Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 12–7 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 468 S Washington St Suite 5, Afton, WY 83110
Phone: (307) 226-5858
Website: http://beepspizza.square.site/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Beeps Pizza
Discover JCB. Beeps Pizza logo. Select location. Find the nearest store. Beeps Pizza. 468 S Washington St. Ste 5. Afton, WY 83110. +100 miles. Store info.
Beeps Pizza | Afton WY – Facebook
Beeps Pizza is a New York inspired pizza company. Counter shop in Afton, WY. Online ordering: https://beepspizza.square.site
(@beepspizza) • Instagram photos and videos
NY inspired counter pizzeria in Afton, WY. Dine-in, take out, online ordering. Winner of 2025 @lcwyofair People’s Choice Best of the Fair contest!
Reviews
Justin Fague
This place is SO GOOD. My wife and I went here because we always have pizza night on Saturdays and we were not disappointed at all!! The sauce was delicious and the classic pepperoni was just wonderful. They also serve beer there so I got an IPA and it was also excellent! Definitely make sure to get the cheesy garlic bread – I was skeptical at first but after eating it, it’s totally worth it!
There aren’t a ton of tables indoors (we went in October) but there are some outside that will make it better to go when it’s warmer out. We would definitely come back!
… moreThere aren’t a ton of tables indoors (we went in October) but there are some outside that will make it better to go when it’s warmer out. We would definitely come back!
Phoebe B
Wow, absolutely loved this place!
The pizza was perfect, we each had a slice – one ricotta and hot honey, one pepperoni and hot honey. The crusts were so lovely and doughy and both had great flavours. They also offer full pizzas but great you can get a single slice if just stopping by.
They had Dr Browns soda bought in from New York too which was a great touch.
Staff were absolutely lovely!! Moved from New York so you know it’s a proper pizza! Must go to if you’re in the area.
… moreThe pizza was perfect, we each had a slice – one ricotta and hot honey, one pepperoni and hot honey. The crusts were so lovely and doughy and both had great flavours. They also offer full pizzas but great you can get a single slice if just stopping by.
They had Dr Browns soda bought in from New York too which was a great touch.
Staff were absolutely lovely!! Moved from New York so you know it’s a proper pizza! Must go to if you’re in the area.
Jaynie Connor
This is the best pizza I’ve ever had in my life. We got a slice of pepperoni with hot honey and a chocolate chip cookie. I will forever be thinking about how no other pizza can stand up to this one. Wonderful staff to boot! Worth the stop.
… moreMicaela Cay Hubbard
We had such an incredible experience here! The owners were so kind and accommodating. We came in with a larger group and they moved tables around to allow us to all sit together. The pizza was absolutely incredible! Some of the best I’ve ever had! Their Hot Honey Pizza was to die for! Absolutely recommend stopping here while driving through or visiting. Praying they open a location in Utah!
… moreNatasha Nelson
We’re in town for the weekend and tried Beeps Pizza for the first time. The pizza is fantastic!! The crust has the perfect texture, the sauce is flavorful, and the cheese ties it all together. The garlic bread deserves its own shout out as well! It’s easily the best we’ve had. We’ll definitely be ordering again before heading back home.
… moreKatie Roberts
Okay, of course the pizza is insanely perfect not too thick not too thin about delicious crust. Such flavorful sauce. The best selection of toppings. We got the New Yorker and it couldn’t have been any better. I also want to add the homemade cookie with the sea salt on top is something I dreamt about last night. The atmosphere is kind fun and easy. How did we look out in Star Valley getting this amazing place? Please stay forever and ever.
… moreTimothy Jennings
I came across BEEPS PIZZA at the Lincoln County Fair this past month. Being a lover of pizza I was a bit skeptical of finding a good pie at a county fair, yet alone in Star Valley Wyoming. Boy was I wrong! After waiting in a fairly long line I purchased 3 slices of pizza, one cheese and 2 pepperoni. Truthfully, this was the best pizza I have had in a very, very long time. Nothing in Wyoming can come close, and although Utah has some nice shops, this was simply the best I have had anywhere. What a complete surprise!!
… moreAlexia Alford
For real NY style pizza with real New Yorkers who are serving up delicious made from scratch pizza… hidden gym. Literally. It’s at the end of a quaint ally down a few yards from the local coffee shop.
I could tell their expertise when I bit into the crust. I’m a crust person so I’m picky with the texture and flavor. It’s hand tossed.
We had the hot honey pizza, a bottled Peroni, and a Caesar salad with homemade dressing. Regretfully I passed up the dessert choices of a homemade chocolate salted cookie or NY style cheesecake. Next time.
Excellent pass through spot.
Probably best for to-go since there’s not a ton of indoor seating. If the weather permits there’s some outside tables.
… moreI could tell their expertise when I bit into the crust. I’m a crust person so I’m picky with the texture and flavor. It’s hand tossed.
We had the hot honey pizza, a bottled Peroni, and a Caesar salad with homemade dressing. Regretfully I passed up the dessert choices of a homemade chocolate salted cookie or NY style cheesecake. Next time.
Excellent pass through spot.
Probably best for to-go since there’s not a ton of indoor seating. If the weather permits there’s some outside tables.
David Marchman
Just off the main drag in Afton – right at the Elk Antler Arch, is a small alley with a great coffee shop with a fantastic pizza joint next door. The pizza has one of those perfect NY style crusts – thin and crunchy with a soft chewy texture. Topped by a flavorful sauce emphasizing the flavor of the tomatoes and then covered with a generous portion of cheeses. The pizza was fantastic. Just remember to buy some cookies while you are there. You’ll thank me.
… moreMatthew Henrich
I was with a group going on a trip through this area of Wyoming and found this was one of the very few places open on a Sunday. I found I could order online and the menu was not complicated (I appreciated that), but I called first to make sure they were open.
Right away, Beep was an absolute pleasure to talk with on the phone. She helped me with menu options and sides that would work for a group of 10. When she learned we would stop to eat, she asked our ETA to be sure food was hot and ready.
We came in to a table set for 10 with plates in place. We got the New Yorker, Hot Honey, Margherita, and a Pepp. They were all bomb. Fresh ingredients, excellent flavor and texture. The Sweet Beep was phenomenal (and they sliced it up for our group).
Overall we just had a great time eating and talking with Brock and Beep. Best pizza I’ve had in awhile (and I’ve had a good handful in SoCal)!!
… moreRight away, Beep was an absolute pleasure to talk with on the phone. She helped me with menu options and sides that would work for a group of 10. When she learned we would stop to eat, she asked our ETA to be sure food was hot and ready.
We came in to a table set for 10 with plates in place. We got the New Yorker, Hot Honey, Margherita, and a Pepp. They were all bomb. Fresh ingredients, excellent flavor and texture. The Sweet Beep was phenomenal (and they sliced it up for our group).
Overall we just had a great time eating and talking with Brock and Beep. Best pizza I’ve had in awhile (and I’ve had a good handful in SoCal)!!