in a gallon ziploc bag, but they wouldn’t fit.
Good news is the pizza tastes great. Super foldable but solid enough it doesn’t fall apart. Sauce is good. Dough is good.
If I ever have a party or something, this would be perfect. Save yourself and just order it by the slice. 😀
Sebastian
The food is amazing and massive but the white guy with a beard and glasses behind the counter absolutely hates his job and made ordering really uncomfortable i love the drink selection too
… moreBig Aych
We had the whole place to ourselves at 2:00 pm on a Saturday. We ordered a slice of pepperoni and a slice of pepperoni with Italian sausage with two Cokes (from Mexico). The slices were GREAT (and HUGE) and the Cokes good. We are pleasantly full. We will definitely be back!!!
… moreEmpty Nesters
Make sure if you get more than one slice of pizza that you’d better be hungry cuz one slice will definitely do ya! We ordered 3 for the two of us and we are gonna have to save the third slice, we are stuffed!
Lovvvve this pizza! Wish we could take ya’all home with us!
Highly recommend!
… moreLovvvve this pizza! Wish we could take ya’all home with us!
Highly recommend!
Ed Thompson
Huge pizzas that were cooked perfectly. Good fresh tasting cheese, tangy sauce, soft dough with a crispy crust. Nice hint of garlic salt on the crust too. Downside was the toppings were skimped on. I was debating on 3 stars, but the rest of the pie was great. I hope they cover more of the pizza next time.
… moreBrandy Faran
This was honestly the worst pizza I have had .. very cardboard texture and tase .. and the older gentleman who works the register is straight up mean and nasty totally annoyed that you walked thru the door !! .. the tables were dirty and floor was gross around the table
… moreEric Paulson
Amazing local pizza pie restaurant . Slices as big as your head. Great for a quick lunch or a family night out.
… moreMemphis Kidwell
We love Benny’s! Always great all around every time we have them.
… moreKrysta Riegert
This was our first time having pizza from Benny’s. We had very friendly service and the wait for two 28″ pizzas wasn’t a very long one. My family loves pizza, I’m not a huge fan of pizza in general, this is my favorite pizza in town. I was surprised that my daughter and I were the only ones in there at the moment. It’s such a nice space. I know they are pretty expensive but I saw the by the slice prices and they were reasonable for the portion size.
… moreEdward Williams
This place is BOMB. The pizza has always been fresh everytime I’ve went there or have had it delivered. Definitely a great place to take the entire family or if you have some friends from out of town visiting feeds everyone for a great price!
… more