Social Profile: 
… View more
Originally opened in 1994, Bennett’s has evolved from an auto parts store into one of downtown La Crosse’s must-visit locations for good food, strong drinks, and stronger friendships. We have a rich history with a great story to tell. But, it takes some time to tell a great story. So keep checking back as Daron continues to uncover the great history of this legendary downtown establishment.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 213 3rd St S, La Crosse, WI 54601
Phone: (608) 502-7501
Website: https://bennettorileys.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pubs & Restaurants in La Crosse, WI | Bennett O’Riley’s
Visit Bennett O’Riley’s, the best bar & restaurant in La Crosse, WI. Enjoy handmade pizza, cold drinks, and great vibes. Stop by or view our menu today!
South La Crosse — Bennett O’Riley’s
Bennett O’Riley’s South La Crosse provides delicious pub favorites, a lively atmosphere, and exceptional service. Visit us for a memorable dining …
Bennett O’Riley’s South La Crosse – Facebook
. Closed now. . 4329 Mormon Coulee Road, La Crosse, WI, United States, 54601. Links. . bennettorileys.com. Contact info. . (608) 502-7501. . bennettoriley@ …
Reviews
Yhskj dihs Did
Here’s a quick NED review for Bennett O’Riley’s Pub:
—
✅ What Works Well
– Classic Irish pub atmosphere—warm, lively, and inviting.
– Great selection of beers, including Irish favorites and local brews.
– Friendly, attentive staff with good service.
– Solid pub food menu featuring staples like fish & chips, shepherd’s pie, and burgers.
– Good spot for watching sports or enjoying live music nights.
—
What to Watch Out For
– Can get crowded and noisy during peak hours.
– Some dishes can be hit-or-miss on flavor or portion size.
– Decor is traditional but a bit dated.
—
Verdict
Bennett O’Riley’s Pub delivers a reliable Irish pub experience with tasty food and a great beer selection, perfect for casual dining or socializing with friends. Great for fans of classic pub vibes and good times.
Rating: ~3.5 to 4 / 5
… more—
✅ What Works Well
– Classic Irish pub atmosphere—warm, lively, and inviting.
– Great selection of beers, including Irish favorites and local brews.
– Friendly, attentive staff with good service.
– Solid pub food menu featuring staples like fish & chips, shepherd’s pie, and burgers.
– Good spot for watching sports or enjoying live music nights.
—
What to Watch Out For
– Can get crowded and noisy during peak hours.
– Some dishes can be hit-or-miss on flavor or portion size.
– Decor is traditional but a bit dated.
—
Verdict
Bennett O’Riley’s Pub delivers a reliable Irish pub experience with tasty food and a great beer selection, perfect for casual dining or socializing with friends. Great for fans of classic pub vibes and good times.
Rating: ~3.5 to 4 / 5
Bert
Our Pickleball group meets the second Tuesday of every month for an outing. This past funds outing was at Ben O’Reilly‘s pub, and there was probably 40 of us in the back room. We had a server by the name of Bella, who took care of every one of us and she was spot on and pleasant as could be.
… moreSean Navin (Sean N)
Ordered takeout this past Saturday at South location so hard to rate the place on other things. First time eating from here.
This was $20. They forgot the beer cheese sauce on the side so maybe that’s why it looks so skimpy. My wife got their deluxe burger and the amount of fries included was disappointing.
… moreThis was $20. They forgot the beer cheese sauce on the side so maybe that’s why it looks so skimpy. My wife got their deluxe burger and the amount of fries included was disappointing.
Caroline Elizabeth
THIS IS THE BEST BAR IN LA CROSSE! I’m serious, yall. Aside from the great pricing and food options, the bartenders are the best! I left my purse at the bar 10 months ago and they held it for me… with everything intact! Im still in shock. Can’t trust anyone to do that where I’m from (Atlanta ). I love the Midwest! Seriously, the best people and the best bar. Shoutout to Jake!! You’re the man! See you all soon!!! Cheers!!
… moreDon L. Hahn
Nice bar, Sammie was a friendly bartender. 10/10 would visit again.
… moreBeth Blakemore
Great place where you feel like family. Awesome wings with homemade sauces, yummy Bloody Mary’s and friendly service.
… moreJeny Smock
Went on a Friday night which was busy as all get out per usual. Bar was hoping place was packed, but only one bartender.
… moreJonathan Wood
My wife and I have never been here before and we wanted to try it. Service was great. Place was busy and their bartender/server Christine rocked the service. The food was far better than we expected. I found out from Christine that the bruschetta egg rolls were coming off the specials. I would literally come back to this restaurant just to eat those. So please keep them on the menu. We also had a burger and a wrap. All the food was amazing. We will definitely come back.
… moreCheryl Miller
We like the place, food is good, but we have had very poor customer service last few times. The owner needs to understand how poorly customers are treated? No corned beef 3/17 by 530 pm? We left tonight because no service, and watched at least 10 people walk out AFTER being seated! Yikes!!! All within 10 minutes! If I owned, I would want to know how BAD the service is ! What a shame, we are soo close, but will not go back or refer anyone there?! Why is there no active manager on site? Seating and directing staff members what to do? Unbelievable?
… moreLori Lowell
My first time dining experience was very enjoyable on a busy Saturday night. Great atmosphere with industrial/modern decor and friendly, helpful employees. The Bennett Special hamburger was perfectly cooked/seasoned and served on a delicious bun with fresh vegetables and their special sauce; this is the best burger I’ve eaten in a long time!! I am highly recommending the crispy seasoned tator tots as the side. I look forward to sitting on the patio when it opens while trying the pizza when the full menu starts.
… more