Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bayville Deli and Pizzeria – Facebook
Bayville Deli and Pizzeria is located at 261 Bayville Avenue. We are here to serve our community with a large selection of food options.
Order Bayville Deli & Pizzeria – Menu & Prices – Uber Eats
Use your Uber account to order delivery from Bayville Deli & Pizzeria in Bayville. Browse the menu, view popular items, and track your order.
Bayville Deli, 261 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709, US – MapQuest
Bayville Deli & Pizzeria is a local eatery in Bayville, NY that offers a delicious selection of pizza, sandwiches, and other dishes.
Reviews
saturnino garcia
I was driving around wasting time, and I saw their sign. I thought, “I’m in NY. I need pizza.” It was not your average NY slice. Very tasty. Spinach, fried chicken, and fresh chunks of tomato, and just a touch of cheese on a pizza crust.
… moreNew york Lacrosse
Been coming to this place any time i work in the area ONLY because there is no other place to grab quick food, and they take full advantage of it, but today I’ve had enough. First of all, the lady working the counter is always rude, and so is the dude serving day old pizza. And the prices are insane. I paid $16.80 for a chicken cutlet on a roll.
… moreKatia Barros
This is a good place to stop for a sandwich, or a slice of pizza. The parking is very limited with only a few spaces in front of the store.
… morem k
The food was great! Had the nicest conversation with the owners while waiting for our food. I not only enjoyed the food but the atmosphere as well. Highly recommend stopping in for a bite to eat
… moreJackie
Firstly, all the guys at the pizza counter are always nice, but the staff at the checkout counter definitely hate their job. I’ve been here multiple times wanting to like it but I didn’t like any of the sandwiches or pizzas. 🙁 The prepared cold salads and soup was good, though. Also the prices seem to fluctuate pretty often, so just keep that in mind.
… moreEvan Hughes
First visited 5 years ago on business from Georgia. The pizza is phenomenal, and the owner and staff really went above and beyond to both welcome me and educate me on the area.
A dozen visits later I’m still hooked, and I always stop in for a slice and a soda when I’m on Long Island. Five stars is not enough!
… moreA dozen visits later I’m still hooked, and I always stop in for a slice and a soda when I’m on Long Island. Five stars is not enough!
Ernst Georges
This cozy spot in Bayville offers a charming community atmosphere, often frequented by friendly older folks who enjoy cracking jokes. It adds to the experience! You can even play the New York Lottery while enjoying some pizza. However, if this place is closed, it might be best to head home or order from nearby options through food delivery apps.
… moreK K
Sandwiches are fine but they charge you extra for every single item you put on a deli sandwich. Lettuce, tomato, onions, etc are all additional charges resulting in a $20 hero. Rather go-to Talentis or Bayville Meat Market or even IGA.
… moreDaniel Shanle
Delicious pizza, friendly service and the best calzones you’ll ever have. The chicken parm calzone was superb! Will definitely repeat..Also, a nice variety of many different dishes on their menu. Highly recommended!
… moreMitchell Guadagni
I must come here about once a week for my regular order, an American Classic Pie with Extra Chicken and Extra Russian on the Side, and I am always the most happy and satisfied. I love the guys there, and will always be coming. Thanks as always, Mitchell.
… more