Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 232 E Michigan Ave, Kalamazoo, MI 49007
Phone: (269) 903-2828
Website: http://bennydicartas.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Benny DiCarta’s
Why Kalamazoo? Benny has family ties to the area since the Prohibition days and we are excited to bring our 28″ pizza to the Great Lakes. Bell’s, Benny’s, …
Benny DiCarta’s | Kalamazoo MI – Facebook
Benny DiCarta’s, Kalamazoo. 3504 likes · 63 talking about this · 1268 were here. Casual pizzeria.
Order from Benny DiCarta’s
unavailable. Tomorrow at 6:46 AM. From: 232 E Michigan Ave, Kalamazoo, MI. Change location. Slices. Whole Pies. Drinks. Dipping Sauces and Extras. Picked For …
Reviews
Megan Start
Not only is this pizza unique!
Its tastes amazing and is affordable!
The menu is simple, but delicious! We love supporting this business!
Kids especially think its awesome.
… moreIts tastes amazing and is affordable!
The menu is simple, but delicious! We love supporting this business!
Kids especially think its awesome.
² ƒathomɀ
Gigantic 2 plate slices on demand. Cool options and huge pieces but personally I prefer mine cooked a little longer than they serve up. drinks by cooler only. worth a visit to wow yourself if nothing else.
… moreDoug Sluiter II
I travel a lot and a good slice of pizza is a regular workday side quest. Benny DiCarta’s did not disappoint and is a new regular stop. The slices are giant.
… moreMark Tan
Probably the best pizza in Kalamazoo area. It’s pizza by the slice – big slice, good undercarriage, good crunch, and they feel light. Only feedback was they forgot our order and we had to follow up after more than 30 minutes.
… moreben brockman
Staff is super helpful and nice. The slices are massive! Extremely good value for money here. The crust is flippin perfect too. I highly recommend this pizza!
… moreS.T.B Swat Team Bunny
The pizza is the prefect combo of New York slice meets college nostalgia. Team was awesome and kind. Well worth the price for a full pie
… moreKellee Marquard
Best tasting pizza in town. We’ve tried many different places since moving here and this is our favorite! It’s around 6 dollars a slice which are hugeeee! And a whole pizza is 40$ but is 28inches wide. So you get your money’s worth. The people are friendly. The atmosphere is calm hole in the wall. Their garlic sauce is what Papa Johns used to be.
… moreMichael Austin
Read a few reviews and figured I would stop in for a quick slice before grabbing dinner later. The “Slice” was $6 even. I had no idea I would be getting not only the biggest slice I have ever had but also one of the best damn pizzas I have ever had. Sauce was on point, crust was nice and crispy. No flop at all on this baby
Staff was nice and quick, pizza was amazing. 10/10. I’ll be back tomorrow
… moreStaff was nice and quick, pizza was amazing. 10/10. I’ll be back tomorrow
Chris Kline
First time visiting and well worth the time!
Met the owner and received a very unique history of the business and their artistic passion in New York style pizza.
While there may be limited options for pizza (cheese, pepperoni, specialty, and mushroom garlic), their specialty pizzas rotate and provide a unique name and an ingredient list to match. The crust is light with a unique crunch throughout.
Be aware that these pizzas and their slices are MASSIVE! You will not be disappointed.
… moreMet the owner and received a very unique history of the business and their artistic passion in New York style pizza.
While there may be limited options for pizza (cheese, pepperoni, specialty, and mushroom garlic), their specialty pizzas rotate and provide a unique name and an ingredient list to match. The crust is light with a unique crunch throughout.
Be aware that these pizzas and their slices are MASSIVE! You will not be disappointed.
Nathon Blake
Tasha was amazing person she handle us new comers very well helped us find something we would like n gave us the truth I love it definitely recommend bringing the kids and family up here anytime. Definitely leaving full belly’s. And if your wife pregnant promise she’ll love all the flavors n textures at this place
… more