
Bella Tuscany is an upscale Italian restaurant in Windermere serving fresh seafood, handmade pasta, steaks, and classic Italian cuisine. Family-owned and proudly serving the community since 2012, Bella Tuscany is beloved by locals and visitors alike. Guests enjoy a warm dining room, attentive service, an extensive Italian wine list, chef-prepared weekly features, and a full bar. Perfect for date nights, celebrations, business dinners, and relaxed dining near Disney, Winter Garden, Hamlin, and the Dr. Phillips area. Bella Tuscany also offers weekday lunch, outdoor dining, convenient takeout and delivery, and a curated wine program.
House-made pasta & Italian classics served in a warm, modern eatery with outdoor space & live music.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 13424 Summerport Village Pkwy, Windermere, FL 34786
Phone: (407) 656-2355
Website: https://bellatuscany.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: toasttab.comopentable.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Best Italian food in Windermere, FL | Bella Tuscany Windermere …
Bella Tuscany Italian Restaurant – Windermere, FL – 13424 …
Bella Tuscany Ristorante Italiano (@BellaTuscanyWindermere)
Last Updates
Reviews
Let’s talk about the food, absolutely amazing! Everything we ordered was delicious, but the star of the evening was the massive mozzarella sticks. Honestly, I’ve never seen mozzarella sticks that big and crispy on the outside, gooey and melty inside, full of flavor, and perfectly seasoned. If you go, please do yourself a favor and order those. They’re a must-have!
We also ordered pasta dishes, and again, the kitchen did not disappoint. I particularly loved the seafood pasta, perfectly cooked pasta, fresh seafood, and a savory sauce that wasn’t too heavy. The flavors were well-balanced and comforting. The rest of our table also enjoyed their meals, and everyone agreed that the food was excellent.
Unfortunately, where the experience fell flat was in the service department. Our server seemed disengaged and didn’t come around very often. When I asked for cheese (because who eats pasta without cheese, right?), he returned a while later, stood at the edge of the table and just asked, “Does anyone want cheese?” as if he was offering it randomly, not because I specifically requested it. I raised my hand, of course, but it felt awkward and honestly a bit ridiculous. It’s not a huge thing on its own, but small moments like this can really affect how welcome and attended to a guest feels.
It’s a shame because the food and setting set the bar high, but the inattentive service lowered the overall experience. I wish I remembered the server’s name because I don’t like leaving negative comments without details, but unfortunately I don’t. That said, with so many top-tier restaurants in the Windermere area, service has to match the quality of the food in order to compete. People don’t just come out for great meals, they come out to feel cared for and enjoy the whole experience.
Would I go back? Yes! for the food, absolutely. But I hope management takes a closer look at improving staff attentiveness and hospitality. It’s the missing piece to an otherwise wonderful place. With just a little more attention to customer service, Bella Tuscany could easily be one of the standout Italian restaurants in the area.
That said, I was extremely disappointed by our most recent experience. I planned a “Day-After-Valentine’s-Day” recovery brunch for my husband, specifically because we’ve enjoyed their Sunday brunch in the past. We arrived, were seated, and only then were told that they stopped offering brunch about a month ago.
While I completely understand that menus and service offerings change, I was surprised and frustrated that I couldn’t find any communication about this beforehand, not on their website or elsewhere. It would have saved us the trip and the confusion.
I still truly enjoy Bella Tuscany and will probably return for lunch or dinner, as the food and overall dining experience have always been wonderful. I just hope they’ll do a better job communicating major changes like this in the future so loyal customers aren’t caught off guard.