Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hearty helpings of classic Italian fare dished up in a simple, long-running (since 1968) trattoria.
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Benito One: Authentic Italian Cuisine in the Heart of NYC
Experience the best of Italian flavors at Benito One located at 174 Mulberry St, New York. Enjoy a variety of appetizers, soups, salads, and entrees with …
Benito One Reviews – Authentic Italian in NYC
Discover Benito One at 174 Mulberry St, New York. A cozy spot serving homemade Italian dishes with true Little Italy charm and heartwarming service.
Benito One, 174 Mulberry St, Frnt A, New York, NY 10013, US
Get more information for Benito One in New York, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Smokin Barrel Barbeque – New Pal
We ate at Benito One today and it was absolutely phenomenal. The chicken parmigiana was hands-down the best I’ve ever had — perfectly cooked, full of flavor, and clearly made with care. The Alfredo was incredibly rich and decadent, the kind you keep thinking about long after the meal is over.
What truly set the experience apart was the service. It was personal, warm, and genuinely amazing — you can tell they care deeply about their guests. From the food to the atmosphere to the hospitality, everything was top-notch. We will absolutely be back and highly recommend Benito One to anyone looking for an outstanding meal.
… moreWhat truly set the experience apart was the service. It was personal, warm, and genuinely amazing — you can tell they care deeply about their guests. From the food to the atmosphere to the hospitality, everything was top-notch. We will absolutely be back and highly recommend Benito One to anyone looking for an outstanding meal.
Adriana
It was a bit of a surprise to find this place, cause usually it’s always a tourist trap. But this place is SO GOOD!
While the place is very tiny, is so cozy, Italian and magical.
The food served is truly Italian with such nice flavors and quality ingredients. The atmosphere is great with great music and big windows to little Italy.
The service is great with excellent recommendations.
Definitely would recommend to try the chicken piccata, the Alfredo and of course a delicious Tiramisu!!!
Loved it!
… moreWhile the place is very tiny, is so cozy, Italian and magical.
The food served is truly Italian with such nice flavors and quality ingredients. The atmosphere is great with great music and big windows to little Italy.
The service is great with excellent recommendations.
Definitely would recommend to try the chicken piccata, the Alfredo and of course a delicious Tiramisu!!!
Loved it!
Ana Luiza Manetti
Traditional Italian restaurant. The pastas tasted amazing and the price is fair. The waiter was awesome, and super nice. The food is made fresh, and comes very hot. We ordered Veal Parm (comes with pasta), penne vodka and gnocchi carbonara. Their carbonara sauce is very well known, and delicious! Strongly recommend!!!
… moreJuan David L.G.
In the heart of the little Italy .
Served by Italians, amazing food and service.
Fair fair prices
Best place in this area! They will make you feel like you are in
… moreServed by Italians, amazing food and service.
Fair fair prices
Best place in this area! They will make you feel like you are in
James Colburn
Let me start by saying this ruined me to any other place. I had lasagna, and it was incredible. The service was great, and the atmosphere was perfect. Had some great classics playing. I tried some of the other dishes, and they were incredible as well. The chicken parmesan was some of the best I have ever had. Don’t pass this place up. It has history, great food, and great service. See you all next trip.
… morenyc ttocs6973
Lovely experience. Benito One serves up authentic Italian entrees with tastes and flavors that are unmatched. My go-to place to get away & enjoy dining experiences that transport you to a special space, so welcoming and festive with delicious eats. A special shout out to Cristian. Your hospitality was exceptional.
Thank you
… moreThank you
Olga Klempas
We only walked into this place because a guy outside was aggressively inviting us in, telling a story about how his grandmother used to cook here. After tasting the food, I can believe she might have cooked here — a very long time ago — but clearly none of her cooking skills were passed on.
The food was horrible.
The pasta was completely overcooked, the sauce was a disaster, and overall it felt like food from the cheapest tourist trap, not a proper restaurant in New York. This place may be run by Italians, but with no class or experience in cooking whatsoever.
The drinks were just as bad — low-level, poorly made, like something you’d get at a roadside dive. I didn’t even finish mine.
I didn’t eat the food either, and the staff showed zero interest in whether we liked anything or not. No questions, no care, nothing.
To make it worse, they charged us an extra $20 plus $8 for “excellent service”, which is simply a pure joke, because there was absolutely nothing excellent about the service.
Strongly not recommended. Avoid this place at all costs. Total tourist trap.
… moreThe food was horrible.
The pasta was completely overcooked, the sauce was a disaster, and overall it felt like food from the cheapest tourist trap, not a proper restaurant in New York. This place may be run by Italians, but with no class or experience in cooking whatsoever.
The drinks were just as bad — low-level, poorly made, like something you’d get at a roadside dive. I didn’t even finish mine.
I didn’t eat the food either, and the staff showed zero interest in whether we liked anything or not. No questions, no care, nothing.
To make it worse, they charged us an extra $20 plus $8 for “excellent service”, which is simply a pure joke, because there was absolutely nothing excellent about the service.
Strongly not recommended. Avoid this place at all costs. Total tourist trap.
Francisco Cappai
This is a really good Italian restaurant! The waiters, the owner, the decoration, the music, the atmosphere, the aromas, the surroundings, the menu. You feel like you are in a little town in the south of Italy. The seafood meals are very fresh and tasty, and the pastas and sauces and exquisite. Waiters were really friendly and treated us very well. I would come back every day just to try their different dishes.
… moreThibault O.G.R Gautier
Amazing Italian restaurant!
The service was good and fast, the waiter is very friendly!
The food was straight up incredible, rich and flavorful.
Highly recommend!
… moreThe service was good and fast, the waiter is very friendly!
The food was straight up incredible, rich and flavorful.
Highly recommend!
Brian Liamero
Really good and genuine people working there …great atmosphere and the food was excellent . We’ve struck out at a few places in little Italy but this one was very good and highly recommend. Native New Yorker here too so good job Benito!
… more