Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5 Beartown Rd, Painted Post, NY 14870
Phone: (607) 937-5219
Website: https://www.facebook.com/Beartown-Peaches-n-Cream-68183027742/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Beartown Peaches ‘n Cream | Painted Post NY – Facebook
Beartown Peaches ‘n Cream isn’t letting left over produce go to waste, they are helping feed local seniors. Apples, pears, potatoes, peppers, onions, squash, …
Beartown Peaches and Cream – MapQuest
Get more information for Beartown Peaches and Cream in Painted Post, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Beartown Peaches ‘n Cream | Painted Post NY – Facebook
. Page · Ice Cream Shop ; . 5 Beartown Rd, Painted Post, NY, United States, New York ; . (607) 937-5219 ; . Open now ; . Price Range · $.
Reviews
R K
Evening Treat at Beartown Peaches & Cream – A Soft Serve Sampler in Painted Post, NY
Stopped by Beartown Peaches & Cream in Painted Post, NY, for a quick ice cream fix. The place has that nostalgic roadside charm, with a big, bold sign and a casual walk-up window that makes it feel like summer even on cooler evenings. I decided to try their soft serve chocolate and espresso coffee swirl, served in a cup with a fun upside-down cone stuck on top—definitely a playful presentation that made for a great photo-op.
As for the flavor, it was okay but didn’t quite hit the mark for me. The chocolate was smooth but very mild, and the espresso flavor was quite faint—almost unnoticeable. I was hoping for a stronger coffee punch, especially since espresso usually has a bold profile. The texture of the soft serve was creamy and pleasant, but the overall taste didn’t wow me.
That said, I have a feeling their hard ice cream options might be stronger in flavor and worth coming back for. This visit felt more like a casual stop than a standout ice cream experience, but the setting is friendly and inviting.
If you’re passing through and want something sweet, it’s still worth checking out—just maybe skip the soft serve and try the scoops instead!
… moreStopped by Beartown Peaches & Cream in Painted Post, NY, for a quick ice cream fix. The place has that nostalgic roadside charm, with a big, bold sign and a casual walk-up window that makes it feel like summer even on cooler evenings. I decided to try their soft serve chocolate and espresso coffee swirl, served in a cup with a fun upside-down cone stuck on top—definitely a playful presentation that made for a great photo-op.
As for the flavor, it was okay but didn’t quite hit the mark for me. The chocolate was smooth but very mild, and the espresso flavor was quite faint—almost unnoticeable. I was hoping for a stronger coffee punch, especially since espresso usually has a bold profile. The texture of the soft serve was creamy and pleasant, but the overall taste didn’t wow me.
That said, I have a feeling their hard ice cream options might be stronger in flavor and worth coming back for. This visit felt more like a casual stop than a standout ice cream experience, but the setting is friendly and inviting.
If you’re passing through and want something sweet, it’s still worth checking out—just maybe skip the soft serve and try the scoops instead!
Abhilash Yerra
Honestly was surprised by the flavors. It was thick and not too sweet and sizes of the scoops were massive. The lady at the front gave pretty good suggestions and you can sample up to 3 flavors. Would love to visiting again soon and try out other flavors
… moreLake Kubilius
Fantastic place to stop and cool down from the summer heat. Has a few vegan flavors, including a rotating Dole Whip soft serve flavor. Portions run huge, and the pricing is extremely reasonable. Try it!
… moreAlyssa Puhacz
We take all of our out-of-town visitors here. They serve Perry’s ice cream and more. They have huge portions and low prices! Highly recommend.
… moreJeffrey Liu
Peaches N Cream is a local institution. Huge menu, warm vibe, and friendly people.
Can’t decide? Ask Dani for recommendations! She’ll build you something phenomenal you never knew you needed.
~
My recent obsessions here:
1. Kahlua Almond Amaretto
2. Bittersweet Symphony
3. Praline Turtle
4. Caramel with coffee/toffee
5. Super Berry Açaí
6. Apple Cider Donut Sundae
… moreCan’t decide? Ask Dani for recommendations! She’ll build you something phenomenal you never knew you needed.
~
My recent obsessions here:
1. Kahlua Almond Amaretto
2. Bittersweet Symphony
3. Praline Turtle
4. Caramel with coffee/toffee
5. Super Berry Açaí
6. Apple Cider Donut Sundae
The Blue Whale (Gabe)
This is an absolutely wonderful store. All local foods and produce. Their greenhouse full of mums is so fun to visit. They not only serve ice cream but also have a unique variety of products to choose from. I highly recommend you visit if you’re in the area.
… moreEJ B
This is the best value for an ice cream scoop I’ve ever gotten. So many flavors to choose from and the ice cream is good. Very good! They know how to set you up for success. If you get a cone with 3 or more scoops on a really hot day they still give you a cup to manage it all.
… moreAleah Carlton
Yummy ice cream! But, the line is usually very long. It took 45 mins to order during softball season. We don’t go often anymore since there are quicker places around town, unfortunately. (But, we still stop by when the line is short!) I love that it’s local, but it needs more employees to keep up with demand. The employees there are super nice, though.
… moreMeg Smith
Lines can get pretty long, but it’s worth the wait. Read their sizing chart before ordering anything bigger than a small. Great food.
… moreJuliana Sowinski
This place is so great! I don’t have any pictures to post because we’re always having too much fun to think of it. The prices can’t be beat (3 adults ordered for 12.50), the quality and selection is incomparable, and the staff is always the nicest and sweetest.
Update: ownership has changed but it remains the same awesome place to go. Prices and selection just can’t be beat! And the staff are the best! Not pictured are the flavors of the day. Everyday has a new dole whip flavor and other specials.
… moreUpdate: ownership has changed but it remains the same awesome place to go. Prices and selection just can’t be beat! And the staff are the best! Not pictured are the flavors of the day. Everyday has a new dole whip flavor and other specials.