Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Bayside Supper Club is a family owned and run for 30+ years. We specialize in Friday fish fry every Friday, Sunday brunch, Thursday open menu and Mike’s famous prime rib & and other specials. Open most Saturdays with either Prime rib buffet or private patties (pls call or check FB). We cater to parties of 2 to 300. Birthday parties, anniversaries, weddings all of life’s special days can be done at Bayside. Will open the doors to bigger private parties any day of the week, business luncheon, funerals, and banquets just call to to reserve your day now. Ask for Mike. Check out our Facebook page for up to date hours and specials, updated weekly.
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bayside Supper Club | Travel Wisconsin
Bayside Supper Club, located on beautiful Beaver Dam Lake, offers a large bar room, a lakeview dining room and a wonderful banquet facility.
Bayside Supper Club – A Cozy Restaurant Experience in Beaver Dam
Discover Bayside Supper Club, a charming eatery in Beaver Dam, WI, offering a delightful buffet, fast service, and an extensive drink selection.
All u can eat buffet with prime rib – Facebook
All u can eat buffet with prime rib – at Bayside Supper Club. No … Wendy Mitchell beaver dam. 6mo · Kristin Mikrut. STFU I’m in beaver …
Reviews
Jeff P.
Tried two all you can eat buffets. The Friday fish and chicken buffet was very good. The fish was on the bland side and not crispy, chicken was very good, and all the food was always stocked and hot. The Sunday brunch was excellent! Great choices all around for anyone. Homemade desserts were very good. The homemade salads were all excellent! The best coleslaw. I even had some for dessert! Very friendly workers each time. Our favorite supper club so far!
… moreRyan Williamson
While passing through, I decided to stop for the fish fry buffet. The buffet-style service was convenient and the choices were great, but unfortunately the fish quality wasn’t as good as I had hoped. It became a bit dry and rubbery. The service was friendly, and the price was reasonable
… moreRonna Blackley
In order to review this time, I had to remove my last 5 star review from 2 years ago.
We just went on a Saturday recently and the prices have gone up considerably..it is now $26 per person for the buffet that includes the entire buffet and on Saturday it was a seafood one that included Prime Rib for what is included on the buffet the price is well worth it.
My issue is the flies..my husband killed 5 of them..we got there just before they opened and I mentioned to our waitress about them. This is something I definitely feel should be checked before opening..especially on those giant windows on the “porch” part of the dining area. I find flies to be pretty disgusting and when you are trying to enjoy a meal and not eat one….or constantly waiving them out of your face..it is NOT enjoyable.
… moreWe just went on a Saturday recently and the prices have gone up considerably..it is now $26 per person for the buffet that includes the entire buffet and on Saturday it was a seafood one that included Prime Rib for what is included on the buffet the price is well worth it.
My issue is the flies..my husband killed 5 of them..we got there just before they opened and I mentioned to our waitress about them. This is something I definitely feel should be checked before opening..especially on those giant windows on the “porch” part of the dining area. I find flies to be pretty disgusting and when you are trying to enjoy a meal and not eat one….or constantly waiving them out of your face..it is NOT enjoyable.
Elizabeth Elliott
Great food for Sunday brunch. Would have given it 5 stars except waitress did not ask if we needed anything else to drink when one of our glasses was empty.
… moreJennifer Schultz
Buffet was good and well kept. The hostess and waitress were so friendly and accommodating.
… moreGary Berghammer
We held our 50th anniversary party here recently and everything was amazing!! They made sure everything was the way we requested and they were friendly and accommodating. Our guests loved the food and the atmosphere. Thanks to Mike and his staff for making our special day so wonderful!!
… moreKathy Griffin
The perch on the buffet was dry/over cooked and the mashed potatoes were room temperature. The mixed drinks were sub standard. Over all, the quality of the food was disappointing
… moreDR JOHN PRYME
Great service, friendly atmosphere, hostess was extremely helpful and courteous. Food was exceptional. Highly recommend!
… morehddude63
My favorite place for Friday night fish. The buffet is top notch.
… moreKoenraad De Roo (BelgianAlien)
We tried the Sunday Brunch buffet…
In a nutshell: I’ve had better buffets at hotels with free breakfast. Small selection of options, and what was there was mediocre at best. The only thing I can say I actually enjoyed was the strawberry torte for dessert. I love a good brunch, unfortunately this was not it for us. The fact that there were only 2 other tables seated at noon on a Sunday should have been our first clue.
While the food disappointed, I have to say I can’t complain at all about our server. She did an excellent job.
… moreIn a nutshell: I’ve had better buffets at hotels with free breakfast. Small selection of options, and what was there was mediocre at best. The only thing I can say I actually enjoyed was the strawberry torte for dessert. I love a good brunch, unfortunately this was not it for us. The fact that there were only 2 other tables seated at noon on a Sunday should have been our first clue.
While the food disappointed, I have to say I can’t complain at all about our server. She did an excellent job.