Wide variety of seafood, fresh and frozen to be cooked at home as well as a wide variety of items to order for dining in or carry out. We are a small casual seafood place with awesome variety of seafood as well as meals. You can get seafood grilled, fried or sauteed. Meals come with choice of two sides and a sauce. Our menu is available on our website, however please remember we are happy to cook just about anything in the market. We do request advance notice for crab legs, lobster tails and live lobsters as we do not have a big kitchen. Call ahead orders are welcomed so we can have your order ready when you arrive.
My Review
This seafood joint is the bomb! I’ve sampled the salmon, the halibut, and flounder which didn’t disappoint! Their soups are equally delicious. There is an area to sit and dine in as well. Have yet to try the in house dining. Next time for sure will grab a bite.This is my go to place for fresh fish. Highly recommend checking it out.
… morekelleigh miller
Great local fresh fish stop, nothing fancy, just very tasty. They have such a good menu for takeout as well as in the cooler for take-home. I had the lobster roll, which was Lobster, not a bunch of filler, soft fresh bread roll and two sides. The staff was friendly and the decor was fun Bayside chic. If you want a delicious down to earth meal, this is a great place to stop.
… moreBrandon Saling
Amazing food and service! We enjoyed the fried oysters, lobster roll, fish sandwich, onion rings, and crab cake blt sandwich. All food & service exceeded our expectations! Can’t wait to go back for more crab cakes and try some other fish! There is nice small dining area and lots of cool decor… I highly recommend you stop here if you’re looking for quality seafood & service from friendly people!!
… moreCharlie Brown
All was good, if I could change anything it would be to reduce the breading on the oysters. To me they were so fresh (very light delicate taste) that the breading slightly covered thier taste. Even that being said. I will definitely be going back here again.
… moreDebbie Hostetler
I love how fresh the seafood is at Bay Lobsters Café & Fish Market. My family especially enjoys having them prepare tilapia deep fried with their special house seasoning. It’s also good grilled with Cajun seasoning when I’m in the mood for something a little different.
The staff is friendly and super helpful. They’re willing to prepare whatever seafood I purchase with whichever seasoning I want (house seasoning, Cajun grilled or blackened). Or I can purchase the seafood I want and prepare it myself. When I have them prepare a meal for me, I also enjoy getting their fried okra.
If you want fresh seafood, this is the place to go. It may be a little more expensive than in regular grocery stores in the area, but the freshness and the variety of selection makes it well worth the price!
… moreA Dilbeck
If you live in Ohio this is the freshest, wild caught/some farm raised seafood you are going to get without driving to the coast. The owner and workers are so nice and ensure you get what you’re looking for. Glad they are here!
… moreJeremiah Cronberger
This place is great. The kitchen was unfortunately closed due to unforeseen circumstances, but John did what he could to feed and accommodate my son and I. Food was great, restaurant/store was great, as was the conversation. Appreciated him feeding us, he truly went out of his way to do so, and if I’m ever back in the area will definitely drop in again.
… moremarrelam
My wife just finished eating some King Crab that she bought from you earlier today. She said it was the absolute best King Crab she’s ever had. So sweet and it didn’t need any butter. We went to Alaska a couple of weeks ago and spent $75/lb for King Crab in Juneau that wasn’t nearly as good as this, plus yours was $20/lb less!!
… moreBethany Lowe
If ur looking 4 some great seafood I would highly recommend Bay lobster , There Salmon & Fish is delicious . I get it with the house seasoning & The comeback sauce is yummy !!
… moreSteve Karl
The market area is clean and a good selection of sea food is displayed in the cases. The staff was friendly and helpful. Did not eat here this time but only used the market to buy two dozen live oysters. The reason for 3 stars. I was shorted two oysters and one was completely empty. At $1.50 an oyster, that totals $4.50 I did not receive.
… more