Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 208 W Chickasha Ave, Chickasha, OK 73018
Phone: (405) 320-5018
Website: http://benandjays.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Ben & Jay’s Pizzeria – Chickasha, OK – 208 W Chickasha Ave …
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Ben & Jay’s Pizzeria in Chickasha, OK. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
Ben & Jay’s Pizzeria – Chickasha, OK
The food taste great and prices are fair. Beer is cheap. The decor gives it a good atmosphere, with a classic Pizzeria vibe. Review by – Google. five star …
Ben & Jay’s Pizzeria | Chickasha OK – Facebook
Our chef-inspired pizza is a flavor-rich delight, fresh from the oven to your table. #BenAndJaysPizzeria #ChickashaEats #PizzaAndMore #OvenFresh # …
Last Updates
Reviews
Teri Hughes
My hub and I had a great experience eating here this evening. Our pizza was delicious. He got the salad bar and I got a Greek salad prior to our pizza, both very good. We will be back! A bonus, they have sloppy beers! Very reasonably priced.
… moreSamantha T
Solid pizza place with reasonable pricing.
We ordered an X-Large pepperoni and sausage, an X-Large mushroom jalapeño and pepperoni, a 10” pepperoni and olive, a half salad, fried pickles, and 5 drinks. The XL pizzas are 18”. The bill was $100, $118.00 with tip.
Drinks: our drinks stayed filled and the waitresses were both helpful and attentive. The tea is a brewed tea rather than a fountain tea (like Gold Peak). It tasted good and the sweet tea was not too sweet.
Fried Pickles: The pickle they use is very sour. It’s good, but know that it is a very sour dill pickle. The portion was good and enough for the whole table to enjoy.
Salad: The salad was fresh and a good size for a half salad. The ingredients were fresh.
Pizza: We ordered everything with light sauce. Even still the sauce was pretty heavy, so if you don’t like a lot of sauce I would suggest ordering light sauce. The sausage is sliced sausage not ground and the jalapeños were pickled, not fresh. All the ingredients were good quality and plentiful. The crust is light and crisp. I really enjoyed it.
I tried the tzatziki as well. The sauce is okay. They grate their cucumbers very finely so it has an odd texture and bitterness.
… moreWe ordered an X-Large pepperoni and sausage, an X-Large mushroom jalapeño and pepperoni, a 10” pepperoni and olive, a half salad, fried pickles, and 5 drinks. The XL pizzas are 18”. The bill was $100, $118.00 with tip.
Drinks: our drinks stayed filled and the waitresses were both helpful and attentive. The tea is a brewed tea rather than a fountain tea (like Gold Peak). It tasted good and the sweet tea was not too sweet.
Fried Pickles: The pickle they use is very sour. It’s good, but know that it is a very sour dill pickle. The portion was good and enough for the whole table to enjoy.
Salad: The salad was fresh and a good size for a half salad. The ingredients were fresh.
Pizza: We ordered everything with light sauce. Even still the sauce was pretty heavy, so if you don’t like a lot of sauce I would suggest ordering light sauce. The sausage is sliced sausage not ground and the jalapeños were pickled, not fresh. All the ingredients were good quality and plentiful. The crust is light and crisp. I really enjoyed it.
I tried the tzatziki as well. The sauce is okay. They grate their cucumbers very finely so it has an odd texture and bitterness.
Arram
Ben & Jay’s had no problem fixing this vegan a Garlic-O-Holic pizza, no cheese with a side of marinara!
It was delicious!!! Especially with the salad!!
My carnivorous work buddy had the pepperoni and loved it!
… moreIt was delicious!!! Especially with the salad!!
My carnivorous work buddy had the pepperoni and loved it!
Amy Barron
We stopped by to grab an order to go after an athletic event. Service was excellent. Food was excellent. They were closing for a private event, but I think the atmosphere would be pretty neat if it were a normal night. Ordered the supreme, meat pizza and Greek salad.
… moreSamantha Roush
Lillee was amazing! There was a little bit of a wait but it was just her working her butt off. But she was great, everything came out perfectly. Definitely needs more staff so she doesn’t have to burn her self out but 10/10
… moreHayley Stanley
Love their (original mozz sticks) I got stuck on them for awhile and would get them quite often but then they started changing them which I didn’t understand bc they’ve always been a good seller there…. They first changed them to these huge logs of cheese sticks in which I wanted nothing to do with lol then they changed them to ones that came out looking and tasting burnt with not as much seasoning which I was okay with those they were still decent, but went back tonight to get some and they changed them AGAIN to the photo pictured. It’s gotta be the fifth time! They’ve almost convinced me to stop buying from them! Bring back the old ones!! EDIT—— was supposed to get refunded seeing as I took them back last night for that purpose! Instead they still charged me 15 dollars will be going to the store today.
… moreDalton Gang
One Bite everyone knows the rules!!! Absolutely fantastic homemade pizza here at Ben and Jays in chick! Would have never known I wasn’t in New York City
… moreHarley Rose
Food is always great. But the service is always SO AWFUL. Waited 15 minutes for someone to come to our table for drinks…I’d understand if it was busy but there were very few tables and 3 waitresses around. Food came out at a decent time, but nobody came back until to check on us…we needed refills and ranch but they came after the food got cold and one person was already done with their food. This was a Saturday around 2/3.
… moreJohn Ortega
Locally owned gem!
Ben &Jay’s checked all the boxes for my wife and me!
-Friendly staff
-Casual atmosphere with a comfortable, hometown feel.
-Had the pleasure of meeting the fun and spunky owner.
-Outstanding and creative Pizzas with delicious ingredients and exceptional crust.
We might have to make the 3 hour trip again just for Ben & Jays pizza!!
Happy eating,
Erik & Rachel
… moreBen &Jay’s checked all the boxes for my wife and me!
-Friendly staff
-Casual atmosphere with a comfortable, hometown feel.
-Had the pleasure of meeting the fun and spunky owner.
-Outstanding and creative Pizzas with delicious ingredients and exceptional crust.
We might have to make the 3 hour trip again just for Ben & Jays pizza!!
Happy eating,
Erik & Rachel
TJ
Lillee was such a great server, I was seeing her doing everything, being the only person working the front. I had the Mr. Meaty pizza and it was amazing!
… more