Victoria M
Stumbled onto this place completely by accident. My daughter and I ordered 1 garlic knot slice each. Owner was supper nice and friendly. The place was clean and cute and the pizza was AMAZING. Definitely will recommend and come back.
… moreCaitlin Bella
The most amazing place the food was incredible and so fresh my pizza & garlic knots!! The owner and the family were extremely friendly will definitely be my go to pizzeria for now on!
… moreAriana Belfiore
The absolute BEST pizza I have had in an extremely long time! I spent three weeks in Sicily and couldn’t find a better slice!! The grandma slice is my favorite!! The owner is such a sweet person. The place is clean with a really beautiful and unique train going through by the ceiling! So much love and care has gone into everything here !
… moreA A
Bella Pazza makes a great pizza consistently.
A nice, family run establishment.
We’ve been impressed with the pizza every visit this summer. He makes a great pie that has brought us back time and again. This time we got the garlic knot pie that I’ve been eyeing since I saw it on the menu. I didn’t have enough patience to photograph before digging in, but I posted a photo of what was left over. This was an awesome creation.
Not every pizzeria in the area makes good food. They know how to make good food here. The dough is the right thinness, the sauce is great, and they get the crust-sauce-cheese ratio correct. If the website is true in that they don’t use brominated flour, that’s the “icing on the cake.” I’ve been eating pizza in the Babylon/West Islip/Bay Shore area for 30 years and now when my family wants pizza takeout, we have to get it from Bella Pazza.
… moreЖеремей Zheya Сенько
Its been a while since I’ve been through.
Fantastic slices, definitely coming back again! Owner is super friendly and has excellent relationships with customers! One of my favourite joints for sure.
Next time I have to try the upside down ! ))
… morereynaldo ulloa
The Pizza here is great! I had two slices. The grandma slice was thin crispy and had a perfect balance of cheese and sauce. The garlic knot slice was new to me. Haven’t seen anyone else offer this combination of flavors. It had a great undercarriage. Thin and crispy, just like pizza should be. A huge plus is that they use NON-GMO NEVER BLEACHED, NEVER BROMATED FLOUR for their pizzas.
… moreRobin Appel Maida
FANTASTIC! This was the best pizza I’ve had in Babylon and I’ve lived here wince 2002. The owners were friendly and considerate making sure to cook the pizza how I wanted it to be. I look forward to going back trying more food!
… morePushpa Devi
For a new establishment, these guys need to keep their attitude down. I got broccoli pinwheel… usually anywhere you go, you get sauce with it… these guys charge 1.50 plus tax for small, and 2.50 plus tax for slightly larger cup. In addition… if you pay cash, you get “discount”. Funny thing is: all their prices are listed in cash…. So there’s no discount. If you pay by card, you pay 4% extra fees, by paying cash, you avoid that 4% fees. So maybe it’s the 4% discount that the place offers if you pay cash. No where does it mention that all prices are in cash to begin with… their prices are lie… especially if you pay cash. One person ahead of me paid 72.24 with card, when the card didn’t go through… he paid the SAME amount with cash. There ya go, enjoy the so called discount. Wish I could rate these guys 0. The cashier had 0 manners. He told me to go argue with Mastercard, visa, banks, not with him (even though it was just a discussion), and then he walked off on my face. There are plenty restaurants nearby that can outcompete these people, if they don’t keep their attitude in check, they lose out on customer service… they already lost the food quality. Food looks like it had been refrigerated and warmed up. See pics for proof.
… moreRenee Frye
This place has good pizza! We’ve been here before and loved it! We’ve been to many pizzareias on Long Island and this one ranks one of our top favorites!
Check out the pizza with the garlic knot crust! Their regular pizza is a little thinner.
… moreBrandon D’Onofrio
Was just here for a late afternoon lunch with my mom. Pizza was delicious no doubt about that. However, the customer service from the guy behind the counter could’ve been a little bit better. Also, the sprite and dr. pepper did not dispense correctly and came out as water from the machine and no ice at all btw. That’s why I’m giving this 3 stars and not 4 or 5, like I really wanted to. Oh and the guy charged me $1.00 extra for the meatball topping after I paid when I had clearly asked for meatball before while I was ordering and didn’t even look to say, “Thank you for coming, or have a great rest of your day!” as we were leaving. It’s the little things like manners that can really make a difference. Just somethings to think about.
… more